I've listened to a lot of audio books, but Mindstar Rising is easily in the top 10% of them.
Comparing Peter F. Hamilton to any other author usually leaves that other author looking like an amateur. In terms of compelling storyline and characters I'd compare it to The Lies of Locke Lamora. In terms of quality and care of writing I'd compare it to The Name of the Wind. In terms of page turning action I'd compare it to a James Patterson or Brad Thor novel.
I haven't, this was my first experience with Toby, and it was a great introduction. He's a quality voice actor.
I don't typically have extreme reactions to books. I don't typically laugh out loud or cry. This book was no exception. But it did have me listening well into the night when I should have been sleeping.
I made it through all of Pandoras Star and the sequels. The thickness of the prose was daunting in those books, but the universe created was fascinating.
This book has the same dialogue-heavy blandness with no story or characters. I listened for 8 hours and gave up.
A mail carrier on a rural island somewhere in the US; good books make me stop the "tape" at every door delivery & package hop out.
If the story was faster moving and better paced. This book seemed to drag on. While I understand that the book is suppose to be a mystery, There were several sections that were not very clear and concise. This led to certain sections that were hard to follow.
No While I have a feeling I will not be continuing the series. I love the scifi genre and I will continue to listen/read novels in this area. I will also read other books from Peter F. Hamilton.
I liked the voices in this book, I found none of them to be annoy or hard to listen to. Also all of the voices were unique enough to tell who was who.
My favorite characters were any of the characters that are stored/interfaced in a computer. There are several moments where people who use an AI/computer to speak and interact. In several of these scenes there are sections where the computer interface "glitches" This leads to erratic dialogue from the characters. This was amazing to listen to. It must have been so hard for the reader to pull that off. Toby Longworth did a great job reading!
I would not cut any characters personally, All of the characters played a role in the story and moved the plot forward all be it slowly.
I really wanted to like this book, I love Sci-Fi it is fun, techie, and can be full of adventure. This book has a great premise, it blends Sci-Fi and detective work and it does so OK-ish. I would have preferred a little more action in this novel. I did not like the anti-corporate/business and environmental spin. That drove me nuts. I hear enough about climate change and global warming crap in the news today, I don't like to hear it in my science fiction novels. I also did not like the several gratuitous sex scenes in the novel, it did not further the plot and it just added to the dragging on of novel.
All in all I would say the idea of the novel and the series is a great idea but it is poorly executed.
Bad to good
Toby's English accent makes for perfect setting of this English story
This book starts with a couple of chapters like a bad soap opera but after that it switches to a very good thriller. The book reminded me of British sci fi of times past. It is an early work of the author so you can see the characters do not have the depth of his later works but as a thriller with neat plot it works.
I would listen to this book again. The story was a little slow to start, but it captured me in the end. Towards the end I did't want to stop listening.
The story line about the gland enhanced main character. The story starts slow but becomes a murder mystery that draws you in.
Like Isaac Asimov Peter weaved a mystery and SifFi. Great story!
Perfect reader with enough voice inflections to sort out the charterers.
One must ignore the focus on man causing global warming crap unless you are a global warming pin head
I had already read the entire Mindstar trilogy on Kindle before receiving this audio book as a gift. I already had a general sense of how things would unfold, yet the amount of detail in the story meant that most of the time I was once again swept up in it. Peter Hamilton created scenes that are full of action and let me enjoy the story at different levels.
I liked the way that Toby Longworth modulated and pitched his voice differently for most of the characters. He was very consistent in this and it made it easier to get pulled into the story.
Hamilton has created characters in this book that I really cared about. He spent enough time developing them as 'real' persons that I got invested in them and wanted things to work out for them.
I am looking forward to hearing the other two audio books that follow this one.
Yes. It's a good story. Industrial espionage and attempted murder (in a way) in a world dealing with climate change and the fall of a fascist political party. It was a solid, entertaining read.
In this story, set several decades in our future, Hamilton and fused some science fiction technology with fantasy-based intuition and empathic abilities raised to new height with an experimental program. The product is now a private eye contracted to solve a simple case. Of course, it's not so simple.
This is not nearly so epic in scale has Hamilton's Commonwealth Saga or Void trilogy. And the novel very knowingly and explicitly violates some rules of science as we know them so far as well as postulating possibilities.
A good read.
Reading Mindstar Rising, the first book in Peter F. Hamilton’s Greg Mandel Trilogy will cost you three credits because I guarantee you will be purchasing the second and third volumes, A Quantum Murder and The Nano Flower in quick succession.
I have to admit to liking a good long story. The problem with that is sometimes long stories are filled with so much superfluous verbiage that you wish you had committed the ultimate of audible sins and purchased the abridged version. Some books although possessing a great premise and promising storyline just seem to waffle.
It is for that reason that Peter F. Hamilton is, and will remain, one of my favourite fiction authors. Because not only does he provide some of the best value for money in the world of audio books he also weaves a compelling and believable story no matter how fantastic the underlying premise. Peter F. Hamilton’s books are the ones you tend not to read in bed because when you nod off letting slip the paperback might break your nose and the hardback will cause concussion. Mindstar Rising is typical of Mr Hamilton’s books in this regard. At 14 hours long it is one of his briefer works. Yet frustratingly this book in common with his other works seems to be far too short as his masterfully crafted characters and compelling environments hold you entranced for every one of those 840 minutes. I recollect starting this book on a Friday evening and I am told that over the next two days I prepared two family meals, mowed a lawn, walked the dog and basically ignored my family and the world. I have no recollection of that weekend because for 14 glorious hours I was transported into a near future Britain where Greg Mandel, an ex-British army paratrooper who back in his service days had been drafted into the Mindstar Battalion due to his ESP potential, now earns his living as a security consultant come private eye. With psi enhancements the legacy of his time in service and Britain coming out of the economic ruin of years of Marxist government on the back of some truly cool tech the story that unfolds could have been predictable and plastic. But it’s not, most definitely not, plastic. This was Peter F. Hamilton’s first published novel and every sentence is carefully layered and finessed into place. Peter F. Hamilton doesn’t write he sculpts. The level of details he puts into his work is one of the reasons that his novels are weighty tomes. But unlike many other authors that detail is almost unnoticed as it creates an incredibly multi-dimensional landscape upon which is then delived a plot that propels you to the end in what feels like a fraction of the 14 hours required to get there.
No sooner had Audible hoped I had enjoyed this programme, I was downloading the next two books. If you like intelligent science fiction, gritty characters and are not afraid of a couple of days of productivity loss buy this book. Now as an undeserved afterthought let me please throw Toby Longworth into the mix. Mr Longworth must be one of the best narrators on Audible. He makes an amazing book incredible. No messing!
Up there with the best
Picturing Greg's gland doing it's thing
The bar at the start when the religious fool was made to look as small as he truely was.
Yes, the concept had me hooked.
Recommended for Sci-fi fans.