Although I've just discovered that free will in an illusion and that my thoughts and opinions are not truly my own in any real sense, my opinion remains:
This is an excellently crafted book about a truly fascinating and ultimately life changing realization. Free will does not exist and understanding this will change your life for the better.
Read and decide for yourself.
This short-format book -- a long essay, really -- explains the complex issues surrounding the presumptions and assumptions of free will through the enlightening lens of neuroscience. From the philosophical arguments about the nature of free will, to experiments that show a person's choice occurs several seconds before they are aware of the decision, Harris paints a clear picture of the true nature of what we feel is our own will to act or decide, and follows with how the truth about our decisions can and should influence the public debate on crime, punishment, and responsibility. The book is long enough to cover all of the bases and short enough to leave your evening free to discuss it with your mate; I cannot recommend this book more!
Yes. Since I have read it, I have changed my mind on free will and become a compatibilist, so I would like to go back and listen to Harris's arguments again. Particularly convincing was Harris's comparison between psychopaths, people with brain tumors who kill people, and people who kill "just for the fun of it".
It is simply and concise.
Unlike his other books, the central thesis is wrong. Free will actually exists. Once you get past that, it is as good as his other books.
When he says that there is no significant difference between people who murder for different reasons because all of them are acting because of factors outside of their control. It demonstrates that we are not the agent of our actions, which most people seem to think.
If you read this, please also read Freedom Evolves, by Daniel Dennett.
No it was OK
I would not. My friend would not be interested. Different tastes I guess. I would recommend it to others though.
The troll wizard of course…
Not Applicable to this book.
No. I can see how this could be a movie.
Maybe, but not if it is as short as this one.
The subject interested me and I started listening with a lot of anticipation, but the most interesting part was the beginning, where a set of very interesting experiments was presented; thereafter, it was all a bit anticlimactic.
It was more a lecture than a book. Which is OK, but I was expecting a book that develops the subject at greater length. But it is not a lecture I regret having listened to.
This is the first book I've read from Sam Harris. I loved the subject matter and the conciseness with which it was presented. I also enjoyed his narration. Love that he points out that punishment is still possible as a preventative measure, we didn't need free will, good or evil to legitimize it. We just need to consider the effects of punishment in the long run. Fascinating, I could listen to much more on this subject.
I thought I would find scholarly ammunition for what I personally am coming to believe about free will. I usually enjoy and understand Sam Harris, in his blog and in other books. But this was too scholarly and did not reach me.
Yes, because I think it encourages people to consider a new perspective that they may not have had access to.
The comparisons that are made.
At first, I found his speaking style alitle hard to follow, but by the time I reached the second or third chapter, I was accustomed to it and it became clear without having to rewind and re listen.One thing I appreciated was that he wrote the book to be accessible to more people by opting for more common words instead of long, uncommon ones... I only had to pause the book maybe 3 times to look up a word.
FREE WILL... You may beleive in it, but you may not have a choice.
The possible new perspective is well worth the relatively low price of the book.
Simply not enough time in the world to read all the books I want to, so now I listen to them.
I already have. It is very short, so it is a very very quick listen. It lays out the argument for and against free will in fairly easy to understand ways. I wished it was longer.
Not really worth using a credit on this book, but very worth the few dollars it cost me.