No -- the narrator's portrayal of the protagonist as a young woman is incredibly annoying, and sooooo slow. I almost quit. But the narration improves and the story is solid.
I really enjoyed learning more about the history.
Average, not stellar. The story was fine, but I think I was emotionally turned off. I headed into it without much knowledge of the Lindberghs other than that he was a pilot, she was a feminist and their baby was kidnapped. This book did a good job filling in the gaps - but I found it hard to reconcile this version of Anne Morrow Lindbergh with the feminist - she seemed to tolerate a lot of crap and dish out a lot of self-pity. I know it was fictionalized, but she wasn't a very inspiring or sympathetic character, and Charles seemed like a Grade-A douche.
Don't get me wrong - it's a quick listen and a fun way to fill your gaps about the LIndbergh lore, but it's hard to find a single character you actually like.
It made me want to kick everyone... Anne needed to grow a set and Charles needed to have his set removed.
What a read! I had such mixed emotions reading this book. Most of the time I just wanted shake Anne Lindbergh for not standing up for herself. But then I had to step back and look at the time and society and she did what every good wife did back then ... she kept persevering to make everything seem wonderful to the world in spite of what she was feeling internally. In today's world (in America), her options would be wide open. Anne Lindbergh was a smart woman who had the capacity to love beyond all things. And she did that with a passion. My heart broke with the kidnapping of her child and the fact that she had to grieve privately for her little son. This was my first time reading Melanie Benjamin and I enjoyed the way she told the story. She kept it interesting yet made the reader wonder what was coming next. I can't say I enjoyed the story, but I enjoyed the way the author revealed it and grabbed my attention. Kudos to Ms. Benjamin.
I think I would like to read the book rather than listen again. I felt that the narrator's voice was "too old" for the chapters that portrayed Ann in her younger years. It took away from the feeling of young love, infatuation, and love. I think the content of the book might "read" differently.
Ann - of course. I read the excellent bio of Charles Lindbergh by Scott Berg so got the "male" perspective. She has always intrigued me.
Yes with the exception of the above criticism.
Listening - made me want to reread/listen to "Gift from the Sea"
The narrator was slow, the text gave too many insignificant details. I think this was noted in other reviews. I've made it to their second meeting. Don't know if I can take much more.
Interesting to learn about Charles Lindberg from another, personal perspective. I was ready to strangle his wife in the end - she is very predictable and that grows old. Predictable, but her actions are fully consistent with a certain personality type - so it rang true. The book should have been shortened to keep it a bit more punchy.
teacher & book lover
Becoming a Stronger Woman
This book is very interesting. My book club really liked it, and I suggest it for other book clubs as well. It will allow for good discussions about what makes a woman strong.
The narrators voice was so perfect for this story. Plus the story itself, wow, I never knew anything about Ann before now. The story was told in a most engaging and empathetic manner, I absolutely loved it!!
This has been one of the summer's most interesting reads or "listens" if you prefer. A wonderful look into a woman's role as wife, mother and companion of a "headliner" husband and her possible reactions to the life it demanded.
I will certainly seek out other books by this author and narrator.