What could have been an interesting topic is completely ruined by an out-of-control author. This writer needed a strong and committed editor to whip this book into shape. Pass it up.
I have listened to several very long books. I will not pursue additional books in this series as this one wasn't worth it. The story itself was interesting and carries/carried much potential. But the pompous characters, almost all, were ridiculous. There were stray ends that could have taken the story along a variety of directions. Many never went anywhere and were unworthy fodder.
Narration was decent.
One distracting piece was a lack of attention, I feel, to accuracy of the era. I have read enough books placed in this timeframe and maybe I am used to their attention to the differences from our times. For example, paper was a scarcity. It was hard to come by and therefore treated with such respect. It lent to an unbelieveability for much of what happened.
I would absolutely recommend this audiobook. The story is great and well delivered. A great mystery and compelling characters.
I was on the edge of my seat throughout waiting to see how the story turned out, and was not disappointed.
I don't often review books, but I owe this one to my fellow audiobook lovers. Speaks the Nightbird is just awful. If you waste your credit on this tripe, just remember, you were warned!
I agree with the criticisms of the several reviewers who found it trite, inaccurate, and completely unworthy of the 30 hours you'll invest in enduring to the end. When you get there, you'll wish you hadn't bothered.
I don't need to repeat the specific complaints about distracting inaccuracies, historical license, anachronisms, and a completely unlikable main character, all presented in ludicrous, overblown "colonial era" language. I agree completely with what was already pointed out, although I wasn't offended by the profane language, sexual content (deviant and otherwise), etc. Much of that was quite (unintentionally) funny.
I will also add that I found the narrator's performance abysmal, and as overblown as the writing. I became so annoyed with his reading that I nearly stopped listening to it several times. However, my fundamental frugality demanded that "I get my money's worth" and stick it to the end.
I can't understand how this was rated so highly. It just shows that we all see things in a different light.
reader, teacher, writer=happy person
I am unhappy leaving Matthew Corbett's world, even with the mosquitos, mud, murder, small minded people and threat of imminent death on a daily basis. There was also buried treasure, animal magnetism, an untouched world of gasping beauty and a bildungsroman. This is the kind of book you read to escape everyday life, so I refuse to let it go. I am reading the next Matthew Corbett book: The Queen of Bedlam. Hello New York!
I love historical fiction and I truly enjoyed this book. However, despite the fact that I also really enjoy long volumes, this book felt a little slow to me at times. I can't recall that I ever had the feeling that 2 hrs could easily have been cut from the book without losing anything - but in this case I did. I still really enjoyed the characters and their secrets and I'm sure I'll pick up the second book in the series, yet I thought it was a bit slow.
I don't write many reviews, even though I rate every book I listen to. Speaks the Nightbird is a very long book, but I was riveted throughout. Every now and then I find a book that I want to tell everyone to listen to, and this is one of them. Edoardo Ballerini did an excellent job of voicing all of the characters, building and maintaining suspense, and his pacing was perfect for the story. McCammon's writing style displays a dry wit, and a tremendous depth of emotions. This book is an exciting whodunit surrounding a witch trial, but is about so much more.
There are a few disturbing graphic depictions of sexual situations as well as gory deaths. With that said, those scenes have their place in the book and are not gratuitous.
A fine job was done creating the character of Matthew Corbett, and I will definitely listen to the other books in the series.
This book was an adventure for me. I'm determined to stay out of a box when it comes to my choices and I found this book to be well narrated and an interesting story for the time. It was a sort of Scarlet Letter meets, Salem Witch trials. It is richly woven and while not a block buster hang onto your seat kind of read, it was entertaining. I'm glad I listened. Narration was great!
I have recommended this book and the ones to follow to many people. The story is very captivating, and suspenseful. There is a lot going on at all times. Many very interesting characters, and easy to follow.
All of the plots in the books keep you very interested. The author is so descriptive, you can almost smell, feel, and hear what he's describing. There are some gory parts, which I love.
I'm hooked on Edorado Ballerini. That's how I discovered this series. I wanted to continue with books he narrated. I love how he flows from male to female, from English to Italian, and so on. He's telling you a story, not just reading a book.
This book and even more with the following books, I laughed out loud at the funny somewhat sarcastic humor from the author. I also winced and cringed at the descriptions he gave. Very realistic.
I hope there are more books in this series to follow!
The story is compelling and full of historical detail.
I wanted to keep listening to see what was going to happen next.
Mr. Ballerini has a wonderful resonance in his voice and is able to differentiate all the voices with great skill.
Too long to listen in one sitting, but the story has lots of twists and turns so definitely keeps you interested.