only complaint is that the voices are inconsistent with the other books, but still a great performance.

the narrator is not good. all the characters sound the same and he had changed how the names are pronounced from book to book. it's really annoying.

in short, I love the books and I love listening to them. however, this one sounded like it was recorded through a metal tube and didn't have the same quality as previous books.

either the writer or narrator messed up at least 3 times in the story confusing characters and actions, for example he said Jamie had placed Briannes rainbow cloak on her not Renley.

The first three books so tight and perfectly executed that it really made for a great listen. This book, however, is awful to listen to. The story is great, but the narrator seems to have forgot how to play his characters. He completely mispronounces the names and the spirit he put into them in the first three books. Aria's voice is the worst, by far. But if this had been a tv show, it would be as though they fired the entire cast of the first three seasons and replaced them with a bad high school theatre company. They should have had the narrator listen to segments of each character to get back the flow of the others.

In short, this is an awful reading and I would hope they consider re-recording this book.

I gave this three stars on the performance and five stars for the story only because the pronunciations and the voices used for the different character changed from the first three books. I liked the way he did the previous books better. All the same, he does a good job bringing the story to life.

just kinda dragged. allot of set up but no real pay off. Still interesting just lacking entertainment

Enjoyed and a great narrator. Hard to quit listening. Well done. Enjoying all the series.

This volume included nothing about the imo or the wall or Danarius. pretty much everyone got screwed over ever way they turned, No happiness here,

great work but Detroyce leaves much to be desired in the narration. After 3 books, suddenly pronunciation of names of characters and accents have changed. Gilly is suddenly Hilly, Catlain is suddenly Caitlen and there are plenty of other examples. poor editing or directing I would assume.