I really wanted to like this; it had been recommended to me by 2 people whose recommendations I usually love. However, it didn't quite do it for me. I found the structure of the story -- a retelling of history from one person to another - was a bit contrived, and I don't think successful in this application. i kept hoping it would take flight, but i never felt that it did. I found the narrator contributed to this too - not the best choice for this story.
This is my first audiobook so maybe I just have to get used to it. My reading voice would have been so different from the narrators, and I found it irritating at times. Too cute.
I found the story overly sentimental and implausible.
I haven't listened to other narrators so I don't know. I didn't like the voices she chose, especially for MiMi.
U Ma was an interesting and compelling character and story teller.
I really enjoyed this story, it was highly recommended to me so I really did not know what to expect! This is right up there with Cutting for Stone. Very well written and hard to stop listening to and a surprise ending. I also highly recommend it!
Probably not. I couldn't relate to the characters at all.
I couldn't connect with the story. I found the mysterious, airy mental qualities of the main character overdone and weaving that with the story didn't work for me.
I couldn't relate to the characters at all.
I am an avid "reader"- I prefer to listen to books rather than read them due to the added dimension added by the narrator.
I could not stop listening to this book. Often, I can't get into a book if the beginning does not grab me right away. This one did that and more. It is a story of the most beautiful and enduring love that spans two continents. The characters are unusual... a boy who goes blind and a girl with club feet who begin as friends and ultimately become lovers. This is probably one of the top 10 books I have read and is in the same place in my heart as Cutting for Stone and 1000 Splendid Suns. It's that good. Rarely do we see such an unselfish love. It was humbling to read The Art of Hearing Heartbeats.
5 starts. Couldn't put it down. Very soothing narrator. Pulls you writ into the story.
Tin and MiMi. I felt that they were the perfect fit for each other. Each had obstacles to overcome.
This is the first
Well this is hard because I liked both Tin and MiMi.
Truly a wonderful story.
Unless I will be recommended by a person whose opinion and tatse I trust, definitely I will not try any book by J.-Ph. Sendker as I really had to force myself to listen to this one. Something not in my line. As for the performance, it is really good, so Cassandra Campbell has managed to do a great job on a poor material.
I do not know. Just to write something different.
Beautiful beyond description
Two simple people, in a country and time so different from what we know, overcome profound tests of character through love. They possess faith which sustains them through painful years of separation. This is a story about wealth, both spiritual and monetary. It is told in a way that brings the listener into the sights, sounds, even smells of the lands and people. It is far more than a love story, although it is that. There is hardship, discovery, struggle, loyalty and triumph. The central characters, who come together in childhood, seem simple at first, but as the story unfolds their true strength shines. This story lifted me up with joy yet brought me to tears.
This is a touching and painful story. A gifted writer and fantastic narrator. Among the good in this world there is always evil...life is so difficult until you think of others problems....it makes you grateful.....this book shows this so well.
A mother, a wife, part-time professional trying to fit it all in...
The reason why this book is so good is because the writing is so descriptive and poetic. You can feel what the characters feel, and the imagery that develops in your mind, as you hear the words, places you right there where the characters are. If this is a translated version, i can't imagine how much more wonderful the original version would be.