I'm a big WWII history buff, and have listened to many good titles of this genre, but this book could not hold my interest. Overall, Mr. Beevor prefers to concentrate his writing on relating the driest of facts: Unit numbers, commanding officer names, direction of attack, strategies from the highest levels, etc., but omits most anything of the human interest side of history. When my attention began flagging while listening to some early war history surrounding Russia and Finland, I thought, "Let me skip ahead to something more interesting, like Pearl Harbor." It didn't improve my opinion. Sorry, but I found this book to be extremely dull. The one bright spot was the narrator--he is a masterful reader.
Not at all--I greatly enjoy history--just not this kind of recitation of facts and figures.
Comprehensive. More complex history than you may have thought, more relevant to todays world in which major powers + internal national rivalries muddy the bigger picture. A great book.
How can there be a "favorite character" in a history? I'd say the people of Poland. If you want to know why listen/read the book.
This is a long book. Much too much for one sitting. In fact good for a re-listen. There's a lot to absorb.
If you've read other books about or set in the context of WWII this book will give you background. Some things start making sense...unfortunately.
One day yes, but not for awhile. This book is very long. I will listen again, but in a few years, as it might take that long to digest everything. Don't get me wrong though, it is completely worth every minute you spend with it.
I can't say what book, but I got the same feeling of excitement and awe that I had after watching Band of Brothers on HBO.
This was so beautifully and expertly delivered. I cannot imagine another person who could have done such an amazing and perfect job.
The book is full of many moments that will make you pause, shutter, and shake your head in the absolute madness that the two world wars were made of.
This book is full of information and is so in-depth you will be amazed. The author clearly has spent a vast portion of their life researching and vetting the information. I especially appreciate the authors ability to present both sides of a story and then provide a level headed analysis to try and remove much of the attempts both sides make to either exaggerate or cloud an issue.
For those who like history in a narrative form, this is definitely a book worth investing your time and money in.
The book covers WWII at a macro level, but more often operates at the battle level moving from one encounter to the next to advance the narrative. Some may find this a relentless and unflinching way to unfold the story; I certainly did. There is a great deal of brutality and inhumanity laid out in the books pages.
There is much emphasis on the Eastern Front. The lion’s share of the book I would say. But there is also a fair amount of attention paid to the Sino-Japanese War and how it became folded into the broader conflict of WWII.
Beevor doesn't spare many of the revered leaders and generals of the war. His opinionated skewering leaves hardly anyone untouched, save Eisenhower. That’s fine by me; it’s only the man’s opinion, but some readers may bristle at his treatment of Roosevelt , Churchill and others.
All in all, a great one volume treatment.
Love reading. Three kids keep me busy so listening to books has become necessity.
Definitive history of The Second World War.
Very detailed and interesting but it some of the less known facts of just how low humans can sink that is the most memorable and disturbing.
Great narration coveys the events of the Second World War with power.
The behaviour of troops to civilians of the countries they are fighting is touchy at times but more often than not very challenging listening.
If you are history fan, particularly of the Second World War, then this is the book for you.
An excellent history of WWII. Very comprehensive with fresh insights. Recommend. I especially enjoyed the analysis regarding what Stalin thought of Roosevelt & Truman.
This was a pretty in-depth book about World War 2 it does seem to spend a lot of time on the atrocities of the sides involved more so then the battles that took place, But it is still very interesting.
Detailed descriptions of the impact of war.
Sean Barrett is the perfect narrator for this material. His voice carries the emotion of the work. His character voices are wonderful.
The invasion of Berlin.
This audio book is a fantastic package.
Maybe, but probably not for a while. It is 39+ hrs long, so I had enough in-depth coverage of WWII for a little while (even though I'm a WWII buff!). I love Beevor's writing (notably Berlin and Stalingrad), but listening to this book, I noticed that Beevor focuses far too much on the French (even after they were defeated and contributed practically nothing to the rest of the War on either side) and to the imperialistic British. I was offended that Beevor only gave one or two sentences about *some horribly dreadful march from Bataan*, yet spent pages, if not chapters, talking about the boring and irrelevant British interest in maintaining their crumbling empire in the far east, and the squabbling and ineptitude of the British command there. I don't care about what the British commander looked like and when he took his tea when, at the same time, thousands were dying on the Bataan Death March. Really, I think Beevor bit off more than he could chew with this. He does have interesting side stories that I haven't ever heard anywhere else, but they tend to drag the storytelling down in some places talking about some ultimately insignificant event, and then speeds through other important events without hardly event getting into detail about them. Beevor, in his own words, in an Anglophile and has a slight Anti-American tone, and continually downplays America's significant contributions to the War. I got the impression that whenever Beevor talks about the Allies, Britain is portrayed as the most important, followed by France, followed by Russia, followed by America, which is way out of line in my opinion. When he talks about the German-Russian battles, the coverage is more balanced and fair. I was sad that I read/listened to this book - it tarnished my respect and admiration for Antony Beevor as an author. This book is okay for WWII history buffs, but I'd really recommend reading the much better and more fairly balanced Stalingrad or Berlin.
The interesting side stories that I hadn't heard anywhere else before. Also, this book covers far more of the Chinese-Japanese conflict than I have read in any other WWII history book.
Good accents and good tone. It was very easy to listen to.
Yes, but at 39 hours, that isn't possible.