Continuation of the Bean and Ender story is great and this story, while short certainly recaptured the best narration of how parents and their children relate over space and time and showed a complexity and depth to each of the characters. Stefan, Emily and Kirby narrated so well without trampling on the story as Scott Brick does.
Can't wait to hear the next one. Hopefully without the dramatic monotone of Mr. Brick.
Sargent for his complexity rather than just a portrayal as a militaristic bully.
Scott Brick's narrative style has caused me not to download any book that has him as the sole narrator.
While Scott's narrative style was not quite as drama queen in this story, as in the Herbert/Anderson Dune and too many other novels, he still makes a chapter he reads more about his special voice rather than the stories. His style of over dramatization with seething forced expressions and odd inflections on the last half of the sentence makes his reading seem more about his personal angst and anger rather than revealing the more subtle nuances that the author writes in.
Fortunately the other narrators of this story capture the dialog and essence of each character, letting Orson's vision shine through. Stefan Rudnicki remains one of the best at portraying character voices and letting the listener see the story come alive. Emily and Kirby also helped to make this story live despite Scott's heavy handed monotone. Scott should stick to reading eulogies.
Must read/listen for the Ender and beyond series.
Interesting to see things from a different point of view. New doors open that could be explored.
Really liked the narration. If you listend to the other books, you will be familiar with how this one is read.
Yes. It is not a long book, but opens some new doors.
A nice continuation of the Ender universe.
This story was too short. I know that this and the book after were originally supposed to be one book, but they should have kept it that way. Not much actually happens in this story and it seems forced at points. Also there is always too much talk about
The voice actors in this volume are the same as all other books in the series which is a huge plus. All give great performances.
Not to the theatre.
When I first heard about this story, it was reported that Shadows in Flight would finally connect the Ender saga and the Shadow books, but as it turns out, it's only about Bean and his kids. OSC apparently wanted the story of this book to be only the first part of that connecting novel, but he realized this story deserves to be told on its own (and I agree). Apparently Shadows Alive will be the follow-up that this one would've been. Despite my initial disappointment, this was a good story and it did have some new info (as opposed to Ender in Exile, which while fascinating, didn't add anything relevant to the Enderverse IMO).
The best part of the story is that it tells the rest of the tragic yet triumphant story of Julian Delphiki, and finishes his legacy. If nothing else, that makes this story worth reading.
I have listened to the narrators before in other OSC books, and I am particularly fond of Stefan Rudnicki and Scott Brick. They could read the Encyclopedia Brittanica and I'd be riveted. I couldn't tell which young lady was doing most of the POVs from Carlotta, but I had moments that it seemed to me that she was a little too bouncy or reading a little too fast for the gravitas of the situation, but overall she and the other narrators were good as always.
Yes, but I don't want to put any spoilers. I will just say that if you're a Bean fan and find it a little hard to get to the punch line in this book, just make it through to the end... I actually cried, both from sorrow and joy...
In the case of Bean's kids, I find their relationship to be too much like the Wiggin sibs to be truly original, but OSC is such a good author that even when he redoes the same theme again and again (which is rather often if you read most of his writing), he still manages to bring something new to the table. This book is a little on the short side, and while at first I thought that was somewhat of a ripoff, I am now glad that OSC didn't drag this one out just to get more hours out of it. Bean's story is tragically short, but full of events that have galactic repercussions, just like this novel.
For such an important conclusion to beans trials this book seems premature What happen between all the characters left on earth the trials of Bean raising his children Mr Card in an attempt to write a shorter book has skipped all the detail we looked for In his books
Enjoyed the conclusion to a great character...wish their could have been a Disney style ending. But this is Scott Card, and he can be as raw and moving in much more real ways...even in science fiction. Bean showed to be true to himself and those he loved, which moved me and kept the pace of the story moving along.
If this had been a free read from the library I would have debated whether it was worth spending my time reading it. Paying real money for an obvious cashing-in type of book was a disappointment. I have an addiction to the Ender's Game series and of course this new book presented itself and I spent my money. LOLEnder's Game is one of the best science fiction books ever written. The only other book he wrote that could live up to or close to Ender's Game would be Ender's Shadow. If you haven't read them, stop reading this review and go buy them right now!
YES: warn people not to buy it... ha!
Get this at the library for free...that's all it's worth!
It completed the story about what happened to Bean and how he died.
All three kids are great..... but Ender I liked the best
I read some not so good comments and almost did not download the book.... I'm glad I did.... I thought it was well developed and written. Those who have been following the Ender story series will love it - as a stand along book it might be a little confusing. Can't wait to read the next one later this year.
If I had realized that this was a short book, I wouldn't have bought it. I feel like I was ripped off. Was this a ploy for more money and less work? It costs the same on Audible, no matter how long it is. I LOVE the Ender stories and Bean, but this was not up to Card's standard. I kept waiting for the real story and characters to develop and then suddenly it ended. What? The narrators were terrific as usual.
I like any story with Bean in it. To be honest, I was really hoping that this was the tie-together story for the Ender series and the Shadow series, but there is a commentary at the end that explains what happened there. Shadows in Flight really feels more like a novella than a novel, but I think that it's an important piece in the over-all story. This is also the only one of the stories that is actually about
The performance was excellent as usual.