This is a must read for students of American History, or those curious about the modern days presidents and their relations. It may very well change your perception about one or two of the last ten or so presidents.
We enjoyed listening to this and had a lot to talk about during and after we heard the book. The political caricitures become human characters. The polarizing black and white of each era is dispelled by welcome persepective.
There are human beings, mere human beings, who could make the choice to destroy our planet. The President of the United States is one of these people. This is an unimaginable burden.
The Presidents??? Club traces the relationships between various Presidents. The main theme is that that only former Presidents can understand the enormity and immense loneliness of the position. There are tears, heartbreak ??? the raw emotions of immense egos, greed, compassion, wisdom, fear, love ??? and that ever present question: how will the future judge me. We are given images of Reagan teaching Clinton how to salute, Clinton???s advice on making speeches being sought by Bush 43, Truman being ignored by Ike, the deep friendship between Bush 41 and Clinton, the personal as well as political challenges presented to Johnson and Ford following the Kennedy assassination, Nixon fixated on self redemption, Carter with almost unrestrained idealism. Of particular poignancy was the relationship between the two Bushes.
The reader is taken through presidential relationships in a calm, factual manner, supported by an authoritative but tired narrator. To my mind, this book amounted to a well researched, very lengthy magazine article. Different points of view were rarely included ??? that would have detracted from the narrative. Instead it sounds like homage to the positive presidential relationships, and almost a dismissal of those who really didn???t want to play the games of this club.
I don???t feel that the disorder, the messiness and brutality, the fears, bewildering information, the brinkmanship, the risks, and the immense decisions emerging from the constant avalanche of advice, were sufficiently explored.
Sentimentality pervades this account. The authors seem driven to discover -- or imagine, or create -- threads of a presidential family.
Very informative and real behind the scenes activities and relationships explored. Also I found it interesting the closeness of the past Presidents, even though the public had a very different perception because of media.
No - I would consider more.
The same as the book - It is a "club" and after listening to the book, I now understand why.
joe the shmoe
I felt like I was allowed inside an amazing secret society.
Whether I loved these individuals or not, I had a new appreciation for the sheer terror the office of President must often present.
His reading brings a lyrical timing to the prose much like Sinatra did for a song.
This book focuses on the interactions between the Presidents. It only used history as a narrative to give depth to the reasons why past Presidents work with current ones. I am in my 30's and found it very interesting to see how much Eisenhower helped Kennedy. How involved Reagan was in national politics before he became President in the 80's. The stories were extremely interesting to history buffs. I actually wish that they had spent more time on the Clinton/Bush II years and less on Nixon, but overall it was a very interesting read.
Detailed, Historical, Important
I learned more and appreciated more about every president. Their need for confidants and trust was evident and important to learn about. How, even those that history may not appreciate, that they were all extremely helpful and knowledgable and appreciative of America and their successors and predecessors.. I really loved every bit of the book. I can't think of even one criticism.
I like listinening to my books at 3x the speed and when going that fast he was still very clear and understandable.
One of the top stories-restored my faith in all the men who have held the job of President since Truman. It is high level gossip about the workings of the Presidency and the comradarie that they held for one another, given that only they know how difficult a job it is..I thoroughly enjoyed the book and was disappointed when it came to the end, as I could not listen to any more stories..
For me there is no comparison - it felt unique.
No - I liked prolonging the read as I used it on my daily walks - it was a treat that I looked forward to every day.
I gained more respect for the office and it made me more hopeful about politics overall.
nice.....not THRILLING....but nice. Just ok in my book. Was hoping for more but it just wasn't there. If you are that interested in the ex Presidents then read their biographies. Nothing new here.
We vote them into the highest office in the land; we make them superstars; we envy their savoir faire; and we want them to be greater than the sum of the parts they had to play to get there. And, they aren't. They may fool the rest of us, but they can't fool one another, and politics is a nasty business. Favors are won, favors paid back, sneers never quite forgotten, and that is where this book becomes fascinating. Helping or hating, criticizing or praising -- they are members of an exclusive club, and each brings something unique to the table.. In reading it, you find Eisenhower was a general all of his life and bears a good deal of responsibility for what happened in Vietnam and that Nixon was far nastier than we knew. You find that Ford really did take the fall for the good of the country, and that Kennedy was like an uncertain prep school freshman when the Bay of Pigs fiasco blew up. about some things and infinitely wise about others. Johnson's tragedy becomes your own. You discover some of Ronald Reagan's unexpected cohorts, and, if you are like me at all, you will come away with a different view of the Presidency and the men who occupy that American throne. It is a great book to listen to while working out!