Beautiful language and a familiar story but I never really cared for the characters. Frazier Douglas did an admirable job and despite knowing the classic tale I couldn't for the life of me understand why thoughtful Greeks would want to spend 10 years trying to capture Troy. At the end I wish that Hector had overcome Achilles and his meddling Goddess mother!
I would recommend this however this love story is not for everyone because of who it is about.
Oh I don't know, this stands alone for me right now. No comparisons needed.
His voice, rather his voices, of these characters was done so well! When I read a book I can "hear" the different voices in my head and Frazer Douglas may have outdid how I would've heard them! He was brilliant, his narration made the story come alive! The images were painted in brilliant color which made it real and full and rich! The
narration was a perfect match of story and voice brought together. When this happens it is near impossible to stop listening until its over!
That's an interesting question... I think I would like to have dinner with the entire cast of characters!
This story is a little bit of ancient Greek myth history mixed with a romance that transcends time and place. It all comes together beautifully and is painted in living colors by an incredible rich and full narration!
This is not a simple retelling of he Iliad, but an original contribution to the homeric poem. Miller's Song makes Achilles a lot more sympathetic than in the original poem and brings Patroclus to the foreground. The language is terse and beautiful, the metaphors appropriate to the setting, and the characterizations vivid and realistic. Although the author makes substantial contributions to the story of the war at Troy, adding a prequel and a touching, satisfying finale, the original material is handled with such care and reverence that it reads like a love letter to Homer. Absolutely beautiful.
Definitely near the top! I love grown up fairy tales, and this fit the bill. I was familiar with the mythology of Achilles, and to have an author so beautifully write a story around it was a real treat. I don't know if I would have enjoyed reading it as much as I did listening. Mr. Douglas has to be the best "reading actor" I've ever heard. The relationships between Achilles and the people around him are perfectly understood; was it the writing or the reading? Definitely had to be both.
It was a mix between a very good historical fiction novel and a fantasy novel; Gregory Macguire comes to mind, with his portrayal of Oz. I've never read a book just like this.
Oh my gosh! His timing is phenomenal, his character changes weren't over the top, but just subtle enough that the difference was engaging. My favorite character reading was that of Achilles. He somehow had "otherworld" in his voice.
Achilles goddess mother. Spooky, touching, powerful.
The love scenes were subtle and moving.
Great story well told and well read. I struggled with The Iliad and The Odyssey when I read them at university. This modern take on the story of Achilles provided a way into the story that worked for me.
The point at which narrator began to speak after his death. I had wondered how the author would pull that off. She did it well!
This is simply one of the very best Audible books I've yet listened to. Miller's prose and Douglas's narration are unsurpassed. I've read several books based on Homer's works, but this is the only one I can think of that I'd recommend to everyone and anyone. Yes, the details of the intimacy between the two men made me feel a little uncomfortable, but that tells you more about me than it does about the book. (All you macho guys that are afraid others will think you're gay because you listened to this book just pretend that you fast forwarded passed 'those' parts). The details of the violence of the battles made me feel even more uncomfortable, but I survived them as well. Knowing all but the details of how it was to end did not spoil a single minute. The story was moving, believable, and made me wish for more. I give this five stars only because I cannot give it six. A must listen. An absolute must.
Very near the top. Loved the story line.
Comparing to Phillipa Gregory's type of presentation. Love the character personalities and the believability of them as individuals. Song of Achillies is a very well presented mythological story and if you are a myth buff, this is perfect for a listen.
His voice characterizations are very honest and distinctive. Easy to fall into each one of them with his narration.
I felt the entire presentation combined with the story line was great.
Buy the book. You won't be sorry. I will probably listen a second time.
Before buying this title I listened to the first few minutes and was caught like a fish on a hook. It was fast paced and fascinating—historical fiction that promised to take me back to the birth of civilization. Turns out, that was just the back story. The rest of the book, or at least the rest that I could stand to listen to, was an insipid boy's account of his romantic homosexual desires for an impossibly perfect cliche of a character, who may or may not be a god. Yes the gods, not to mention centaurs, are real in this book. The plotting is tedious, merely an excuse to separate the lovers briefly, then conveniently unite them again. And when they are united BTW, the author jumps to the dawn every time. She hasn't the nerve or imagination to give account to the sex. But she's very good at describing pounding hearts and sweaty chests. The narration is not helped by the readers' attempts to portray feminine voices.
No. The homosexual lust became more of a distraction than an enhancement. This book read more like a gay Harlequin bodice-ripper than an historical fiction. Although there have been centuries of speculation whether Achilles and Patroclus were lovers or just comrades in arms, Miller removed all doubt -- in more detail than I prefer. The first incident I dismissed as youthful androgynous fascination of the plain for the beautiful, regardless of sex. The second was more specific, and other occasions were even more graphic. An analysis of the fascination with feet would power a master's thesis for a literature major, or a psychologist. Although I commend Miller's ability to write about sexual encounters without devolving into crass profanity, I still would have preferred this story -- which is otherwise very well written -- to avoid the thrusting, sticky, strokes that occupied so much of the text.
He was able to vary the voices of the characters in ways that helped paint their personalities very realistically.
No. I would have preferred to read this book as text, so I could skip over the tedious grope and moan sections and get to the real story.