I did not read the print version (this is the only Anne Tyler book I have listened to in audio) but as a devoted fan of Ms. Tyler's writing, believe that either version could deliver the emotional effect commonly found in Ms. Tyler's books.
The protagonist Aaron Woolcott. The true sorrow and love he describes when speaking of his wife, in spite of all the imperfections in their relationship-and themselves-was beautiful and heart wrenching.
I loved the narration. Mr. Heyborne's reading brought me to tears.
I remember howling out loud years ago when I read Accidental Tourist. And for some reason I never went back to any other of her books after that one. But this book does not have that same draw. It is a dull story of a dull man who married a dull woman and had a dull sister. I gave up. Narration was fine but it didn't help this boring, awful book.
I honestly don't think anyone could like this book. The main character is so whiny and bratty. The guy reading the book I think did a really excellent job of being annoying, and whiny, and bratty, that's why I gave him 5 stars.
She would have to completely re-write the book for me to have enjoyed this more.
I hated his performance, because it was spot on. He was exactly who the main character was meant to be. Too bad for me that I hated the main character.
The entire thing.
In the beginning, he talks about how his wife came back from the dead and he says that other people can see her too. Then the next several chapters are backstory, and when he finally gets to the part where she "comes back from the dead", absolutely nothing is mentioned about others being able to see her. In the beginning of the book he also makes it out to see like him seeing her is a regular occurrence, when in reality it only happens maybe 4 times.
The author did a good job of describing grief after losing a loved one.
Yes - Gone Girl. Performance was about the same, but better story.
I would pick the contractor. He seemed the best adjusted.
author of books for teens and children
I have read all of Anne Tyler's books. She's one of my favorite authors. This book is terrific like her others. The protagonist is a stubborn young widower who walks with a cane and has trouble overcoming his grief. He is fully fleshed out, and surrounded by fun, quirky friends, coworkers, and relatives. If you like smart, character-driven novels with humor and poignancy, you can't do much better than an Anne Tyler novel such as this one.
Since I have been a fan of Anne Tyler's beautiful writing since I was a young adult and discovered that I loved quirky, heart-warming stories about difficulty lives. Each of us can relate to moments throughout each of her stories. This beautiful story, well- performed will be something that you will look forward to listening to till the very end. So glad I own it.
I'll be the first to say that Anne Tyler is one of America's finest contemporary novelists, but I couldn't help feeling a lot of been-there-read-that while listening to 'The Beginner's Goodbye'.
While Tyler's honed storytelling style and Heyborn's fine narrative got me through the book, I was bored by a too familiar cast of characters involved in yet another long, slow slide toward healing.
(huh: maybe I'm getting jaded in my old age....)
This is just a wonderful story about couples and family. While telling ourselves that we treat them fairly with kindness and thoughtfulness we learn lessons along the way that we were not nearly as kind to them as we were ourselves.
This is a well written story about human nature. I enjoyed it a great deal, while complipating the story long after the final words in the book. It would be lovely if we could all see the bigger picture like many of the characters in this book fortunately got to see.
There is no Frigate like a Book To take us Lands away Nor any Coursers like a Page Of prancing Poetry – Emily Dickinson
What a sweet little book! Anne Tyler is certainly good at describing the small details of life and relationships. I found myself nodding and agreeing with so many of her observations about some of the smallest but telling details about life. However, overall these telling moments didn't really add up to much of a plot or make me particularly fond of the characters.
By the end, or the last 1/4 I'd say, I did feel a connection with Aaron and felt happy that he seemed to learn, in the end, that the most important thing about a relationship, with all of its human flaws and problems, is that both people need to appreciate each other while they still have the chance. The author has a minor character, Luke, state this theme overtly at the very end:
"My friend Luke told me once that he’d been considering my question about whether the dead ever visit. It was true that I had asked him, back around the time I asked Nate, but this was weeks and weeks later. Apparently he had been deliberating the issue ever since. “I’ve decided,” he said, “that they don’t visit. But I think if you knew them well enough, if you’d listened to them closely enough while they were still alive, you might be able to imagine what they would tell you even now. So the smart thing to do is, pay attention while they’re living. But that’s only my opinion.”
It is so simple and tried and true, and I WILL say that this book DOES do a good job of SHOWING that lesson. It just that it's a bit of a bore, with insightful moments breaking it up, along the way. Then, in the end, it packs a powerful, emotional lesson. I hope it sticks with me.
The story had very little plot and moved extremely slowly. Given the quality of the work, even the best-quality narration wouldn't have improved the experience. However, and unfortunately, the narrator made the story even more ponderous.
The description was poetic, but the plot was thin and the pace slow.
His voice was annoying and his pace made a slow story even slower.
Frustration that I couldn't move the story along, and disappointment that Anne Tyler's work this time around couldn't hold a candle to past work.