I enjoyed every minute of the story. Me. Whelan did an excellent job narrating. I could feel Elizabeth's emotions.

I have read this book several times; it really is a great story -- a bit scary, a bit enlightening and very emotional. I just get drawn into Elizabeth/Abigail's life and what it might have been like if just one small thing has been different.

I love Burt. Not a dog person, but have told my husband over and over I want a "Burt"

Excellent vocals; always able to understand every word

Absolutely and have

I have this book in hardback, on DVD and now on Audible. I can read it anytime I want; again and again.

Great story, enjoyed immensely. performance was well done without taking from the story. well done.

I can't ever recall reading a Nora Roberts book though I have read one or 2 JD Robb books which were futuristic mysteries. This book was, in a word, amazing.

The story started with a long overdue, in my opinion, teenage rebellion which led to disastrous consequences. After the stage was set, the book fast forwarded 12 years and enter our hero, Brooks. He is not your typical hero. Rather, he has a wonderful demeanor and affability that simply has you admiring him. And to watch Liz, now known as Abigail, slowly, very slowly transform, is one of the sweetest and endearing storylines I've read in a long, long time.

As Brooks is the Chief of Police, there are many subplots that turn this from a novel to more of a real-life type story.

Not that I didn't enjoy some of the Lieutenant Eve Dallas books...they were truly fictional. This book has a more "real" feel to it and was masterfully written.

Julia Whelan did a wonderful job narrating. So, yes, this is definitely a book you can and should read.

I liked the characters. I thought Elizabeth/Abigail and Brooke were developed nicely and I really liked them. It was fairly light but interesting with some fun plot twists. However, the continued swearing using some pretty intense words and some subject matter did not add to the story and actually was pretty distracting. And with listening it is pretty difficult to skip over. To bad. It was a fun read otherwise.

One of my favorite authors. The performance was outstanding and well paced. New to audio books and this one sold me!

Good book but lacked suspense. Had many opportunities for it but never went anywhere, You want a good ending but need the excitement along the way!

great story, good narration but details on sex,cual acts not apprecoated. narration was good suspense in the story was great but without sexual detail

Enjoyed the story very much. It was nice to see that everything ended well for Liz

overall great book!! rarely do i get attached to characters, but this book really got me tied up and rooting for Elizabeth.