While I like the ideas explored in this sequel, the plot simply fails to culminate in a way that is satisfying to the adult reader. It felt to me that this book would have been better off split into two separate books - The first ending after Tris' rescue and reunion with Tobias.
I really like this series it is not your typical/predictable story line. I am looking for ward to the next book.
I was thrilled to read Insurgent finally, because (1) I want to see the movie and have a strict rule about reading books BEFORE watching the movie and (2) I'm already into the series. Now that I've read Insurgent I'm equally glad it won. I devoured it in just 2 days time and I've already downloaded Allegiant to start on as soon as I'm done writing this review :)
Even though I read Divergent back in November of 2014, I had no trouble picking up where the story left off - although I did have to try and separate in my head the book's version versus the movie's version since they are slightly different. I felt like the pacing in Insurgent was pretty non-stop, which I loved. Even in the lulls there was a lot going on mentally - Tris was either trying to figure out her own feelings, what was happening on a larger scale, or there were developments within the different factions.
There were so many twists and turns in the story, I don't think it's possible to call all the twists - I did call one of the biggest ones (*mental high five* lol) but I wasn't 100% sure of it until literally the last moments of the audiobook. The story just keeps you on your toes. One of the things I really liked was the stress in Tris and Four/Tobias's relationship - particularly because it wasn't caused by the introduction of third person. No love triangles here - just the stress a new relationship would understandably go through in the midst of a rebellion/war/revolution (it's kind of all three) where both partners are deeply involved and don't always agree 100%. I don't necessarily dislike love triangles, but this was still a refreshing change for a YA dystopian.
Needless to say I did really enjoy the story and I can't exactly tell you why I'm not giving it the full five stars, except to say it wasn't quite five stars. *shrug* But 4.5 is pretty damn good, right? Oh and I should totally mention that Emma Galvin does a really good narration - I listened at 1.5 speed and it still sounded really good, with a variety of voices and clear male voices. Not all narrators can handle that increased speed in my opinion, so I'm putting her down on my list of pretty great narrators.
Can't wait to see how this trilogy wraps up (please don't let it have the YA dystopian third book kiss of death....)
I had high hopes since there is so much buzz about this series. Could hardly get through these long, drawn out passages. I'm not bothering to finish the series.
yes, they all follow the same formula and try too hard to be the hunger games
I am neutral about the narrator, not outstanding in either direction. The poor quality of the writing stood out more.
skip this fad
The film did not do this book justice. It took away all the complexity, and motivation of the characters and plot. This book, and this series, makes me forget it was written for young adults. My jaw dropped at the ending, and now I'm writing this. The ending of this book is better than Divergent, hopefully Allegiance brings as much suspense to the table.
I saw the movie first and was pleasantly surprised when I read the novels. The story is loaded with moral ambiguity which is refreshing in young fiction. While the dystopian coming of age tale is nothing new seeing the world through the eyes of a surly angry young girl sets this story apart. The young protagonist is valued for her selflessness and intellect rather than her appearance.
As far as performance the voice actor does an amazing job.
there were so many scenes that could have been left out all together. it's pretty boring for the most part and if it's not boring its annoying because tris and four spend half of the book arguing over literally nothing.
probably not. divergent was great, the story moved and it kept you interested. insurgent was so far from that. i have no desire to read another novel from her again because theres no consistency
no. she's flat most of the time, inflecting the wrong parts of the sentence and getting the mood of some scenes totally wrong.
the end where the message is finally revealed is clearer in the book than in the movie but thats about it.
i saw the movies and loved them, so i read divergent and it was great. I figured that insurgent would follow in suit. boy was i wrong. my rule of thumb is that if i like the movie i'll love the book. the book gets more of the details of the characters that movies can glaze over. unfortunataly there are exceptions to the rule. insurgent is one of those exceptions. the movie changed the story for the better. this book fell so flat for me. i have no desire to read the next story in the series.