The Lord of the Rings is one of those books that changes you. And the delivery by this particular narrator is splendid.
Very Good book
Gandalf was favorite character
very good narration
no particular reaction to the book
no additional comments
Probably not. I loved the story, but it was a bit long and tedious at times...
My favorite thing about the story was the characters. I loved Gandalf the wise guide with a surprising sense of humor. I also thought Sam and Bilbo were exceptional characters. I also loved the beautiful descriptions of the various lands and areas encountered on their quest.
The narration was outstanding. I love the way all the characters were performed. Inglis is a cut above, for sure.
I will definitely finish the series. Inglis is outstanding.
I suppose I find the print and audilble versions equally good, just depends on my mood whether to listen or read. Most of the time lately I prefer to kick back and listen, but then I tend to fall asleep and miss parts which I then return to. I'm not in a rush, I keep telling myself, it's the journey that I'm there for not to quickly read the last page.
None at this point.
At first it took a bit of getting used to, probably after being so used to the movie series. Now however I find Inglis's range to be quite good most of the time, and all the time it's adequate. He doesn't do females well for instance. It would have been really nice to have given the job to several voice actors.
No extreme reactions but since I so love the story and characters it's an enjoyable journey I'm making with them, once again.
Love listening to audio books at work or on the road.
There is a film an the film is awesome
Rob does a great job, his singing could use some work but he is not a bad singer. My only problem which is less apparent in the audio books is the book is a little longer as Tolkien loved explaining his world.
I'm a software developer.
Rob Inglis' narrations of Tolkein's work is by far in my opinion the greatest of any book every recorded. He does the voices well, has a great rythm, and a perfect accent. Possibly the only one you'd want reading Tolkein.
By far Gandalf. Then again, I've always been of fan of the old, wise men with beards in any story.
Tolkein practically invented the fantasy genre and while much of this seems cliche now, it was all original when it was written. This is one of my favorite pieces of work of all time.
It's a classic story and engaging enough as it is, but Rob Inglis' narration quite literally makes the book. He uses unique (and consistent) voices for each character and sings all of the songs that the reader might be tempted to skim over.
Aragorn/Strider - he's very noble and kingly in the book.
Gimli. Rob Inglis uses a low, deep tone for Gimli's lines and they are rich and exactly as I imagine a dwarf to be.
HIGHLY recommend this book (and the others in the series). Among the best narrations I've heard.
In the audio version I pay attention to the poetry and songs, and so have found a new delight. I've enjoyed the humor more, and seen the tenderness with better clarity. Other things I might have picked up from the audio version I also learnt in the movies, such as how to differently pronounce Sauron and Saruman. And as in most audio books, sentences here or there that escaped my eye do not escape my ear.
Disney's Sleeping Beauty: lots of swords and thorny undergrowth. I liked that Harry Potter's Neville Longbottom, herbologist-in-training, honors the famousest tobacco.
I've only heard his narration on Tolkein's books. Sometimes Inglis' voice cracks. Sometimes he just sounds too old, yet often he brings a different spin than I had in my head or which we've seen in the movies, made a decade after Inglis's reading. I wonder if some of the actors understood their character better by listening to Inglis. But overall -- and I've listened to this audio on cassette every 3 years or so for the last 15 years -- in its entirety he is about perfect.
The entire cycle is intended to be lived with for several weeks, to dive in and occasionally come up for air.
Rob Inglis narrates all three of the trilogy and his ability to make a myriad of characters come to life is amazing! I now know what orks, ents, and hobbits all sound like and they all sound distinctly different from wizards, elves, and future kings. The characters really come to life. Sam is never confused with Pippen or Merry and your can hear Frodo's exhaustion grow as he continues on his quest. I enjoyed them so much that I'm starting them over again.
I am now a huge fan of simultaneously reading and listening to a book, sometimes one then the other. I find it completely useful to pursue the story even while my eyes are engaged say, on driving, walking the dog or grocery shopping. Robert Inglis is a wonderful narrator, indeed. His voice lends a special gravity that translates well into a 54-hour long listening experience. It really is rather like listening to a radio drama. Special mention should be made of his Gimli and Gollum! Bravo!