The story is enormous. It eclipses virtually every other work in the high fantasy genera.
The diverse cast of characters yields an atmosphere unlike any other book I have ever read.
These characters could not be better performed. Ralph Lister's style, pace, and huge library of voices is truly incredible.
If you have any love for high fantasy, just click buy.
Yes, only for a friend looking for a book to listen to but not someone who wanted a book with a good story.
Yes, but after this one I would only gravitate towards his books if I just wanted something to listen to in the car.
Ralph Lister's performance was solid and he portrayed all the characters well. He ability to change from Demi-God to lowly farm hand was impressive.
Yes but only because the story took so long to come together. The book starts in the middle almost, dropping you in the middle of a very integral conflict. Making you piece together puzzle of what happened. I was forced to listen twice to a few chapters after the fact to make sure I did not miss a characters name or position. It may be reader error but I am not a fan of a book where you are forced to deal with a lack of meaningful prologue.
The series is supposed to be better after the first book because the characters continue. You learn to enjoy the Captain and Whiskey Jack but it takes the book. Which is probably how they would be in real life: you don't enjoy their company but then you start to appreciate the gruff.
It's as good as all the positive reviews suggest.
And unlike another remarkably skilled fantasy author, Steven Erikson has completed his grand saga. You actually get to see how it ends... how the author penned the final page.. not how HBO finished it because the author got fat, rich, lazy, and had a heart attack.
Disappointment and boredome
Maybe too many characters introduced...maybe I couldn't keep up...maybe its as simple as I couldn't get interested.
Sci fi and fantasy is where I live. I read not to escape , but to enjoy the thoughts and dreams of my fellow Earthlings and Others. Peace !
yes he is a good storyteller
his many characters held up even through the long hours of reading
yes the whole series was good just a little too busy with the number of characters
After reading Blood Song and realizing that the release date is over 12 months away I read about Steven Erickson's series on the Malazan Empire. Most of the reviews were universally good so I spent the $ 24.95.
I struggled through about 4 hours of the first book- one character after another until I lost count- with absolutely NO character development. NONE. Very little scenery of other descriptives - Erickson is trying to copy Black Company (a favorite of mine) with none of the humorous sarcasm and funny asides. The world is intricate for sure- intricately BORING- after a while I realized I was PRAYING for this book to end - HOPING beyond hope that one of the weird Gods of the Erickson's imagination (that I neither cared about or understood) would DESTROY the entire world, universe and everything in it and relieve me of the tedium of listening to his audio anvil I spend $ 24 bucks on. Really Erickson owes me $ 24!!!
Yes his world is intricate- and intricately b o r i n g!!! despite the B o r i n g none stop action- but none of the characters are developed, I could not keep track of what in the hell they were doing and who they were- and even if I could have - I really did not want to since they barely existed for me.
Okay if you like fireballs and demons and blood- this is your book. But if you want stories, characters that are human (0r hell I would take an alien with a personality) then STOP and save you $$$.
Much better choices abound: from Red Country (Joe Abercrombie) to Prince of Thorns Series (by Mark Lawrence) to Blood Song by Anthony Ryan to the old standby Brandon Sanderson. Scott Lynch "Lies of Lochlomara" blows this away. Each is different but by God they write decent stories. I am NOT the agents of these guys nor in any way associated with them- other than a fan who appreciates the craft these guys exhibit.
I read later that this novel grew out of a Dungeons and Dragons game in 1982. I should have guessed because it has the literary content and meaning of something 14 year olds pushing minature figures around a table and rolling strange dice about. But most DMs don't charge money (or they did not the last time I changed D&D in 1978)
Four thumbs down- and where is my $ 25 bucks!!!???? Really I feel like my pocket has been picked!!!!! This book should come with a warning on it!
For the life of me I cannot understand how this guy has sold a book much less won all these awards. I did read that one either loves this stuff or Hates it. Count me as the latter as you might guess.
Ralph Lister does a very good job as a narrator - but he can no more rescue this junk heap of a book than Sauron could rescue Saruman.
I haven't read the books and wanted to experience the story for the first time audibly. I cannot get past the first few chapters. The narrator is so overpowering that my mind keeps cringing and I have to rewind and so on.
Is it worth it? Look, the author doesn't have to be as awesome as Joe Abercrobies and Brandon Sanderson's narrators but I feel like I'm listing to Summer Stock in Nantucket. The flow is wrong, the voices are wrong, the diction and enunciation is all wrong. Put it in German and it may be a little worse but I can't get through it as is.
Can somebody tell me it gets better?
Say something about yourself!
I read many of the reviews of "Gardens Of the Moon"before I purchased it .The one comment I remember is that this is not a book you can listen to casually while driving around.
I agree and I tried but its definitely not one of my favorites.To give you and idea .............
I loved and highly recommend........"The Lord Of The Rings"Trilogy and George R.R.Martin's "World of Fire and Ice" series.
If you are really into magic,sorcery ,wormholes etc,you will probably love Gardens of the Moon.
But I found myself not caring for the characters and getting lost in the plot even though I continually replayed chapters to try and understand things better.
You say....well ....the Lord of the Rings is full of magic.
It is, but somehow it's better
As lengthy as the Rings is , it is never confusing or boring.
I really wanted to like this book because I was hoping to go through the series, but I just can't do it. Though there were pockets of brilliance, and characters that I could almost sink my teeth into, the writer just wouldn't let me. Right when I would get 'this close' to really liking a character, he would go off on another part of this very convoluted story and leave me hanging.
The one aspect that readers might like is the fog around which side (out of many) was 'good' and which was 'evil,' This was one of the pockets of brilliance I spoke of earlier.
'I think hell’s a fable.' 'Ay,' says Mephistopheles, 'think so still, till experience change thy mind
I was looking for a series that compared to GoT, Wheel of Time, or at least The Name of the Wind; but I think this book fell well short.