Retired Ex-Pat living Near San Jose, Costa Rica.
While some readers complained about the narrator, I think the real problem was choosing a British narrator to interpret a Danish detective. Makes no sense, and didn't work well. That was the producer's fault. The reader was fine, but with all the fine alternative readers, Pacey was a crummy and distracting choice.
My big mistake was reading this book after recently reading the Louise Penny novels... All eight of them! She may arguably be the finest living author of the modern detective genre and frankly, this author is not close.
This is a C level book. Not sorry I read it... But I am not at all motivated to buy another. I also found the interaction between the protagonist and his "staff of 2" to be just weird. His staff were far better detectives than the detective who, quite frankly, detected little.
In fact, I could not connect with Merck at any level, neither professionally nor personally. Found him to be boring and not overly bright. Hard to build a series around that.
Still, as you can see, my three star rating is in the minority, so give the book a try and if you agree with my analysis, you'll know to consider my other reviews when you see them.
But if you REALLY want something special, check out Inspector Gamache by Louise Perry.
I love books!
This is my second book by Danish author Jussi Adler-Olsen and it was great, in a genre I really like, crime thrillers. This thought keeps coming to me that the Scandanavians are really coming on as authors as Adler-Olsen is about the fifth I've come acreoss recently that I've really enjoyed. Adler-Olsen seems to have a real macabre imagination in coming up with his plots. I'd hate to think these kinds of people really do exist but, who knows, maybe they do. This one was built around the idea of a group of rich preppies forming a gang while in school in the 80's where their motivational theme came from the movie "A Clockwork Orange". The gang came to the attention of Dept Q, who works cold cases in Denmark. Carl Moerk is the detective at the head of Q and he and his team of two work the case and intereact with each other and those around them in a way that is very entertaining. Adler-Olsen does a good job of developing the story and characters. I'm already looking forward to book 3 in the series.
Well-crafted, never boring. You don't have to wait for the good parts.
Excellent narrator. I will look for him again.
The characters are fabulous. You can't help but love Carl Morck and his assistant, Assad.
Not Erik Davies. I don't want to complain about Steven Pacey... he's a talented narrator with lots of range in his reading. However, after listening to "The Keeper of Lost Causes" narrated by Erik Davies, it was jolting to hear a different voice. Yes, that's how good Erik Davies' reading was.
So, please bring Erik Davies back with his excellent understanding of Adler-Olsen's humor, as well as his Danish accent and wide range of other accents.
No disrespect to Steven Pacey, but there is a certain cadence to stories, and you get used to how a person sounds. I was comfortable with Carl Morck's voice as portrayed by Davies. But, Davies really gets the book and all of its subtle cleverness.
Jussi Adler-Olsen is a great author for suspense, intrigue and unbelievable gruesomeness. I've read several of his books. This was a bit more disturbing than some. I love how intelligent Jussi's books are. Smart. Characters are both serious and funny. The narrator did a fine job switching roles.
The first of this series is a really fascinating book, somewhat surreal but also touching and human. The reader uses a scandinavian accent at times, and an american one at others; it worked. The next two have degenerated. I'm not sure if its the sneering BBC uppercrust voice that the new narrator gives the lead character, the fawning and almost racist portrayal of Assad, or the writer. But I'm out of love with these books.
Tell us about yourself!
A closed cold case lands on the top of the pile at Department Q. Much effort is put forth to get Morck to leave it alone which makes him more interested. This pursuit leads to even more, seemingly unrelated, cold cases. The story is engaging, the threads are eventually woven together, and Department Q triumphs again.
More is revealed about Morck's personal life, his unusual assistant, and a secretary joins them,
The narration is well done and the overall listen is enjoyable.
Story was great, but narrator turned Karl and Assad ( or as narrator called him ASSad) into whining, generally unappealing characters..totally unlike the characters in Keeper of Lost Causes.
I listened to the first book with rapt attention. I could not get enough of it. It was authentic and Danish. The Narrator did a phenomenal job with Danish accents. This one was awful. The narrator gives Danes cockney accents complete with dropped "h" and f/th substitutions.. I had listened to hours of Ah-sahd...gotten to know him as that....now it's Ass-add. . . Or Marcus Jacobson as Marcus YAH - cobson...now its YAK-obson. And that's just the beginning. I kept losing the story in the strangeness of Danish names pronounced with British accent.
No, and the reason why is the narrator. I have no idea what people from Denmark sound like. I assume they sound similar to those from the rest of Scandinavia and am fully capable of inventing some accent that sounds appropriate in my head while I read. With a Narrator this is not possible. You are subjected to the brilliance of the person who selected a narrator with a wretched British accent to read a Danish novel..... Why??? It makes as much sense as hiring a veterinarian to fix the brakes on your car......
The background humor that goes on amidst such a dark mystery is great. You are intrigued, amused, entertained and disgusted all at the same time.
His performance is not bad it is just misplaced. He should be reading Dickens not Adler-Olsen
It is full of ups and downs. If you enjoyed the first one you will love this one as well
You can get through the narration....it's bearable, ok, all but the Whores voice is bearable. the story is great you will be thoroughly entertained.