How different the story was from the film. My favorite parts of the story weren't in the film.
I thought the narration was good.
Wizard of Oz - Un Tarnished
A school administrator and avid reader and listener of books. At least an hour of every day is spent in the car, and that's where the bulk of my listening is done. I tend to listen to books on "faster" mode so I can get through more books!
The movie was an icon of my youth, and yet I never read the book until this week, and the age of 44. What a great book, and better than the movie, which seems nearly impossible. Baum's imagination and the story he crafted is one of interest, courage, and compassion. The characters are more developed and rich than those in the movie, and Dorothy's quest is more satisfying. Anne Hathaway's narration is outstanding, and I hope she narrates more books!
Moving further from work extended my daily commute... thank God for Audible.
What a surprise. I grew up with the 1939 film adaption and therefore can’t remember a moment in my life when I didn’t “know” the Oz narrative. But this was my first encounter with the original text and I was charmed from the first sentence.
I guess the film doesn’t stray too far from the original. But I had a great time spotting the differences when they did appear (and then trying to guess the motivation for MGM introducing those changes into the film). Overall, I think the book is considerably more charismatic than the film – and that is intended as seriously high praise.
Reading other reviewers, it seems the most divisive element of this particular reading is Anne Hathaway’s voice characterizations. I listened to this recording with my three primary-school-aged boys, and I believe it was the voice-acting that kept them glued to the speakers. So for my money, Hathaway did a fantastic job and definitely deserves a five-star rating. But I can also understand how it grated on some people (I’m guessing adults who were listening without kids?).
This engaging story has truly stood the test of time, and really does deserve its reputation as a classic.
I have always enjoyed this story
Her narration of the story is not as good as I thought it was
It's a fabulous and engaging story.
The performance was phenomenal! This is the first audiobook I've listened to with my children and I wasn't sure if they'd enjoy listening to books as much as I do. They are enthralled with this book and the performance and can't wait to get back in the car to listen.
She does such a good job with the different characters as well as the narration. Her performance is no doubt the reason my little girls love this book so much.
For anyone thinking of trying an audiobook with their children, this is the perfect book with which to try. We may even listen a second time!
Too much with the silly voices, which detracted from Ms. Hathaway's flawless narration. Otherwise this would've been perfect.
I couldn't help but compare this to the 1939 movie (Judy Garland as Dorothy) production that I saw on television when I was a teenager because that movie created a very special image of the story in my memory. I have to say that this production (Anne Hathaway's narration) is as good but also in a different way. Anne Hathaway is just amazing in narrating different characters in the story (and I wasn't particularly a big fan of this actress in movies). She creates a special world out of this story. She must have gone through a lot of trouble preparing for playing more than ten different characters. As a teenager, I thought the story had (cute) flaws (e.g., a brainless scarecrow wouldn't be asking for a brain if he did not have a brain, etc.), but now that I am an adult, I could just enjoy the way this brilliant actress presents the story. I highly recommend this audiobook.
I greatly enjoyed the story Baum wrote, and don't know why I waited so many years to "read" it. I found Hathaway's performance quote enjoyable as well. She was able to bring a few different voices to the characters and I think it added a nice touch. Children would probably enjoy listening to her read this book to them, and as an adult, I can say I liked it as well.
The world of Oz is full of fantastic people and strange things, and I can't wait to get back into it in the other Oz books.
What a wonderful story! Most people with a casual or nostalgic interest in The Wizard of Oz will be delightfully surprised to find out the book is wonderful but different than the movie. Many things in the movie musical mirror the book quite closely but there is much in the book that is not in the movie. So my three words are Wonderful, Surprised, and Delightful!
What I enjoyed most about listening to this book was re-discovering Oz in all its wonder. And finding out there is more to the Land of Oz than I had ever thought or expected.
Anne Hathaway does an outstanding job of performing this book. There are many different types of characters in this book, from mice to flying monkeys, she portrays each character with a unique voice that if you just read the book, instead of listening, would be lost.
Anne Hathaway does a fantastic job throughout the book! I was not expecting to hear a distinct voice and accent for each character from her. I especially enjoyed her portrayal of the Cowardly Lion. This is definitely one to come back to and listen to over and over again!