Great book, great narrator. One irritating thing though if that the narrator changed voices for several of the characters in this book compared to the previous ones. For example, Arya Stark (a ten year old) in this book has the voice the narrator uses for old women. It makes Arya sound like an old witch...
The fact that I found you could speed up the narration to 1.5x and still understand everything. I got this book done in a month's time!
Probably Arya most of the time. That's the most interesting story, obviously. I hate Cersei, Brienne's accent in the audiobook is annoying (Sanser Stark), Jaime isn't really a badass (... and moonboy for all I know), Samwell Tarly is Samwell Tarly, and the myriad of other characters aren't that great. God knows I can't stand the ironborn ("What is deeaaaadddd will never dieeeee but rise harderrr and stronger than before").
His accents all changed and the way he pronounced people's names changed. Brienne has a really heavy accent that makes her seem really sissy. Arya's accent changed from a sassy tomboy to an old lady. At least Cersei doesn't really sound like a man anymore though. I would say one of the cleverest things about Dotrice's narration from before was the fact that Jaime and Tyrion had similar accents but still sounded different. Now Jaime sounds like a normal dude. Samwell sounds better though. I'm glad he doesn't say "Pe-tyre" anymore, but I hate that he now says "Cait-lin." I've always hated "Bry-Eeen," but he probably pronounces her name 5 different times in the same chapter.
All of the sudden Mr. Roy D. decides to change voices, pronunciation and delivery. Considering that this is a book of side story's and supporting characters development, it was overall good, but very tedious.
Not as good as the previous books, but better than most. The story is a bit slow, and doesn't focus on all the characters from the series, i assume they will be featured in the next book. Dotrice also uses new voices for some of the characters which could be annoying for some.
It is good, great writing, well acted and sad, but keeps you on the edge of your seat and you are sadden when it ends. I was surprised by the length of this book and so sad to see it go because that means that I am almost at an end of the Game. I know that I will immediately restart the series over when I have completed book 5.
roy dotrice was called back to do this narration by his fans. He is in his 90s, so he probably didn't do this for the money, this was a fan service. Things are much different now, the pronunciations and the accents, but they aren't that different. Dornish still sound like they are from Dorne, easterners still have their accents. Many of the characters too, if only a little off. Ignore the angry reviewers, this was a well done book with a great narrator. If you want to blame anyone for the change, blame the director, but remember that recording two audio books of this size would take a lot of time, and at his age, time is precious. Mistakes are easy to overlook. Totally worth it.
only off thing is the Narrator switches voices on a few characters. I'm still trying to decide it is purposeful or if it is an accident...
the whole plot is totally avoided during most of the book and instead filled with worthless dialogue that has nothing to do with the main story. nothing happened and all the most exciting characters were not even in the book. i wish i had skipped on to book 5
Good performance by Roy. Book leaves a lot to be desired. First and last few chapters are the only ones that really move the story forward.