I don't care for this narrator at all, was a struggle to get through the book because of the inflections in her voice at the end if every sentence.
It took me a little while to get into this book, but after a few chapters I could barely put it down, even to go to sleep (my darling fiancé finally made me pause at 3am for a break to sleep, heh). I really liked most of the story, and I loved Judith's personality. Her compassion and determination was incredible, and I was so glad to see what she did for the women around her. And the romance was as frustrating as it was sweet - so silly how people see what they want to in others' motives. We are conditioned to expect the worst, even if we know better. But as exasperating as Iain's reticence was, and her constant worry, it all comes together in the best ways possible. Their passion was evident early on, and I enjoyed how the author carried it out. The bedroom scenes were erotic but tastefully done. But really, I almost liked a lot of the background plot, the social changes she advocated, and her new friends, better than the "courtship".
All that being said, my one major negative caveat is the narration. For female voices and narrative, Duerden is fine, even lovely as Judith and Francis Catherine... However, the moment a man opens his mouth to speak, I cringed. And there were so many men - the book was populated mostly by men- that at times her 'masculine' voices became hard to bear. Some sounded always gruff and angry or constipated, and some were just awful grumbly. Iain's voice bothered me the most - he came off sounding lecherous more often than not, when he was supposed to be considerate or tender... It was awful, but I liked the book so much I pushed through. I would have loved it otherwise, and I wish there was another recorded version I could have substituted. As it is, I'm not sure if I could revisit this audio, as much as I'd like to reread this book.
A good listener!
The story was sooooo predictable. I actually skipped forward through much of it (thank you, Audible, for that feature). So, two stars for the story (one of them is a pity star). As to the narration . . . have you ever heard a song that has basically four notes that just repeat, in the same sequence, over and over? Well that was this narrator's style. A REALLY annoying singsong of
da dadada daa,
da dadada daa,
da dadada daa,
da dadada daa,
One star for the narration, and that much only because I liked her Frances Catherine voice.
All business but contemporary fun!
I would really want to learn about Ian a bit more. I feel like there was so much more to his character that we didn't see. He almost acted as a secondary character.
Judith is a beautiful young English woman who has grown up with a verbally abusive uncle and indifferent mother. She stays loyal to her childhood friend who married in the Highlands and goes to her when she is about to give birth. She meets Ian McClean on the way, and throws him off with her sweet, tender manner yet strength to speak up and do the right thing, that he stands no chance :). The plot had many developments to keep you entertained until the very end. It was funny and sweet. My main issue with the story was that everything turned out too good to be true, in all respects, which took away the believability of the story.
A wonderful mix of history, romance, and drama. Beautifully written and performed perfectly. I'm looking forward to listening to the sequel.
I listened to the book in one day!! I love historical fiction. Interesting story line with romance, a little sex (not porn), and humor. I laughed quite a few times. The only thing I don't like about this book is that it doesn't continue. I like series that continue so you get to know the characters, but is a nice filler for series books I am waiting to come out.
I am not so sure what I would compare it to, but if you like Scots that are loyal and romance it is a nice filler to help pass time waiting for Diana Gabaldon to write her next book...but I will have to check out more of Jillian Garwood's books. Right now I am in the middle of Never Seduce a Scot by Maya Banks also pretty good this is one I might compare to this book.
I only liked her female and children voices. When she did the male voices I felt like I was listen to a person who speaks Italian try to speak English with a Scottish brogue. I could just be me, but in my minds eye I was not seeing Scots I was seeing Italians.
Yes, I did want a quick listen, but I thought it was a series of books about the same family. So I figure I could read more when I had a day here and a day there. I am a binge reader. I like listen when I have free time to scrapbook, so I like something quick when I do that.
I would definitely recommend this book! I am going to telling my friend about it today!
While my time wasn't wasted, this is not the best of Julie Garwood's books that I've ever read. The story actually started off pretty good, but began to fizzle in the middle. There was little build up to support the speed with which the characters fell in love, so their "love" seemed a tad rushed. I actually liked the main female character, Judith, but she had a very irritating habit of whispering almost everything she said. That got old very quickly. Her love interest, Iain, was likeable as well, but neither really came to life. However, it was decent enough that I wanted to finish it rather than just put it aside.
The most interesting aspect of this story was the unfolding of the "secret". The least interesting was how it was revealed and dealt with. I expected more drama than what was delivered.
Her performance was fine. I can't think of anything I would want changed.
No way. There's not enough of a good story there to keep a viewer's interest in a movie or TV series.
While I won't say the credit spent on the book was a waste, I will say, if you're looking for a lot of excitement and a compelling love story, start with something else first. Save this book for when you've plowed through the other great books in your stack and need something to pass the time.