Great narration and interesting story line. If you love British mysteries, this is a good one.
I really like this style of mystery - police procedural, interesting protagonist detective, set between the wars in England. I thought the main character was really quite well drawn. However, I found the story somewhat confusing and the mystery itself implausible and almost irrelevant. I liked all the ingredients, but for me the story itself was not interesting. Also, all of these characters who take on each others' identity. That whole thing didn't work for me, and didn't seem to have any point or plausibility.
The main character is very interesting and likeable. I was hoping for more involvement with his sister, who only appears in one scene but is also engaging. I might try number 2 in the series, eventually. An okay listen, but not as good as i had hoped. Nicely narrated, though, except for the terrible attempt at a scottish accent Xb
This British detective procedural is fair. I enjoy a bit more of a pace in my mysteries.
I just could not get pulled into this novel. Too much talk and little else.
Haven't read, only listened. But, the reader is superb, so I lean toward the audio version.
The continuation of a most intriguing character, Ian Rutledge. The author has refined and expanded him with each new book.
His conversations with the rector.
It was "moving" throughout the entire book.
The main character, Scotland Yard Inspector Ian Rutledge, has grown and expanded as a character in each book of the series. Todd tells wonderful stories, with excellent character development - and the tricks and turns of the mystery are always fascinating.
loved it from beginning to end.characters well developed. the narrator is skilled at giving each character voice and personality in voice inflections and accents.
I really can't stand Simon Prebble's Scottish accent - it's awful.
Generally good, just can't do a Scottish accent at all (I know, more than 3 words!!)
Was very long and too wordy I completely lost track of what was going on was glad when it was over
This novel has a lot of characters both past and present - at times I found the book confusing, probably because I listened to it in small segments during my short commute to work and this did not do it justice. I have found the Ian Rutledge novels are best listened to for longer stretches and they are engrossing enough to be enjoyed that way.
I have listened to this series in order, which is great, but I think any of the books could stand alone. I highly recommend the series and the books and both the narrators who read them. I haven't read any of these in print so I can't compare.