I am a structural engineer. I don't really like fantasy. My first book was Atlas Shrugged, which was great. I can't wait for the 2nd movie.
I don't think anything could have made this book better. It is boring and trite. I am surprised that JK has so many references to sex.
Yes, I don't like or understand British idioms.
I don't know, except that having a British narrator certainly is appropriate, if you understand the Kings English, and all of it's quirky phrases
The darkness of the book.
She must have growwn up in poverty and the dark part of the world to write so vividly about the class of people
No, most of my friends dont want to hear swearing.
Yes, I do like her writting style. But this one was too much "adult language" for me. Didnt get past chapter three before I turned it off.
It might be if you dont mind swearing. I was wondering where the story was going to go. And it peeked my interest. But stopped listening after the F word was ringing in my ears. Maybe the swearing stopped after that?
I dont enjoy swearing. I wish you could have ratings for audio books like movies. I think J.K. Rowling was trying to prove she could appeal to an adult audience. She missed the fact that there are many of us who appreciate a more mature book without all the language of real life.
I would not recommend this book since the story was so unfocused and many of the characters were either unbelievable repulsive or ineffectual sadsacks.
I'd give her another try. the Harry Potter books were very enjoyable.
The coda was very effective and makes you wonder where that magic was throughout the rest of the book.
Marginally. I considered stopping a number of times but plowed through to the end.
JK has proven her ability to write beyond Harry Potter--but this book was tough to keep reading because of its difficult and dark story. I suppose we need to know that there are people like Crystal Weedon and her family, but why couldn't there have been at least one mostly good character (besides a dead guy)?!
I did finish the book, and even though it is thoroughly depressing, I was satisfied and felt closure at the end. I am now searching for something light and humorous to follow this up with, though!!
A better story, even one likable character.
Truth be told, maybe my expectations were too high. I knew not to expect any magic but I thought I'd at least get pulled in to a compelling story. Bummer.
I found it extremely difficult to stay awake while listening to this book. The various stories making up the novel seem disorganized, the transitions jarring and the perspectives muddled. The overall impression I get is a sort of Jackson Pollock semi-random arrangement of subplots. At various points I thought I had accidentally skipped some vital chapter as I was lost in a muddle of subplots and digressions. I frequently found myself questioning whether I was simply a Philistine incapable of appreciating what was probably a wonderful book by a great author. At some points I found myself crying out phrases like, "what dreadful, tedious drivel!" Listening to some passages was so painfully boring that I felt obligated to write this review to reduce the potential for others having to suffer through it.
I have no idea what the genre of this book is. It seems to be a genre like, "bland drama about the tedious lives British suburbia." I would not willingly subject myself to another book similar to this, but I'm not sure that genre is the culprit.
I would not actively avoid a book on the basis that Hollander narrated it. I would also not select out a book because he read it. His reading was uninspired and workman-like, but not bad. I sympathize with him in that he had to narrate this book.
Rowling has several clever sentences and a few interesting character descriptions. I appreciated that she was willing to use explicit descriptions and vulgar language when appropriate. I do not believe the author intended to create such a painfully dull book.
I like J. K. Rowling, I enjoyed the Harry Potter series, I enjoy a wide variety of fiction and non-fiction books. I did not enjoy this book. The experience of listening to this book was not pleasant and was at times painful and tedious.
I was stoked to read what JK would provide to an adult audience, but I was bored with the story and the characters did not pull me in. I just didn't get the point/theme of the story.
good, emotional, engaging
JK character development was well done & maybe based on personal experience. Usually there are good and bad persons in a story that balance each other but I found the balance really very negative. Expectations were a positive read (After Harry) but found this book a tragedy.
Narrator did a good job of reading. Continued to that end of the book because it was an audible, I would have put the book down if I needed the engergy to read.
The book kept my attention but it was hardly a "can't put it down" audiobook for me. The writing was very good and I found the characters interesting but somehow something was just lacking. Loved the narrator - I am a sucker for British accents.