Nothing, it's just not my kind of story.
He almost mumbled.
Not my cup of tea! Before anyone starts sending hate mail, please understand, the book is well written, I (meaning ME, my opinion) just hated the story. In regard to the characters, I'm not sure who the protagonist or the antagonists are but I hated Tom! and Hannah! Truth be told I don't like reading any book that is so overwrought with sadness as to make ripping my own heart out and shredding it with my fingernails seem preferable, but I digress. I have five kids, so yea... I'm a Mom. I thought Hannah was selfish to demand the return of Lucy/Grace without thought for what it was putting the child through. I also thought Tom was selfish for agreeing and then, in order to quell his own guilty conscience, destroying just about everybody's lives. Something akin to confessing an affair for no other purpose than making yourself feel better. Isabel was the easiest for me to forgive, losing 3 babies and then having one appear almost magically. It would be real easy to convince yourself it was a gift from God and surely meant to be.
Having an authentic Australian voice was great! I read reviews before buying and heard a sample. The reviews were not very positive, but I understood the sample well so I went ahead and purchased it.
It was an authentic accent. If the listener is not familiar with accents outside of the US, I can see the frustration. Best recommendation would be to have a hardcopy book on hand for any difficult areas. It's a pleasure hearing it in an voice similar to the setting and author's voice.
I love books!
First time author me, debut novel for the author. Set in Australia in the 1920's, the book centers around a couple that live on a small island 100 miles off the west coast of Australia. The husband is the lighthouse keeper. They live a fairly happy life except the wife really, really wants to have a baby, especially after three miscarriages. Then one day a boat washes up on the shore and inside is a baby wrapped in blankets and a dead man, no identification. The couple makes a decision to raise the child as their own. This decision has implications that take a while to unfold and ends up causing a lot of pain and sadness.The book is really well written and brings a tear or two towards the end.
In reading the reviews prior to diving in with the book I read where many of the reviewers had complaints about the narration. I don't understand what listeners want? The book is written by an Aussie author, set in Australia, and it should be no surprise to have an Aussie narrator with an Aussie accent. I, too, find sometimes when I start listening to a foreign accented narrator that it can be hard to understand. But, I also find that in the beginning I have to pay closer attention to the narration but that my ear eventually gets attuned to it. Scottish accents can be tough to get used as well. But I didn't find the narration detracting from the story, in fact, I enjoyed it.
This book was terrific. A great story, beautifully written, and the narration.. oh the narration. Hearing a book based in Australia narrated by an Australian REALLY brought the book alive. Thanks to Mr. Taylor, I could sense the townspeople whispering, I could feel the waves crashing, and I could see a little girl standing before me.
This is a book about choices, doing the right thing, loss, regret, and above all else, love. There are no villains... just imperfect people dealing with imperfect situations. Mr. Stedman writes in a way that constantly has you questioning, guessing, second guessing, and, at times, on the edge of your seat. I smiled, cried, ached, laughed, and at the end of the story was left feeling (to my surprise!) supremely satisfied.
The narration left much to be desired. He dropped his voice at the end of each sentence and it came out garbled. I missed a lot of the story.
Better read than listened to.
No. Well, perhaps from the author but not from the narrator!
I'm half-way through this book, having to read it for Book Club. The story is fine... it's the narrator. He starts EVERY sentence up - meaning you can hear it - and ends EACH sentence speaking so low and mumbly you can't hear/understand what he's saying. I would quit listening to it right now if it weren't for book club. I don't have time to "read" it.
Yes to perhaps catch the 10% that I lost with the unintelligible narrator
Tom. Always thinking of others well being.
A proven good narrator with a clear voice with no accent.
Did not like the reader. Had a very difficult time engaging in the story at the beginning. Couldn't understand the reader much of the time. Gave up on it .. Read the book
Not only did I not like the narrator, he made me mad! I had to turn the volume way up to be able to decipher the mumbling, uninflected reading. I nearly gave up on it a number of times.
But, I continued, and found it to be a sensitive, interesting portrayal of an impossible family situation. The characters were, for the most part, well-drawn and depicted. The ending is a tear-jerker, and I wept for all the losses and poignant dilemmas. The book did move me, and was well written.
The narration was AWFUL unless you like a monotone mumbler that has a slight lisp.
The Secrets She Carried by Barbara Davis
Could not go beyond Chapter 10. The narration was unbearable. It was like Chinese water torture.
I am so sorry that I didn't read reviews before purchasing. This was my Book Club's selection for the month, so I just purchased. Never in a million years would I have gotten it if I had read the reviews.