Stephen King is one of my favorite authors. This book,although good, does not do the dark tower series justice. The story is okay, it just feels a little too different than the others in the dark tower series. Get the book, it is worth the listen, but if you have not heard any of the other books in the dark tower series, please do not make any assumptions about them based on this book. The Dark Tower series is outstanding and I think everyone should read or listen to it. One other thing, Mr. King narrated Bag of Bones, Needful Things, and other books that were just fine. However, you can not create a series like this one, have it narrated by two other men with the voices they have and then write a book to go in the middle of the series and narrate it yourself! It is not that you are a bad narrator, you are okay at it, but George Guidell and Frank Muller are seasoned narrators with deep powerful voices. I am very sorry Mr. King, your books are excellent, but the choice to read this one yourself was a mistake. If it was re-released, with George Guidell or Frank Muller reading it, I would buy the book again and see if it changed my overall rating much.
I think SK should use another reader, yet my mother likes to listen to him read his books. I am a huge Dark Tower nerd, therefor I loved the story.
Oregon Forester, audio book addict
A great story with-in a story with-in a story. I felt that the book would have been better without having tried to tie it into the Gun Slinger series. It seems to me that making this A Gun Slinger book is an attempt to gather readers. I don't think that this book adds anything to the story of Roland and his clan. All that being said I did enjoy the story a great deal. I personaly would prefer that Stephen King stick to the writing and stay away from the narration, it wasn't bad but I think that another narrator could have made a better performance. My review has some negative points but again I really liked the book and think that it's well worth the scratch, a great listen.
I dont write reviews.... This was fail story.
From a devout lover of the dark tower series.
I push the series on friends as my favorite.
I will recomend this is not added into the mix to enhance their experience.
Yes but didnt change the disappointment. I have enjoyed King as narrator in other stories.
Not ment to be too bold but WOW come on man... give me more of the Ka-tet not B.S. Side story
There are few things better than a good story well told!
Dark Tower 4.5 is a great listen. Mr. King???s imagination and wonderful story telling skills come alive in this tale of Gilead and young Roland. There is a story within the story which is where the cover art comes from. In it there are beasts, swamps, magic, evil, good and a young boy???s quest to rescue his mother from darkness. The Wind Through the Keyhole is more a glimpse of the world in and around Gilead than it is about Roland, Eddie and Suzanna. And while I still think of Frank Muller as the voice of the Dark Tower novels, Mr. King???s narration is very good. I very much recommend this for Dark Tower fans.
While King is no all-star narrator he really isn't that bad and does not detract very much at all from this audio book. I listened to the first four as a set up (3rd? time at least) and that was not necessary but it did let me stockpile some credits. This does not add much to Roland's story, but sheds some light. The story and the story within have connections that do not seem forced - some don't like the connections but I think within the other works that connect and the King as character later in the Tower series that the add a lot to the story(ies). Not sure if I'll finish them all again - hate to lose Oy again.
My reviews are honest. No sugar coating here.
I've been reading a lot of reviews that the narration is bad from Stephen King for this audio book. I have to disagree. Maybe I'm just used to of listening to Stephen King's voice, but I don't mind and really don't find him annoying. In many ways, it gives authenticity of the Dark Tower series.
Sure, King is nowhere close from the late Frank Muller (RIP), but I enjoy listening to King's voice. I've read all of his books and King has narrated a great number of his novels, such as Bag of Bones, On Writing, and many other of his short stories. By narrating more of his materials, the constant reader gets an insight of what characters should resemble in the author's imagination.
As for the story in "The Wind Through the Keyhole", it took me a while to get into the book. I have forgotten how complex the Dark Tower series and how Roland tells his story within another story. It's brilliant how all of his stories intertwined with each other and you finally get a bizarre outcome.
I felt soft hearted when I heard Roland, Eddie, Jake, Susannah, and Oy, again.
This is why we are "Constant Readers."
In order to comprehend the full story, one needs to read from book one (Gunslinger) and read the complete series.
The Dark Tower series is the best set of books that you will ever read and or, listen to.
I am a D-Bag.
A story in a story in a story in the middle of a series after the ending had already been written. Make sense? It will when you read it.All and all it was alright on about par with the other Roland Baggo books.
King did a good job reading this book. I like his style he does well for an author. Frank Mueller was the best and would have nailed this book but he took a header off his bike on the black top. Shame a real loss to the auido book field.
yes,I would advise anyone thinking about becoming involved in the "Tower"series to read this one.
It ties a lot together.Gives depth to Roland's character.
his narative style is very addictive.The pronunciation was superb.
Come,let me tell you a story about a boy becoming a" man of his times"The tale will be tall.The deeds will be large.You will believe!!"
These were the stories Mr. King was born to write.They are the stories we long to hear!
The greatest thing about this book was narration by the author. The words were spoken as he envisioned them, and it made a huge difference for me. I loved it! To have the author read his story to you added another dimension to the Dark Tower saga.
The adventure the boy went on was riveting and especially loved him stepping right on a dragon.