Great book and certainly more story detail than was provided in the movie, also much more character development
The Hobbit failed to capture my imagination, but FOTR made me a Tolkien fan.
All the characters were brilliantly played, but Sam was fantastically done.
I grew up watching lord of the rings! Absolutely love the movies and story.
Since I am such a big reader I'm not sure why it took me so long to read the first book, but so happy I did. These books add layers to the movies, and it is nice to finally know what is actually written. It makes me love the movies even more.
Loved the narrator!!
This review covers all three books of the Lord of the Rings.
I've read the Lord of the Rings Trilogy many times since I first discovered Middle Earth at the age of 14. I thought I knew the whole work thoroughly after many re-readings. I was wrong. The sections that focus on the history and lore of Middle Earth seemed, when reading the printed page, a bit slow - and I may have given them short shrift.
One great thing about audiobooks is that you will get every word that the author wrote. Maybe it was Rob Inglis's narration, but parts of the book came alive for me as though I were reading them for the first time.
As a long-time Tolkien reader, I enjoyed the movies - but listening to the books made me realize how I really loved them, and how superior they are to the movies. While it may make me sound positively medieval, I just don't think that film (at least mainstream film) can capture the depth and meaning found in books - including audiobooks.
A final note on Tolkien as an author. He's often described as a a better storyteller than a prose writer. I think that's wrong. Yes, he writes in a traditional style (suitable to his subject matter), if you are looking for evidence of his writing prowess, go back and read the scene of Faramir and Eowyn on the walls of Minas Tirith. And on another level, think about the interlacing of history and lore with the narrative - reminiscent of Tolstoy's War and Peace. The Lord of the Rings deserves to be listed among the great works of 20th Century literature.
Again, as in The Hobbit, I am enchanted with the way Tolkien sets his characters and his listener on the road; it’s completely plausible, utterly believable, true to life. We want them to go. We know they have to go if we’re to have a story (and we want the story). But Tolkien sets it all in motion through a series of circumstances and discoveries that make it inevitable that they should go--and that we should have our story.
In spite of the fact that Bilbo, Sam and Frodo live in a world so much different than ours, their motives and emotions are utterly familiar to us. That’s probably why Tolkien succeeds so well: he creates a strange world full of Dark Riders and enchanted woods and haunted barrows, but his characters think and act as we would here in our world of minivans and weekends and laptops. True, we may not be as adventuresome or heroic. But if we were…
Since this is just the first third of the quest, it’s hard to say much more, other than that the story thus far is completely satisfying. The characters we encounter--at least, the members of the Fellowship--become our boon companions. As such, we are loathe to let them go. And the good news is, of course, we don't have to yet.
As with The Hobbit, Rob Inglis’ sonorous voice is the perfect vehicle. But to be honest, you’ll either buy or not buy according to your own lights. If you enjoy this sort of story, if you’re familiar with some of the Saxon/Icelandic/Medieval masterpieces that Tolkien was drawing from, then you will enjoy Fellowship thoroughly. More, if you’re a thoughtful Christian the story will have even more to say to you. Don’t take Tolkien at his word at the end when he says the story was written just to amuse us. (And remember Wilde’s disavowal of any moral purpose at the beginning of Dorian Grey.) Tolkien wrote to edify us, too. As a Poor Clare sister with whom I discussed the book put it, “He’s good. Even better than C. S. Lewis.”
It had been years since I'd read the Trilogy, and after seeing all of the Peter Jackson films, I thought I'd give Audible a try. I listened to all three books in the series over the past month or so, while driving to and from work, and it was so much better for me than listening to the unhappy and troubling world news. In particular, Rob Inglis does an amazing job of differentiating the voices of the many characters - Frodo, Sam, Gandalf, Strider/Aragorn, Merry and Pippin - and all of the Elves, Dwarves, Orcs and other assorted beings. Each had a unique accent and vocal quality, which made listening to the story so fun, and easy to follow. The story does get a bit lengthy at times, but Inglis did such a wonderful job narrating, and singing the songs, it was like listening to poetry. I loved it!
The LOTR trilogy is amazing as it is from the pen of Tolkien, but I will say that this particular recording with Rob Inglis serves it very well and even makes it better. I remember reading the books and found parts of them long and almost too detailed at times. I find however that Rob Inglis' narration makes it come to life! Also, the fact that there is a lot of songs in the book is in favor of going through the LOTR in audio form. Some of the songs are fine, but there are some gems that are quite beautiful. It is all a cappella delivered in an elegant form by Rob Inglis. Especially the song of Galadriel and for Boromir. Strongly recommended!
I love the scope of the story, this is the start of a tale within the midst of an even larger mythology. There are so many deep nooks and crannies in this book -- all of the side stories and songs that get told by the characters, and their own backstories -- it feels like a road trip where you see glimpses of loveliness and mystery as you drive, and sometimes you get to stop and take a bit of closer look, but then you have to drive on, hoping that one day you'll get a chance to see more of it. But don't get me wrong, the main story is gorgeous in itself.
It sounds like he had a merry old time reading this book. It's contagious.
It makes me do both. Though it is only the beginning of the trilogy, it is so much about endings and memories, and beautiful things that are to pass away, and some that are gone from the world. But there are truly funny moments too. Even though Tolkien's prose is very poetic and about a fantasy world, it feels true to life.
Heroic quest epic.
This has always been one of my favorite stories, from childhood. It's always delightful to reread it.
I don't know who I would prefer, but Rob Inglis is just not working for me. He did The Hobbit. Now I've got three LOR rings with him, and I just don't like his characterizations or the way he emphasizes his sentences. Plus, he's slow. Yes, you can speed it up a bit, but then it's off.