John Scalzi's sense of humor as usual makes this a fun read.
Excellent job on the voices and tone.
Several laugh out loud moments.
Not quite on par with some other Scalzi work, like Old Man's War, but still a great "listen."
I listen to books while running and walking my dog so on average about an hour day and like books that have a good pace to them.
I bought this book expecting a star trek parody but was pleased to find that it was so much more than that. Although this book focused on a group of "red shirts" and appears for a while to be a simple parody it quickly moves beyond that and in acknowledging its erstwhile source material offers a much more interesting perspective on science fiction television.
I expected there to be a villain in this story for the first third but as the story unfolded it became rich with interesting detail that built into a much more complicated scenario involving time travel and other machinations that I will not reveal. Needless to say, an apparently simple solution proves much more complex in this well crafted tale.
There were times when I got a little confused with some of the characters, in part because of the brief role some played, but overall this was well narrated.
Very good book.
While he generally had good emotion, the repeated "blah blah said... blah blah said... blah blah said" got annoying.
No longer a reader of the Dead Tree Scrolls
Oh yes, because of Wil Wheaton!
I loved it all
Wil Wheaton is my favorite narrator, he is superb in this as he is in everything
It was quite funny, it moved me to laugh!
This book is good, not great, just good. Scalzi's writing style is a bit out of place in audiobook form, as none of his dialog flows. Scalzi makes a point to add "she said", "he said", etc. after every piece of dialog and therefore translates to audiobook in a very jerky and difficult to follow style. This is why Wil Weaton feels a bit out of place. He's trying to audibly read a book that's not meant to be read aloud.
The story is good, funny, and witty. And whereas the main story is well done, I wish it was more fleshed out. Things move quickly. Honestly, I felt the best portion of the book was the Second Coda. The Second Coda is extremely well written and is perfectly suited for narration. It's a shame the entire book wasn't in the same style.
Great idea for a story, and it was pretty hilarious at times.
Wil has a pretty distinct voice which was nice because of the familiarity; but he didn't change his voice ever for different characters. Long strings of dialogue just kind of mesh together and are hard to follow. Lots of he said, she said, he said, he said.
I didn't really like the Coda's.
The narration by Wil Wheaton is great. The story itself is cutesy but it feels fairly short and it's not really deep or significant in any way. It almost comes across as Star Trek fan fiction. I kept thinking maybe I got the wrong book. THIS won a Hugo award??
Overall it was entertaining but it just wasn't a seminal, thought provoking piece of sci-fi literature like I was expecting. It's a fun, light hearted story that is only decently written. The world of the book is based on a fictional Sci-fi TV show that is campy and poorly written, so as a result the writing and story of the book are sometimes... well, campy and poorly written.
Is it fun? Yes. Does it belong on a list with other Hugo award winners like Ender's Game, Stranger in a Strange Land or Ringworld? No.
The story its self was bland and kind of cliche, but the codas that followed the story were very interesting and better than the book its self.
It is funny and ironic that an actor from star trek would narrate a book that is a spoof on the lazy writing from star trek, that said Mr. Wheaton narrates the book very well
The codas were excellent in particular the second was amazing
This is definitely a story for sci fi fans people who are unfamiliar with star trek style books and movies will probably not enjoy this novel.
The Publisher’s Summary does not represent the book very well. Read the reviews before choosing this one.
“Redshirts” was amusing but also “so what” … I didn’t find it to be the book of laughs so many others here did; nor “intriguing”. Although I did wonder which came first this, or “Galaxy Quest”; the latter is the better “read” (great casting showed out).
All of it probably is a better read than listen; especially post story deconstructions; these throw into doubt all that has gone before and all that is until the final word. But this is more like an in-joke than anything else … very much an “emperor’s new clothes” moment for me. I gave up part way through the first coda.
Wil Wheaton’s reading, which so well suited Android’s Dram, seems forced; a bit board with all the ‘he said’ / ‘she said”. Part of the problem may be that the sound is a little muted; but maybe that’s part of the pun.
Get “Android’s Dream” instead.
I have come to really like John Scalzi's books. I started listening to his very short stories, and am now getting his novels and the same thrall of listening is in them all. I totally enjoy the reader of the book, he 'makes' the books, also.