Yes, only for a friend looking for a book to listen to but not someone who wanted a book with a good story.
Yes, but after this one I would only gravitate towards his books if I just wanted something to listen to in the car.
Ralph Lister's performance was solid and he portrayed all the characters well. He ability to change from Demi-God to lowly farm hand was impressive.
Yes but only because the story took so long to come together. The book starts in the middle almost, dropping you in the middle of a very integral conflict. Making you piece together puzzle of what happened. I was forced to listen twice to a few chapters after the fact to make sure I did not miss a characters name or position. It may be reader error but I am not a fan of a book where you are forced to deal with a lack of meaningful prologue.
The series is supposed to be better after the first book because the characters continue. You learn to enjoy the Captain and Whiskey Jack but it takes the book. Which is probably how they would be in real life: you don't enjoy their company but then you start to appreciate the gruff.
Erikson starts his stories as if you already know the characters and the world they live in. There is no context setting and you spend the first third of the book just trying to figure out what is going on and who is who. It is really not until you are half way through the story that you can really follow all of the characters and you begin to see how the story is coming together. You would think that would make for a bad review, but the story is absolutely brilliant. Events follow one after another in an unpredictable but very realistic manner. The world he creates is immense. And as you approach the end of the book you are left to wonder how he could have written such a brilliant story. It’s dark, it’s realistic, it’s funny….it is a great fantasy read!
This series is characterized by superior writing, excellent plot and character building, and consistently exuberant world-building. Ralph Lister performs in a professional manner that extracts simplicity and emotionality from complex story-telling. I sincerely hope Audible releases the remainder of this series that regularly appears on top-ten lists of Fantasy/Sci-Fi series.
Sci fi and fantasy are where i live
yes he is a good storyteller
his many characters held up even through the long hours of reading
yes the whole series was good just a little too busy with the number of characters
1. Brutal - The world the Malazans novels is brutal and hard, there is no black and white here, everybody is a moral shade of gray. 2. Harsh - Conquering armies squashing resistance, coups, set-ups, the world of the Malazans is a no holds barred fistfight of human and non-human races all vying for dominance. 3. Unforgiving - No character is guaranteed a free ride to glory in this world. Every man for himself in a battle royal of human and non-human political maneuvering and warfare.
I liked Ralph Lister but I only gave him 4 stars for this book. I felt he had a few characters a little bit off from what I imagined them (I had read six of the books before). I will say that he improves these characters along with adding a few new voice in Book 2 and by Book 3 he is a slam dunk 5 star performer. Book 3 is one of the best performed book I've ever heard. That is why I am saddened that he is not scheduled to do the rest of the series. For those who know who Kruppe is, Lister completely nails his character and had me laughing aloud continually during his parts.
The Malazan series is not an easy read. You are dropped right into a world in a specific time in its history with no knowledge of how the magic system works, who all the players are, who the non-humanoid creatures are, etc. It takes a while to get the hang of what is going on, but once you do Gardens of the Moon is a tale well worth waiting to see played out. Interestingly, I had read 6 of the 10 books previously and had struggled with some of them. But, I thought Gardens of the Moon as well as Book 2 and Book 3 read in audiobook format much smoother. The jumps between characters and even continents really read well through the audio, much smoother and clearer than what I remember when actually reading them. If you like high/epic type fantasy and aren't afraid of a harsh, unforgiving and sometimes brutal world of injustice and indifference then the world of the Malazans is a worthwhile investment.
Not by the narrator for sure
Listen to the Blade Itself series again because this was boring and confusing.
Never finish the book it was confusing and slow.
I really wanted to like this book because I was hoping to go through the series, but I just can't do it. Though there were pockets of brilliance, and characters that I could almost sink my teeth into, the writer just wouldn't let me. Right when I would get 'this close' to really liking a character, he would go off on another part of this very convoluted story and leave me hanging.
The one aspect that readers might like is the fog around which side (out of many) was 'good' and which was 'evil,' This was one of the pockets of brilliance I spoke of earlier.
Narrator kept on using these nasal voices that were consistently annoying. The way he portrays the voices has no correlation to how people speak in reality. It was so annoying that I found it hard to actually focus on the story. The author also made a choice to pick thoroughly confusing names for his characters. This when combined with the annoying reading made it hard to follow the plot almost a full 4 hours into the reading. After a total of 4 hours of listening I was barely getting a vague sense of differentiating the characters in the book. Maybe it's just me, but I am not happy with this book so far and I am finding it rather hard to continue listening to it.
Nothing, I bought the book based on other reviews everyone seemed so excited about the series available. I've listened for two hours and still don't get it. I'm giving up and moving on wished I had not wasted my credit.
Not sure but not this series. I may listed to the Dresden series again.
Nothing against the performance the book is just not to my liking it's slow and confusing can't find the story line.
The story is good if you can understand what is going on however it seems to skip around and follows too many characters without piecing them together. All in all if you have the time to listen and re listen to the book a few times it is a good story the reader was very good i have the book in paper form as well and it is also hard to follow.
It was good and it leads you to the next book in the series
he give the characters depth and is very creative with distinguishing each character
it would make a good series but not a movie it has too many different roles and i am unsure who to put in what role.