An old broad that enjoys books of all types. Would rather read than write reviews though. I know what I like, and won't be bothered by crap.
War Rain Peace
The bringing together of all the characters from the four books for a satisfying conclusion.
Bringing Liir back from the dead.
Would have loved to, but too long to do it! However, I did stay up quite late on the last night. Had to see how it ended!
The author wants his readers to draw their own conclusions, like always. At first I was unsure of the ending, but thinking it over now I love it. (The last sentence in the book is eerily similar to the first sentence in Wicked).
Readers should look for sly references to the musical, Judy Garland, The Wiz and of course the previous books. There are also some fun asides to Gone With The Wind which was also produced in 1939.
After part three I began listening in shorter segments as I did not want the book to end and I knew it would not be finished in a tidy manner. It was not as life is not. One of the reviewers said that Elphaba's fate was known at the last page. I did not catch it at any rate and that adds to my sense of frustration. Gregory Maguire's writing is so tart and he catches the characters to my liking at any rate. By book Four many of them are my friends and I care for their well being. The narrator is perfection. I hope the untied strings means Gregory Maguire will come back add a few more books. Please do not let this be the last one in this series.
They keep you guessing all the way to the end if Elphaba is alive or dead. The one person who knows the truth won't tell you until the last page.
The Tin Man where it's a similar story line in that the leaders are removed and decades later they come back.
I would liked to have seen Rain trained by the time we saw her instead of where she was. I thought they would have her ready to war with Uncle, not just beginning to learn. I would liked to have had the story with Liir leading a resistance instead of doing what he did.
If you've read all the rest of the series then you need to read this one. Not a bad closure to the series.
I have enjoyed all the other books in the
He is good at all of them
It was better to listen to than read, at least the reader is entertaining.
The narrator's voice was extremely annoying! I kept thinking that the story was going to pick up, I got about half way through, and gave up. It wasn't going anywhere.
I really need to start proof reading my Reviews before I post them.
If you have read the other 3 books in the series, this one should be read as well. Wicked and Son of a Witch were the best of the series. The Lion Among Men was a low point for me and I almost didn't want to read this. But this book begins to recapture the magic that was ignited in the first of the series.
I did really enjoy the tour of San Francisco with the aunt and uncle, worrying and fretting over Dorothy's mental health and marriage prospects. Dorothy's trip to the chinese restaurant was a lot of fun. I could have read an entire book of just her perspective on the 'real' world after having survived her trip to Oz.
I enjoyed the starts of all the characters in the book, when their turns were wrapped up and the view point shifted I was always just a little sad because I wasn't ready to move on yet.
The aspect of the story I didn't really enjoy was that the story didn't seam to have any place to go. The massive pending war that was over shadowing everything, didn't seem like that real of a threat. I felt that most of the characters seemed to need anti-depressants and a good therapist session, and all the major tension would have been resolved.
There seemed to be a lack of respect between characters that did not sit well with me. They didn't seem to want to be together, nothing except the threat of death was keeping them together, and if Leer just treated his time with Trisim with respect and honesty way back in Son of a Witch the world of Oz would have been such a better place.
The narrator was great. John McDonough gave each character their own voice and they felt unique and sounded completely different in my mind's ear.
I am glad that I listened to the story and that characters got an ending that they could mostly live with.
I was amazed to see this book out this month. I caught it just a few days after it was released. I am in awe of Mr. Maguires writing. The depth and intensity of the language he uses and invents is simply amazing to hear. Mr. McDonough's narration is so extraordinary, it's as if he was born to read these pages and bring them to life. The whole series has been a joy to listen to. There is so much to these stories and this book, it's hard to sum up in a few sentences. You simply have to listen and believe.
Thank you so much for taking a simple guideline and making it so enjoyable without hurting the original story of "The Wizard of Oz".
You are a true Master of Words.
Thank you very much for all your books and this series.
I could not finish this book. I tried for weeks, but it's just too slow. Wicked was great but each book is slower and more tortured than the last.
"And I never knew what happened in this world 'til I met up with Mary Jane"
I've read the books already and would love it if I could afford to listen to them all as well. Gregory Maguire is an amazingly creative author and Jack McDonough couldn't be a better storyteller.
No comparison, really. Except for the other books in the series.
I really liked the scene where Lady Glinda and Rain cast the 'Winter Upon Water' spell on Cherrystone's and his Dragons.
The land of make believe becomes a reality.
Keep 'em coming Mr. Maguire! I've already read 'Lost', 'Mirror Mirror', 'Confessions ..' and the whole 'Wicked' series. I'd love to see 'Wicked' on the big screen ...!!