Simon Prebble has read most of the audio versions of Charles Todd's, and his readings are wonderful. Very rich and painful and macabre, much like the inspector himself. This wasn't my favorite of the series, but as usual, Prebble weaves the tale like a good play. You won't want to stop listening.
Great narration and interesting story line. If you love British mysteries, this is a good one.
I really like this style of mystery - police procedural, interesting protagonist detective, set between the wars in England. I thought the main character was really quite well drawn. However, I found the story somewhat confusing and the mystery itself implausible and almost irrelevant. I liked all the ingredients, but for me the story itself was not interesting. Also, all of these characters who take on each others' identity. That whole thing didn't work for me, and didn't seem to have any point or plausibility.
The main character is very interesting and likeable. I was hoping for more involvement with his sister, who only appears in one scene but is also engaging. I might try number 2 in the series, eventually. An okay listen, but not as good as i had hoped. Nicely narrated, though, except for the terrible attempt at a scottish accent Xb
This British detective procedural is fair. I enjoy a bit more of a pace in my mysteries.
I just could not get pulled into this novel. Too much talk and little else.
Haven't read, only listened. But, the reader is superb, so I lean toward the audio version.
The continuation of a most intriguing character, Ian Rutledge. The author has refined and expanded him with each new book.
His conversations with the rector.
It was "moving" throughout the entire book.
The main character, Scotland Yard Inspector Ian Rutledge, has grown and expanded as a character in each book of the series. Todd tells wonderful stories, with excellent character development - and the tricks and turns of the mystery are always fascinating.
Absolutly love to listen to the great classic English detectives.
MAYBE, NOT SURE
THE WAY TODDS PLOTS, ALWAYS CIRCLE BACK ON THEM SELFES.
SIMON PREBBLE IS ONE OF THE TOP NARRATORS IN THE BUISNESS AS FAR AS I,M CONCERNED.
Old England mystery
The blend of mystery and old England
A nicely plotted, enjoyable read. Mystery plotted in old England. I will try some of the other books after reading this one.
The Inspector Ian Rutledge mysteries are certainly that- mysterious. They are dark, plodding, gloomy, and at times tedious. I love an intricate plot, and these books do have very entangled plots. But sometimes it seems the Charles Todd makes the story so complex and entangled that it strains credulity... and not in a good way. The police procedural details that I usually enjoy following are slow, slow and slow. And did I say slow? I wanted to stop listening several times, but stuck with it just out of curiosity as to just which unlikely character would turn out being the murderer. Simon Prebble does a good job with his narration, and much of the descriptive writing is quite good. The whole post WW1 historical background is also interesting. But I can't either read or listen to another one of these books. Whew!
I enjoy a variety of books including mysteries, historical fiction as well as young adult and children's literature. Listening to books gives me the ability to "read" in the car as well as the evening as a nightcap before bed.
I found this mystery novel tedious, long and a bit boring. The main character was depressive and the mystery was not particularly interesting. None of the characters seemed well developed or engaging.
I liked the way the book wove the characters together. Making you really think about who did it.
to me it wasn't an on the edge book, but a good tale that kept you coming back to hear more.
Ruledge & his dead mate giving his opinion was excellent.