First of all, please don't take my 3-star rating as a negative. This was an EXCELLENT book. An incredible and eye-opening view into the life of a soldier as well as the real story of what's going on in Afghanistan. I have much respect for our soldiers, but serious questions about the military leadership. In their defense, there is an ingrained culture where questions aren't asked and top brass is always right. It's very difficult to change that. But, as this book points out, that culture is causing our military and our country hundreds of lives and billions of dollars. Politics have taken over and it's quite frightening. What's even worse is how, after giving their lives to keep us safe, our soldiers are literally dismissed when they come home.
So why the 3 stars? Well for one, this is a long book describing battle after battle. For some it might be slow and boring, for others quite upsetting and for others still it can be exciting and suspenseful. Since we know what happens in the end, you really have to commit to the story. But what you're actually doing is committing to hear the soldiers' stories. If we don't listen to them, who will?
Jake Tapper rocks. Good performance. Great telling of a tale that needs to be told. Thanks to those on the sharp end and thanks to Tapper for getting their story out.
Live life smell the roses and rejoice.
The book drew you in by letting you know who the soldiers were and the made you cry that so many brave and incredible men died for our country.
Any Historical war book. First book on Afghanistan that I have heard about.
Heartbreak valley for the Brave Americans of Outpost Keating.
If you have loved ones going to Afghanistan I would listen upon their return this will just heighten the worry.
Yes, but difficult. This is a book which needs much cross-referencing to fully understand location and military lingo.
The truthfulness of it.
Exacting. Concise. Emotionless.
Yes. However, due to the cross-referencing necessary for a full understanding, this book would be more comprehensible if read from the written form, with a map and index of terms readily available.
The realistic rendering of the story.Those that have been in an all out firefight will recognize it and those that haven't been, might understand what it's like.
NO, but he's now at the top of my list
Fantastic book - perfect blend of historical detail and 1st person perspective. Performed in a way that conveyed the seriousness of the subject but still brought to life the individual soldiers portrayed. Mostly it's a perfect reason to make sure I thank a veteran.
This book is a must read for any one. I was in the military and things like this happen more often than you would think. It is not always the smartest person that makes the decisions.They should have found out who planed to put the outpost in that valley and court marshalled him. to loose all those men for nothing, a lot like Viet Nam. What a waste.
It is so sad to read of such brave young men sent off to fight a senseless war in a senseless place and for so many to lose their life and for what, why? These solders are true hero's who were put in the line of fire on an outpost that served no purpose without the support from the generals who sent them there. The writing is excellent as well is the narration. A must read and more importantly a reminder to honor those who are sent to serve under fire.
write my first review
The story sheds light on the poor planning of the military. The story is all over the place with way to many characters to follow
Great listen and narrator! The amazing courage and drive of our American soldiers in places that the odds are completely against you every single day.