the first time through I thought it was ok. didn't knock my socks off and didn't regret the purchase. so a few months passed and I thought I'd give it another listen. I loved It. that's what I can tell you.
Tell a story. Don't strive so hard to work in lyrics from 40+ years of source material.
Peart doesn't really have what I would consider an acceptable narrating voice. His pronunciation is somewhat slurred and often mushy (possible speech impediment?). His cadence is almost singsongy as if he were reading to children. Almost every sentence follows the same build up and trail off finish. I'd have rather just listened to him drum...
All of the above. As a huge fan of the band and specifically Peart's lyrical style I was really hopeful that this novelization would capture some of that magic. I now realize that great lyrics, especially ones jammed into every conceivable place in prose, doesn't work. Once I caught the 4th or 5th random lyrical interjection I found myself listening specifically for the next one as if I was on some aural easter egg hunt. This not only distracted from the story but often I lost track entirely because of the ear worm effect. For instance, every time they said "Cold Fire" I'd drift off singing the rest of the lyrics. The result reads like the worst kind of pandering fan fiction written solely as tribute or to garner the attention of the artists.
I'm glad I didn't invest in the rest of the series.
The story seemed to be aimed at a younger audience.
The narrator seemed like he was reading to his daughter and not to an adult audience, which is fine. Wish I knew the audience level before reading.
Loved the references to Rush's song titles and lyrics. There were Easter eggs all through the audio book!
Also, if you enjoyed the Clockwork Angels album that Rush released in 2012, this audio book will fill in the story blanks. Not sure if you will enjoy the album any more or less though.
I love Neil Peart and Rush, but never connected with the characters in this book or the story. I personally would have been much better off imagining the story in my own mind based on the lyrics and music from the exceptional Clockwork Angels Rush album.
As a fan, I enjoyed the many references to RUSH lyrics throughout this well told tale
I am a clinical psychologist and writer living in Colorado's Vail Valley. I taught myself to read when I was 3 and I have been a voracious reader ever since. I love science fiction, literature, and non-fiction about psychology, business, history, politics, science and biography. I adore audiobooks and my kindle.
This book was clever and well-written. I enjoyed seeing the world through the eyes of the main character and I really liked the author's writing style. The story was straight-forward and deep at the same time. It was fun picking out all the references to Rush songs/lyrics while I listened. I wasn't crazy about the narrator's voice. It wasn't bad, but I think someone with a little more warmth and inflection would have made this a better listen. The additional material at the end gave some interesting insight into how the book got written, so keep going and be sure to finish out the whole audiobook.
I prefer the audio version because where else can you have a rock legend like Neil Peart read a story to you, honestly!
The flow was intentionally similar to Candide. It also reminded me of The Alchemist. I enjoyed Clockwork Angels more than either of these two however because of the pairing with the soundtrack.
Neil brought a real honesty to the reading. It didn't come across as a voice talent but as a friend telling me a great story. I was pleasantly surprised by his work.
The true meaning of tending ones garden.
Great story with an incredible soundtrack!
Couldn't Tell you didn't read the book
Neil is a good reader but I am not sure if Neil's voice is the problem of the qualit of the recording but sometimes it sounds like Neil has some marbles in his mouth and the sound drops out a little. but I like how neil reads the book.
Yes it was exciting enough that I wanted to keep listening to it.
Good book typical story but I still enjoyed it a great deal and would recommend this book!
As a long time Rush fan I was looking forward to more insight of the book with the album. Unfortunately I found the story underwhelming as well as the narration by Mr. Peart. I'm still a huge fan, but honestly I was a little disappointed in the book. It seemed aimed at a preteen audience.
This is essentially a story of self-discovery but there really isn't any sense of urgency, purpose or drama. A naive teenager impulsively sets out and story after story occur. None of them interesting. None of them particularly revealing nor suspenseful nor rewarding. It is interesting that the society in the story is very regulated, structured and bland (by intention) and, as a result, so is the "adventure" we experience. In listening, I must admit I was bored by this story; drifted my attention to other thoughts; came back and really didn't miss anything. I am at a point of just hearing through the end just to finish it.
The biggest problem is that there is no suspense aspect at all. I can't tell what is really driving this character besides curiosity and idle choice. There is no drive here, Owen just does things and he doesn't know why and neither do you...and after a while you don't care.
Here I have to bury my fanboy bias for Rush. Neil isn't a good narrator. He reads the story as a father would read a bedtime story to a young child or a baby he's trying to lull to sleep. Very few sentence inflections (and I mean like three or four) and they don't particularly match the story action. He has limited character 'voices' and they all sound fairytale-ish. He voices the main character, who is a naive 17 year old, with such innocence that I equate it with a naive 10 year old.
Also, sad to say, Neil has a slight lateral lisp and his 'ess' sound come across as 'esh.' Now that's no big deal, and many people speak that way...just not professional narrators. There is a reason why people with hangnails aren't professional hand models, if you catch my drift.
All that said, the story doesn't help either.
It's not a matter of scene or scenes to cut. The story just needs more purpose, and either drama or humor or adventure or love or anything really.
It does make for a good, if super-prolonged, drinking game. Take a drink every time you hear a Rush lyric or song title!