Broken Harbor kept my attention and the story built methodically from the beginning.
I liked the complexity of the characters who were portrayed with flaws and all. As the story went on the strengths and weaknesses of each character became apparent.
For those who enjoy a very well-written, intriguing mystery, with top-notch narration, you can't go wrong with "Broken Harbor." I found myself taking every opportunity to listen.
The story held my interest and I wanted to be able to listen just a little bit longer each time.
I have equally liked the two Tana French books that I have listened to.
When you first became aware that things were not what they seemed to be.
Although I am not much of a novel reader, I needed a story to give me a break from the psychology books (e.g., Everything is Obvious, Denialism) that I like to read. Murder mysteries do the trick for me.
The fun part of this book for this Texan is that the investigator develops a relationship with his new partner who, in the end, drops the ball big-time. The murder of a family in a new, yet abandoned (due to economic times) sub-division on the coast of Ireland, is horror enough. As the plot unfolds, the suspects are not the only piece of this mystery, although they are an integral part in the development of the final conclusion that the prime investigator comes to. He learns a lot about himself, his partner, and his precinct -- specifically his bosses' outlooks on the case.
And then there's the voyeur who has been watching the family -- how does he all fit into the puzzle? It all becomes clear, but this guy watching this entire family from a near, yet abandoned house, would become a prime suspect. Does he ultimately become the culprit, or is he just an "innocent" bystander?
The reader was great, and the story kept pushing me to keep listening.
Mostly I can be a prude and want to read good literature. But I wait for Tana French's new books and read them right away- they're good mysteries and I enjoy listening to the Irish narrator. This one is as enjoyable as the others.
I loved the imagry. Tana French really has a fantastic ability to draw me in. Her writing is suspenseful and kept me interested. I think my favorite part of Broken Harbor was the budding partnership between Scorcher and his newbie partner.
His voice is nearly perfect for Scorcher, both as I imagined him and as Faithful Place introduced him as.
It was a bit difficult for me to listen to the narrator, as he had a peculiar knack of STARTING A SENTENCE LIKE THIS AND then ending it in a whisper. Its hard to listen to and if you latch on to annoying things like me, you might have to press pause for a few minutes.
I didn't read the print version.
Aside from the amazingly talented narrator, the brilliance of the story itself comes through his performance. He had a lot to work with here, because the author appears to have done her homework on all the intricacies of criminal law and, in particular, interrogation techniques. I usually listen to audiobooks to help me fall asleep at night, but this one has kept me awake, it is so top notch. In fact, I was compelled to write this review (only my second for Audible) even though I'm not yet done with the book. The reading is THAT good.
His uncanny ability to switch in a millisecond from one character's voice to the next, from posh to working class, to a different KIND of working class accent, between women and men. I never found it difficult to tell who was speaking. I'm going to look for more books narrated by Stephen Hogan. He has definitely chosen the right career!
I'm simply overwhelmed by the talents of the author and the narrator.
Tana French has delivered another meaty police procedural with plenty of twists and turns and surprises. Her characters--as usual--are oh-so human and vulnerable, just like all of us. I found the story highly addictive and listened to the last section all in one uninterrupted gulp. Good, gripping story and excellent narration.
My standards for Tana French are high, and this just doesn't cut it. Development is very slow, and the end result is not worth the wait. I don't have to like her characters, though in all three of the other books I have in fact liked one or more of them. I do have to understand and be at least a bit sympathetic to one or two of her main characters. Not in this book!
There was too much telling and not enough showing in this one. And the telling was quite repetitive.
I do highly recommend any and all of her other three books.
Good character separation. Not perfect -- he sometimes took a few extra seconds to transition from one speaker to another -- but quite good.
The whole approach to getting us to know these characters just doesn't work. It's not about cutting scenes, it's about changing the approach. What goes on in Richie's head is important, but we can't get at that very well because he's not the narrator, and it's critical that the narrator be ignorant of what's going on in Richie's head. Not enough was done to let the reader figure things out that the narrator couldn't.
I hope the fifth book returns to the previous quality! I'll certainly give it a try.
These are people with all the flaws and goodness that we see all the time but perhaps we dont feel compasson or take the time to understand. The crime is horrific. The motivation ....well read and decide.
I read audiobooks everyday as I work outside and some of my work allows this. Stephen Hogan is the best reader I have heard. The beauty of Tana French's writing style makes just listening a pleasure for the words alone.
This is the first book I have read from this author but absolutely not the last.
I have given only a few books a 4 star rating but there was no question about this one.