I love how real Harry Bosch feels. When I am not listening to the book, I miss him. Connolly has developed this character for 20 years. I find myself writing down and following up on the jazz recommendations from every Bosch novel. I spend some time in LA every year and enjoy visiting landmarks and restaurants mentioned in these novels.
Harry Bosch because he feels so real and the world he inhabits is authentic.
No extreme reaction. Just the comfort of visiting with an old friend.
Haters are going to hate! This book is excellent and I've enjoyed it thoroughly.
Like others, I was sorely disappointed to find a new and unfamiliar narrator for the 18th book in the Harry Bosch series. Why has Len Cariou been replaced? Some inconceivable whim on the part of the author? A contract dispute about money? Please say it isn't so. At first, I agreed with other reviewers who found the narrator flat and uninspired. But as the reading proceeded, and I became used to this new voice, the story took hold and I enjoyed it thoroughly. Connelly has written another excellent book. The narrator does a credible job. Harry Bosch - the hesitant lover, the bumbling but well-meaning father, the brilliant, driven detective - soldiers on in his waning years. Still, I wish Len Cariou was carrying us forward.
Never read the print version, Love the audio book.Time on the road allows me finish these and I love the story
Got to go with Harry and his daughter they have a relationship that is honest and each has respect for the other
The end with the crash when Harry almost lost his cool but he regained control
Like the book Black Box Clue
Love Harry and I realize there can't be many more but please do as many as you can Mr Connelly we love them
All of my Harry Bosch experience with Michael Connelly has been with audio and this most recent edition/addition to the series is a quality product from both the story and the performance.
It was a bit eerie to start the book in the LA Riots after just listening to some real-life accounts of chaos in the streets of Syria and then there is the jump to 2012 when the cold case begins to unthaw. Bosch is the central character and Connelly builds the story around his long-time detective friend while giving us an increasing view of the values and experience that may eventually drive his daughter Madeline into law enforcement. The innocence of Maddy combined with the persistence of the 1992 victim were an interesting bridge in this entertaining novel.
The history for the plot was quick and well developed. The police work that helped move this story forward is interesting and methodical as well as credible -- which is a little more than you can say about the unusual happenings at the end. Connelly took some shortcuts as he resolved this story and it is not easy to tell if they were lack of imagination or inability to fight through the rules of this particular genre. The ending worked to get us through the story but the lack of reasoning for the IA detective's presence just doesn't sit that well.
But, don't let the nitpicking keep you from an entertaining 12 hours.
"Well, it is in my policy!" may be a quote I will work into my life -- wonder how that will go over with some students?
The narration was not right for Harry. Edgar, his partner has no nuance to his voice. If Dick Hill was reading this I would try and finish. Major disappointment for a big Harry Bosch fan.
What a waste of a credit.
This book is not Audible worthy. I will take Connelly off my preorder list. What was I thinking.
Reader totally destroys the story and the character. I have loved
Harry for several years but this book is terrible and the main problem
is this reader.
I finished this book in only a couple of days. Couldn't stop!
The only bad thing about this book is that I have to wait a whole year for the next one.
Was it the narrator, maybe. Was it the writer, maybe. Can't put my finger on it but Harry just wasn't the same.
I am actually writing my first negative review after being an audible member for 4 years. Audible shouldn't have even put this book up, until they had a decent narrator. If I was Michael Connelly, I would be irate. He ruined the book. If I could return it, I would.
I have listened to all the Harry Bosch books and will probably listen to the next one. However, the only thing that would have redeemed this installment would have been if Harry realized that he was really loosing it and retired at the end. First of all, everything the reader needs to know to solve the crime is revealed by the end of the first chapter. Unfortunately it is also revealed to Harry who takes until Book Two to put it all together.In addition, despite constantly feeling guilty about neglecting his daughter, Harry needlessly puts himself in a position to make her an orphan.Finally, as others have said the narrator was sub par. He read, rather than performed the book. In addition despite the book being written by a Californian and taking place in California the narrator consistently mispronounced Manteca, calling it Man Tek A, rather than Man Teek A. Annoying!