I will definitely listen to A Feast for Crows again. It was long and slow, but covered a great deal of information for many characters.
Feast for Crows is probably the slowest of the 5 (so far) Song of Ice and Fire Series, but it keeps you going and has a lot of subtle story plots that are interesting.
He does a great job reading the normal text as well as all the voices of the characters. If you watch the Game of Thrones HBO Series, it takes a little while to get rid of the actors voice in your head and accept Roy Dotrice's, but once you do, you learn to appreciate the effort he goes into all the character voices.
From the Shadows
Well....what can I say. As an audiobook, this one fell short for me. Dotrice had established such great character voices in the previous books only to alter some completely (and to their detriment) in this one. So much so that parts were hard to even listen to. I managed to get through it, but definitely wasn't my favorite audio experience, and ended up picking up the print book as well.
I have enjoyed all of the Game of Thrones books. Love the characters and the storyline as well and the stories within the story.
There have been lots of memorable moments. I have most enjoyed the scenes from Dorne.
He was difficult to understand. Some of his words were not clear and it was difficult when he changed from one character to another.
I am still reading. I will complete this section when I have finished.
It was so difficult for me to understand the narrator that I purchased a readable version and I am reading the book instead of listing because I do not want to miss anything. The narration sounds as if he is talking with loose dentures and is spitting as he reads. I would not but this again. But I will continue to buy other Audible Books, just not books with this narrator. I was very disappointed as I had been waiting for this book.
Only if someone hadn't listened to the other books.
I am just echoing what everyone else has said because they are right! I don't understand what happened to the narration. The first three books were consistent and fantastic. This one is just weird. He pronounces the names differently - not only from other books, but within the same segments - and uses different voices than he did in the first three. It's jarring. I've read the comments for book 5 and it's more of the same. So sad!! I won't be listening to book 5. Sigh.
Roy, if you're listening...produces these last two again - please!
My interests run to psychology, popular science, history, world literature, and occasionally something fun like Jasper Fforde. It seems like the only free time I have for reading these days is when I'm in the car so I am extremely grateful for audio books. I started off reading just the contemporary stuff that I was determined not to clutter up my already stuffed bookcases with. And now audio is probably 90% of my "reading" matter.
This series just gets better and better. Things that were annoying in the earlier books (like the overuse of certain vocabulary terms) have been fixed or at least mitigated in this latest installment. We will forgive him for falling prey to a new batch of overused terms towards the end.
Unlike book 3, book 4 starts off in a way that seems to deliberately ignore where the previous book left off. Rather than remind his readers of recent critical events, Martin simply goes on with selected storylines, trusting that eventually there will be enough clues to fill in the gaps. His opening scene doesn't appear to fit in anywhere and we will wait an agonizingly long time to find out what it relates to. Likewise, we are forced to wait an agonizingly long time to pick up the story lines for the most intriguing loose ends of book 3.
The result is a book that is always entertaining yet vaguely unsatisfying. While we get to watch the aftermath of the recent war play out, and while there is clearly a lot of background preparation for what must ultimately happen, there isn't a feeling of making much progress toward a final conclusion. I am not wishing for Mr. Martin to telegraph the ending, but book 5 had better do more than simply mark time.
I have recently been subjected to other imaginary worlds of inferior quality and it has me pondering why this particular world holds my interest. Martin has taken the time to construct a back story with unstable forces in play. And then he has taken the trouble to create a host of very individualized characters each with his or her own agenda. But the real magic comes when Martin lets those characters collide with each other and with the sociopolitical forces of their time. At that he is a real master. And all the specific trappings of the imaginary universe assume their proper role as background matter.
I like magical realism.
If you're a die hard fan, you probably won't find this book as boring. As for me, I'm stuck reading it sheerly because I've made it this far.
I think I understand what Martin was trying to do with this installment. Many of the chapters are from the perspective of auxiliary characters. Unfortunately, that's exactly what I didn't like about the book. On the bright side, it made me wish for chapters with characters whom I previously thought were boring.
I have no problems with Roy Dotrice. He is a great narrator and I enjoy his performances.
I imagine every character is necessary in some way. Honestly, I'm very tired of Sansa.
Just trudge through. It's not as long as the third book or the fifth book.
The stuff that happens towards the end. Oh wow. It will knock your socks off!
What's not to like?
He manages to capture each character uniquely enough, but he changed up the voices that he used from the last few books. For a person jumping right from the last book, it can be a little jarring. He only narrated this one after popular demand, or so I hear. He was not the original narrator for this particular book, so Dotrice was returning after years and years of not having narrated the last few books. He did a fantastic job. Arya and Petyr are the most notable. Arya was a bad change. Bad bad bad.
There is a part where someone is having their face eaten off. I was driving at the time and it was hard to concentrate on the road. I was cringing.
Despite other people's mixed reviews of this book, when comparing it to the last, it is safe to ignore all of that. It is a great book. I actually hesitated to start in on it because of the reviews. Forget all of that. It's not a good as the last book, but few books are.
I just wanted to clear up some of the confusion around the narrator. When I purchased a Feast for Crows, the Audible website stated that it was narrated by Roy Dotrice. However, when I downloaded it, the narration was actually by John Lee...
I contacted Audible yesterday. They fixed the problem, and put up the version narrated by Roy Dotrice.
Not really time well spent. The first 3 books are better.
I would try another. The first 3 books were better. This book 4 was difficult to follow. For me the reason may be all of the new material that is introduced here.
Not ever. Listening to his narration probably has a strong impact on my opinion of this book 4. Most of the time the narration is garbled and difficult to follow. I have great speakers to listen with. Not even the Bose speakers helped much.
No. I can't see this being made into a movie as it stands. As it stands, it's really boring.
I hope the next book is as good as books 1-3,
I liked that this book was able to give me perspective. Do we really need to know or care about the main characters from the last 3 books? Are characters really as shallow as they seem? Well, this book answers them for you, unfortunately both answers are not good.
After 3 amazing books, this book just seems to indicated that GRRM ran out of steam. I know he likes the slow burn in terms of story development, but honestly, having read book 5, I think you can skip this book and not be worse off.
I love Roy Dotrice in books 1 through 3. He was consistent and an excellent reader. While he is still an excellent reader, he seems to have forgotten what all the major characters sounded like, and it can be quite confusing.
The HBO show is already into this book, and doing a better job of it (in season 3). I'd say just watch that instead.
I was disappointed.