George Guidall is a master of accents and characters. So very good
More books please in this series.
I made the mistake of having read this one before 1632 so I didn't get a few of the references, however, this is a great book and I will read 1632.
Eric doesn't seem to mind killing off major characters and has a few really good twists and surprises in the mix. I liked the combination of historicity, time travel and the imaginative use of modern technology in a historic setting. Kept me wondering how I would have played the political game with what they had to use differently.
This story is about an entire town in the US that is transported in time back to Germany, right in the middle of the Thirty Years War. Interesting, informative and plot filled, but I think I would have enjoyed it more if I had read 1632 first.
The narration is most excellent.
This is a great book but its the first of a two part story. The other story is 1634:the Baltic war. I called audible and their person said out by the end of October 2012. I called Baen Books and they said its being recorded by "RecordedBooks". I called them and they said out some time in middle of 2013 :(. There is another, later in the series, book out on Audible, not sure I understand the logic here.
Yes. I have read many of their books already.
I love the series, but this book focused way too much on macro-level political machinations and planning of the new armed forces. This is just my own personal preference, but I prefer to read/hear some description of battles, whether small skirmishes or large campaigns. I would also like to see more focus on the individual personalities of key characters. This book reminded me of a TV program that ends with the main character in a cliffhanger situation and then advises them to “come back next week” to see how things turn out. It reads too much like a history text called the “Precursors to World War 1.” On the other hand, if you’re devoted to the series, then you cannot miss this book. It’s similar to the Safehold series. Although some of the volumes are dryly political, a reader would be missing something if he avoided them. I just wish that Audible would get the whole series up and available for download.
Well, I first ran into him during the Dark Tower series. He's by far the best reader I've heard. I often listen to his books twice!
It already has one -- if Audible would just get busy and make it available.
Just a little too much American flag waving and labour union praising for my liking. Found that some parts of the story went into intricate technical or historical details yet others completely glassed over large details.
This book has an interesting, yet confusing, start. The premise is kind of fun, but my goodness is it slow moving. While I love good character development, this goes overboard!
You need to be very patient, and you may not be standing by the end (that is if you make it).
I really like Weber, and will continue to read his stuff. This is not altogether unheard of for him. His books tend to be long with some overdeveloped characters.
Good follow up to the 1632 book, personally, I felt that there were several logistical issues that just seemed to disappear in these books, but they are a form of fantasy, so I ignored them.
Guidall as a reader was excellent.
The main issue I had was that the Whispersync for Voice did not work correctly when transitioning from the Kindle form to the Audible form. The transition from the Audible to the Kindle synced perfect every time.
Middle of the road, which is disappointing when compared to the first book of the series.
A very poor follow up to 1632, which to me was one of the best audiobooks I've listened to.
I made a big mistake when I bought this (it was on sale) before listening to the first book in this series, "1632." That book was only so-so and if I'd listened to it first, I would NOT have purchased this one.
This one, "1633," was mind-numbingly dull most of the time. I enjoyed listening to about 10% of it (primarily the action scenes). The rest was torture because I was NOT interested in the boring descriptions and LONG, dull conversations. I almost quit MANY times, but then something briefly interesting would happen and I (foolishly) kept slogging on.
I do NOT recommend this for anyone who is not fascinated by 17th Century European politics, military tactics, religions, culture and philosophy. If you're not a fan of the history, much of what is discussed will be of zero interest to you.
Much of the "story" is actually thinly disguised lectures by the author about how society and politics SHOULD be.
The plot was lacking, as well. Minor spoiler example: the Americans have an expert sniper. They had no problem in "1632" having her shoot enemy officers & leaders. Yet they ignore the obvious solution to virtually all of the problems they're facing in "1633" -- have her assassinate Cardinal Richelieu. It would be ridiculously easy, and save countless lives.
The narration was excellent, but this was the worst story I've listened to.
The audio version is better than the print version because the reader pronounces all the place names properly for you. Now you can read other books in the series without fretting over some very foreign names.
Compare this book to most other time travel books and be happy because there are no whinning travelers worried about how blowing their nose might affect the world they came from. What a relief!
This reader is just great.
Cromwell was the most memorable character. I never thought of him in quite that way.