I like Mr. Churchill's Secretary! Like many first books in a series Ms. MacNeal wanted to tell you everything about everyone so some parts were tedious. Overall I enjoyed the book and I did not figure who the duplicitous character was until very near the revolution point. This was very cleverly done.
I did find one mistake. I am not sure if it was written incorrectly and the editor missed it or if the narrator misspoke. However, it was Edward VIII who abdicated for the woman he loved not Edward VII.
If found it easy to listen to as I drove to and from work. you can follow what is happening without taking away from paying attention to road.
I plan to get the second book and will follow the series as it progresses.
The last few chapters were the best but isn't that usually the case with a mystery. I particularly liked the last scene between Mr. Frame and Michael Murphy.
Wanda McCaddon (Donada Peters) does a good job of narrating the book. Her lovely British accents are very well done and you just can't get that when reading. She does a darn good American accent for Maggie too.
Depending who was in the cast I would go see it. It might make a better "made for TV" movie than a feature film but still the casting is everything.
Time spent was okay since I commute an hour each way. But I almost bailed on the story. Just does not move well, not much of a plot, and in my opinion the character development seemed weak. I never seemed to really get a feel for each of the characters, poorly developed. Almost felt like Churchill was a cartoon-like character.
Narration was fine...but as with most audio files, chapter starts and finishes seemed clipped.
Maybe spend a little more effort looking for a good historical novel dealing with this period.
I really like the premise, but the writing is almost schoolgirl level. It is very predictable and never achieves any level of sophistication, The author has the girls thinking in the present way of thinking and not of the 1940s times so obviously no research was done into the way they thought, and talked back then. I know for I have done such research and was not impressed with this authors writing on it.
No, unless the script writer was amazing.
I am a one time English major, a lifelong reader, gardener, culinary experimenter, and fiber arts artisan. A perfect day for me is spent working with my hands while listening to an absorbing book. I love history and horticulture.
I enjoyed this book about young woman who finds herself working at Number 10 Downing Street during WWII. It reminded me of other books I had read that were set during the same period in England, but pleasantly so. I am a longtime reader of British Lit and fan of BBC TV. This book reminded me of the fantastic series Foyle's War, which I recently watched on Netflix. Some likable characters and a few surprises.
I'm not sure if any of my friends are interested in the same things I am. This book did not shake my tree. The performance was quite good. The basic idea was intriguing. It was a bit of a cookie cutter type style.
WWII and Churchill
There were interesting tid bits.
This was a not bad story completely spoiled by a narrator who attempted accents so badly that it was hard to tell where Lancashire ended and Atlanta Georgia began. The accents were so irritating that they detracted from the story. I was sorely disappointed as it was an interesting premise.
Yes! This is a very engaging story, right from the beginning. The narrator is very easy to listen to and you always know which character is speaking. I love the fact that this book is about women in WWII, though sometimes it makes the men look like bumbling idiots. That part I didn't like. But I found myself rooting for our heroine in her struggles against the mighty brotherhood of men. I loved it mostly because it entertained me.
Since this is a book about women, she helps round out that perspective.
I absolutely loved listening to this narrator read this book. It was wonderfully written and read. Wanda McCaddon excellently switched from character to character without over doing any of it. Her accents were perfect, her male voices believable.
Susan MacNeal wrote a wonderful story, truly making me feel like I was in London during WWII. Her descriptions were full but not flowery nor tedious. She made me feel like I was friends with Maggie and David.
I cannot wait to read more by MacNeal and would listen to anything read by McCaddon.
Such a nice combination of spy thriller and actual history. Totally enjoyable for anyone who likes suspense combined with history of WW II in England. And very well read. Wish there was more like it!
I wanted to like this book but the overly simplistic plotting and writing were a disappointment. It seems like I was reading a book aimed at a Jr High audience.