Only my previous loyalty to Harry and Michael Connelly got me through this. It was very disjointed and did not offer the excitement that Connelly's books usually offer.
As a Bosch fan, I always enjoy Harry Bosch and supporting characters. But in this book he is operating more on his own, and there wasn't enough of the relationships- Hannah, Maddie and his partner very all superficial.
A little less than average.
Yes, the new narrator was fine.
If you are a real Bosch fan get it, but it's not the best in the series.
Excellent story, excellent reader. Harry solves a 20 year old murder in his typical build the momentum off a small lead style. What is really nice is human side you see in him in his interactions with his daughter. Great mystery,
Nararator does a wonderful job. Overall I think the best combination of story and reader in the series.
I love Conelly and Bosch, but I hesitated to purchase this one based on the reviews, particularly the new narrator....but glad I did.....loved it.
I have been a Harry Bosch listener for several years and downloaded this book as soon as it was available. I couldn't believe they changed the narrator, and what was worse, this narrator was very poor. I finished the book with no pleasure, I won't buy another with this narrator.
Not Connelly's best but still a pretty good listen. It starts slow but gets rolling pretty well if you stick with it. I read a lot of negative comments about the narrator. I think he did a fine job. Pretty similar to Len Cariou (who I like very much) truth be told. The story is a police procedural and the narrator has a no-nonsense style that fits the story quite well. I am making a point of saying this because although I have read every single one of Connelly's other books, I almost skipped this one due to the horrific comments about the narrator. Glad I didn't.
Michael Connelly continues to hone his craft. I must admit that I guessed the primary elements of the plot early (getting only the actual act and motives for the cover-up off in their detail.) However, Connelly's telling of the story of "The Black Box" still unwound in a way that gave flesh and vigor to the characters and kept the player rolling in two five+ hour sessions. I appreciate Connelly's good sense to leave the details of violence and inhumanity to imagination. Even the final twist shows how our minds often engage in "making things up" that impel even our fictional selves to draw conclusions that lead us to engage in dangerous behavior.
I enjoyed listening to Harry Bosch continue on with his investigations.
The plot kept me interested. I was not bored and did not think it was slow paced.
No. I think that some of the other reviews of this new narrator are not fair. I almost did not listen to the book because of their wrong negative comments on the narration. I am glad that I did not heed their advice.
The narration was just fine maybe he was not what you were used to but he did a good job.
Story continues to grow Harry as an individual. If you haven't read/listened to all the others, the book may not seem as good to you. It does have the usual angles--Harry's relationships with his partner, his daughter and others in his life, some new, some returnees. It's about his not so great relationship with the power structure. Perhaps mostly it is pretty much like all the rest of the series in that it is about how Harry deals with Harry. Yes, Harry goes of the reservation again.
The sequence of the events in the story and while those events are pretty much "basic Harry" the variations on the theme were good
The end sequence
No, but to me, none are that way because I like having the opportunity to "drop in on" characters in books over a period of time--after work, on a trip, on a day off...
The whining over the narrator in the early reviews caused me to begin the book with a negative attitude, that's why the "C'mon man!!" title for this review. After about a chapter, I quit trying to find fault with Michael McConnohie and enjoyed the book. When you throw in the Mickey Haller books, by my count, 6 people have brought Harry to life. Did I like some better than others? Yeah. Did any of them ruin the book for me? No!! As an individual, Harry seems to come to life on his own. Do I have a favorite narrator? Perhaps Dick Hill, but I suspect that if McConnohie had read all of 'em, I would have liked the series just as much as I do and would have bought all of 'em just as I have.
So, y'all quit whining and enjoy your visit with Harry.
The reader -he brought nothing to make this story keep your attention.
No comparison. Harry Bosch has always been interesting and exciting. This Harry just seemed old and tired.
Yes although it would not keep my attention a second time unlike previous books in the series. I have listened to most of those twice.