This book is tedious with a bunch of short stories patched together. The reader's voice is just odd. I quit about 1/4 of the way through it.
I seemed very disjointed. I'm not sure the rape was the primary focus ... she seemed to lose track of what she was talking about.
Strange accent, strange cadence ...
I was hopeful that I would be drawn into this book. Unfortunately, the narration is awful, the pace of the plot slow and the characters forgettable. I'm not going to finish listening and write this one off to "They can't all be good." Blech.
I've listened to hundreds of books and this is by far the worst narrated book yet. The story was good in a few parts; the parts that related to the mother and what happened to her. The rest is just garbage. Very disappointed in this one. Recommend you spend your money elsewhere.
I fell for it. I thought the story slogged along and this was one of the worst narrators ever. So many times, I had inserted a mental period only to discover that it was a mistimed, inappropriate pause. The only reason I finished was I didn't have the good sense to download a backup for my roadtrip. Thumbs down!
It's now been several months since I listened to The Round House with Gary Farmer as the narrator. The reading fit the book so well, that the two together - story and performance - make this something of importance.
The story has real characters caught in a terrible situation. Their reactions are perfectly real. The writing is insightful. The reading is wonderful. Having not grown up in the Northeast, it was a pleasure to have a slower story narration with the realistic intonation and accents of the characters. Since this book hinges on emotions, such a realistic reading was quite necessary and appreciated. I think there were a couple of mistakes, but nothing took away from the exploration of the character's thoughts, feelings and actions.
I don't think this book would have had the same impact on me if I had read it myself. That's saying something. With every other book through Audible, I have listened for convenience. That's what I expected for this book. However, that's not what I got. This is the only book after about a year on Audible (and purchased several beyond the ones that come with the subscription) with which the performance enhanced the story beyond expectation. I recommend listening to this version rather than purchasing the book and reading it yourself. If you want someone to read through a story quickly, almost like speed reading, then don't get this. If you want the true feel of the author's words, then purchase this and listen. You will not be disappointed.
I enjoyed this mystery. The story is deep, there are some great characters and twists I did not expect. I love Gary Farmer's narration--he's the reason I decided to buy the audio book. Other reviewers mention asides that threw them off, but I like them and feel they add to the richness of the material. Except for a couple of scenes where my attention faltered, I was riveted. The pace of the story--or at least the poem-like prose and rhythm--is very effective and lovely. It reminds me of other books or stories I've read, particularly by other Native writers. I recommend this audio book.
I'd recommend the novel, but not the audiobook.
Very interesting take on Native American culture intertwined with an intriguing mystery story.
The worst narration I've encountered on Audible. Virtually no differentiation between characters, frequent emphasis on the wrong words within sentences.
I can't wait to read another Louise Erdrich book. Right up there with Sherman Alexie, Thomas King, and Tony Hillerman.