I enjoyed this book and was immediately engaged by the narrator. I felt the voice she used invited sympathy with the main character, Claire. The writing drew me in to the story and I found it an easy listen.
Interesting story about the art world and art forgery. The plot is cleverly built around a real historical figure (Isabella Stuart Gardner) and the unsolved theft in 1990 of a number of paintings from the museum in Boston that bears her name.
I would have given it 5 stars except for the fact that a number of phrases, sayings and other things are repeated in more than one place in the book. It's kind of like the author forgot that this had already been said and no editor picked it up. I'd say this happened about five times, which I found disconcerting.
Otherwise, a great read that grabbed my interest from the start!
The Art Forger is a creative, well paced mystery. I found myself listening at every free moment to hear the next turn in the story. The listener is kept on their toes with twists and turns that build anticipation.
The narration is great. The reader gives a compelling performance, riding the wave of emotion the story embodies. Character narration is differentiated nicely with subtle changes in tone and cadence rather than oddly performed caricatured voices as in some audio books.
Overall this is a great book for the mystery lover. I'd recommend it to friends...
Very well researched both in terms of art history and of the technique/skill of oil painting. I have always been a huge fan of Edgar Degas. In fact, seeing his show at the metropolitan museum of art in the late 80's was for me a life changing for a girl of 15 which is how old I was at the time. Besides being a terrific book with a great plot, the skill in which the writer describes Degas's work, and Claire's experience in re-producing the masters painting, is not only well researched but very moving, especially of you understand painting.
Claire, of course! A true heroine, with enough humility and honesty about herself and the art world to understand that beauty is indeed in the eye of the beholder, and that in the world of high end fine art, the world only sees what it wants to see.
No. Sometimes I felt the reader sounded a bit too "weepy" or too emotional. Overall, she is a very good performer.
Isabella Stewart Gardner. Of course!!!M oh to know what she knew...
If you love intelligent thrillers & mysteries AND art, this is your book!
Learning about the "art" of art forgery and the commercial side of the art world was interesting, but the story was based on an "idiot plot" : no reasonable thinking person would have gotten him/herself in such a situation! I know that art forgers do exist and have their reasons, but I do not find them to be sympathetic. I continued listening to learn how the author would tie up the loose ends and vindicate her protagonist, which I knew she would do. The main character seemed likeable, but for a supposedly smart and strong-willed woman, was easily manipulated by men and lied too easily for her own good. By the end of the novel, I didn't understand how she had any friends or supporters. The story was so implausible, I ended up feeling cheated of my 10 hours.
Learning about art forgery, and the mystery of the fake Degas.
Men were irritating. She did well with the main (female) character's voice, but the men all were depicted in a deep-throated husky voice.
Yes and no. I could have spent more time in the world of the art world, less in the head of the main character, who was meant to be a heroine, but was really an unsympathetic character to anyone who cares about art and authenticity.
Dialogue was thin. Supposedly smart creative people should be much wittier.
I really enjoyed this book. It took me awhile to figure out the mystery and it had a satisfying conclusion. It did drag a bit in the middle and I felt like some things were just filler. The narrator was excellent. A very enjoyable experience!
Ears picking up the slack so my eyes can work.
Take note that I’m barely half through this book right now. Still, I feel like talking about the things that bug me and the things that work. I love the art aspects of the story. What the writer does integrating process of art and the culture of artists into a commercial novel is pretty impressive. I don’t think it all entirely works, but it mostly does.
The shortcomings, I feel, have mostly to do with the main character. She doesn’t exist. She’s impossible. There are too many contradictions. By that I mean the flaws and perfections don’t really make sense when all gelled together in the story. There’s a missing piece to her character the author hasn’t included that make it all make sense, which I believe is that she is somewhat of a groupie and a shallow art chick.
A muse who aspired to a greater talent and who should have come short, but the commercial aspirations of the story makes her both a mimic (which works for the story) but also THE GREATEST MODERN PAINTER SINCE PICASSO. What???? haha.
That’s crazy. Unlikely. A mimic wouldn’t do so well keeping her own voice out of the work if she were also a genuine artist (as opposed to craftsman). Still, it’s an impressive story. I’m enjoying it. However, yeah, the narrator is completely wrong. The voice reminds me of a Jem cartoon or Ariel from the Little Mermaid. Her default emotion seems to be wistfulness. She seems to try really hard to be liked and it doesn’t work. Some of the line readings are laughable. Character is read as ‘just a regular gal’ whereas I think she’d be more self serious and FOCUSED. The way she portrays men is seriously bad. They’re all slyly suggestive and creepy. Then I realized it was just how the reader was making her voice.
Though to be fair, male readers on other audiobooks are about as bad in how they do women. Except usually they just sound bad without necessarily making me dislike the characters. Here I dislike the guys.
I’m sure the reader is good but just mismatched to material.
A piece of art lost to history is sought by an artist hired to copy it.
A very different kind of mystery from my usual. Three different timelines reveal their stories bit by bit, keeping me on the hook especially about the goings-on at the end of the 19th century storyline, though the author predominantly focused the story on modern day plot - the stolen Degas and the painter who spotted it as a forgery, sparking her own investigation into its history. An appreciation of art would be a plus (I happen to love Degas), but not necessary, especially if you're just as interested in the theft and mystery itself. Kept me on edge as developments grew in suspense and gravity. Cynical commentary on the art world and media. The tragedy of the main character's past haunts much of her present actions, which was a little overly included, even harped on; I think you could have deleted a few instances without losing the message of its significance, but it did impact her whole outlook and course of action so not irrelevant. She also seemed a bit too naive and trusting going into this endeavor for having been through what she has (but maybe its more illustrative of my reading habits and being on the lookout for deceivers and solving the whodunit before the end, rather than about her...) After all, I figured it out the same moment her own thoughts lead her to her final conclusion. It was a fascinating story of a painting.
The narrator was wonderful at the tones of the women, but seemed to have only one, maybe two distinct male voices, which confused me once or twice.
Overall a good read, couldn't put it down near the end- the moment i had the chance i listened to the last 3 hours straight through. Makes me want to go view some impressionist masterpieces.
The book rated one star across the board because I couldn't write this brief review without rating each category. I can't rate the story because the narration was so bad. Probably won't buy the paper or kindle versions--my book "reading" takes place in the car.
Well researched thrillers Chriton-esque. Nonfiction: Science, medical, biography, "self-help" meta cognitive sub-genre, memoir, philosophy..
03 words: I wish the painting have been there Vermeer. The plot draws upon an intriguing story in real art history. The characters are very well done. It's not overly thrilling, overly scary… It's just not over the top. However it was eminently listenable. And my immediate reaction upon concluding the book was to see if the author had another available on audible.com.
The plot kept me going in no small part due to the characters and their relationships. Yet this is an easy book to have going on while doing other things around the house.
The main character. I think the narrator did a poor job with male voices and it took some real getting used to. Plus all the male voices were the same to my ear.
In many ways this book was just exactly what I wanted and needed. I wish I had more of them. Not too heavy. Not too twisty. Not too dark. Yet grounded and not out floating around somewhere in the universe of lost threads. I like the insight into the main character and thought that was very well written. That character was humanized. Artist or not, it could've been so many of us.
At an eight out of ten. good story overall
the stages of painting the artwork was the most interesting
Its a good story. A bit too much is given away as you hear letters from Bel Gardner but the end twists enough to keep it interesting. Wish the main character was stronger but...