I've read this whole series over a hundred times. My husband has little time to sit and read, we listen to the books as well so he can enjoy them as well. He refused to listen to the previous reader after the first chapter, he said it was all wrong, the tone, the performance everything. I recently purchased this version an have to agree. While the other reader had a very good voice, it didn't do much for the performance of the story and its nuances.
I love the portrayal, but he does mix up the pronunciation and occasionally forgets which voice he was using for characters. But overall, it's still a fantastic listen.
Wish Dotrice would stay consistent with character voices. Very annoying that main characters like Arya have differences from one book to the next. Otherwise, a nice reading.
The most memorable moment had to do with Brianne of Tarth, one of my favorites but besides that the book was a little dull for the series.
The names of people, places, and other things of importance changed in pronunciation. It made the story difficult to follow at times. There really should be a note about why this was done. This book builds on the previous books and lays a lot of foundation for the upcoming books.
While this is the same narrator as with the previous three books in the series, you wouldn't know it as he pronounces the names of some of the main characters differently and performs many if the voices differently as well. It is as if he didn't bother to prepare himself properly for this book. It made listening to it an annoyance as opposed to a pleasure.
First...I must agree with nearly everyone here... Roy KILLED this book for me.. I honestly was floored by the change in voices.. EVERYONE sounds like badly cast Irishmen.. Even the women! This is the most disappointing narration because we were really given a treat with books 1-3. Roy NAILED the characters...from the pronounication of names, to voices...they all sounded very elegant and fit the atmosphere of the story.. But this... is just appalling.. My favorite characters ..Arya and Sam both sound the same, like old leprechauns from cereal commercials. It was hard to listen to..I really hope Audible cues him him for the next book... .Anyway with that off my chest...onto the real part of the review.
I'll have to admit, this book started off as dull as drying paint. I normally don't need (or even want) action, and in your face dramatics all the time. After the events of Book III, it was perfectly acceptable to have Book IV be a big more laid back. That being said, I just could not follow or get into the events in the first few chapters. The thing is, Book III ends making you crave more to find out what happens, and the first three chapters of Book IV aren't even dealing with characters that we've met. Martin's very liberal use of names, and history works against him here I believe. I simply did not care for the new characters introduced. Don't get me wrong I like the Greyjoys, but Martin's writing is at fault here. He dumps a ton of characters and names on you and expects you to get attached to them or even remember them.
To this effect, the last chapter of the Book IV references a character you meet in the prologue. I had no idea about this until I read the book's chapter summaries. I may be in a worse off position than my fellow readers who have the book in front of them. It's easier for you to go back and re-read a passage if you need to. Also your book as the appendix of characters in the back.. My audio books does not have this.
My other complaint is that lack of direction. Actually let me amend that, I'm sure Martin has a direction, but it's such a slow, ponderous journey, the average reader losses interest. I love Arya, my favorite character, but in this book, i feel as though her misadventures are pretty pointless. Brienne as well. Like her as a character, but she accomplishes nothing. This book was unfortunately for me, seen more as a filler. Things happen, but i don't feel any character's have developed.( maybe the relationship of Jamie and Cersai perhaps). But even characters like Asha and the Greyjoy's are introduced...then forgotten. It takes the fun out of reading the book, when I don't know which characters I need to really focus on.
I'm also not a fan of how we're now supposed to feel empathetic for Jamie..I like dynamic characters and all...but giving him a soft side and adding that 'human element' just feels off.
Also, the book's theme of scheming behind closed doors is wearing thin for me...
What I did enjoy though was the interaction between characters. Martin's ability for dialogue is great. Most of the characters have a distinct way of talking, and it's fun to read.
I enjoyed the book to a point. I suggest you read the wiki for the chapter summaries though. Really helped me get the concept of what Martin was babbling about at times.