The point when Beauvoir is watching the video, the monks are chanting and the whole story seems to be coming together in a perfect storm. Powerful!
I love listening to Ralph Cosham read the Gamache series.
I've enjoyed many of Penny's books, but I believe this is her best to date. I can't say I enjoyed the ending where I now have to wait for the next book, but it was a small price to pay for an otherwise good book.
Beautiful Mystery ranks high on my list of favorite reads/listens of the past two years.
Beautiful Mystery left me breathless with surprise. I've read a number of Inspector Gamach stories. Louise Penny likes to pace her stories with great detail that pulls the reader though the details of most of the main characters lives. Though the Inspector is the dominating force of the series, it is the supporting characters that drive the plot. Beautiful Mystery is no exception.
In this case the Deputy (sorry, I don't have his name at the moment, I am away from the book right now) and the workings of his inner life serve to create enormous empathy towards him. The Deputy's confusion and moments of clarity create conflict and confusion for all involved.
I believe that this is a book to be savored. Louise Penny is an author who insists that the reader appreciate the nuances of life. the reader who insists on a quick jolt of excitement and drama may become frustrated. This can lead to moments where the book seems to drag. One might ask, "do I really need that much detail?". However, when the book draws to a close (with a truly stunning end), most will appreciate the time the spent with each character.
How long must we wait to learn more? Louise Penny is such a marvelous story teller and she has me totally "hooked" by the end of the book. So leaving quite so many loose ends made me want to just cry and yell. I kept hoping that things might resolve, as I watched the minutes tick down to the ending. I hope she won't keep us waiting long.
A first-time Louise Penny reader might enjoy this book, but because I have loved the character depth and the community and the very real human interactions and relationships, I found this lacking.
The plot was thin, the characters uninteresting, and the ending betrayed the relationship Penny has developed and nurtured between Armand Gamache and Jean-Pierre.
Of course! One disappointment from eight is nothing.
Ralph Cosham is a master in capturing these novels.
Disappointment. I hope to see a return to Three Pines, but recognize she may have run her course with that quirky town and its mix of complex characters.
I'm not a big fan of murder mysteries, but the setting tempted me, and I'm so glad I was drawn in. Instead of gory details of corpses and murder scenes, the novel was set in a rich and detailed place, full of characters that were multidimensional and powerful. No stereotypical all-bad or all-good characters. Deep and thoughtful character development, and attention to detail of place transported me to a place where I had never been in real life. Louise Penny is a masterful writer, and Ralph Cosham an excellent narrator, one of those readers that is so seamless that you lose yourself in the text and forget someone's reading to you. Highly recommend!
The audio edition of 99% of the books I have listened to are definitely better than the printed version. I can still use my imagination on the audio books as well as the printed versions.
I would compare these books to the Pendergast series because the (hero) in both series is beset by higher ups who want them to fail.
I have not listened to any other books Ralph Cosham has narrated because, once I latch on to a series, I am afraid to venture into any others.
Yes, when the helicopter flew away from Gamache who was heart broken.
I would really like to see Inspector Gamache win out against his superiors once in a while.
I dont usually read books twie
only two main characters
could not believe that after two oxycodone the detective got completely hooked again and gave up everything. that took away a lot from the book.
This book sweeps you up in a story about beautiful music and a thought-provoking mystery. The end of the book keeps you hanging waiting for the next one to resolve a mystery in Gamache's own life. Can't wait for the next book!
Gamache -- always!
All good; hard to choose.
A forgotten monastery sweeps you up in a mystery within a mystery....
Yes, I do - because of Ralph Cosham. His interpretations of Louise Penny's characters are flawless. His readings have been spot on from book 1.
For this book it's Gamache, for the depth of his feeling for Jean-Guy as well as the respect and reverence shown the friars,Abbe and history of the monastery.
Yet I enjoy all the Three Pines characters. Looking forward to their return.
As previously stated, can't imagine an audio version without his narration. Mr Cosham's performances allow the listener to always identify which character is speaking or musing.
Were I to read the book, I suspect I would hear Ralph Crosham's voice.
No, I love to savor Louise Penny's books. I have all her books on my IPOD. I don't listen to them just once. Frequently replay them. They are that good.