I loved this story. It was alittle slow to start but once the plot thickend I was pretty rivited.
Murakami???s story was excellent, however, the narrator that read parts by Mr. Ushikawa absolutely destroyed the listening experience for me. What annoying ???Spit Mouth??? clicks and slurps???forget about the violent gasps for air. If / When I figure out which of the male contributors read the Ushikawa character, I???ll never purchase another audio book he???s involved in.
If the story had tied everything together at the end. I felt like I did right after I watched the last episode of Lost on T.V.
First one I have read by this author.
Narrators were good.
Disappointment. As long as this book was, the author failed to tie all the loose ends together and explain everything.
I am left with the impression that the author was paid by the word. There was so much repetition and fluff in this story she made Stephen King look like he writes fortune cookies. I was optomistic in the beginning and then deeply disappointed at the end. I would not recommend this book to others.
I read this book because it screamed surreal to me, and I am left pondering it. Murakami is surreal. There are loose ends. I smile when I find the one star "I don't get it" and "huh??" ratings along with the copious five star ratings. So, if you like to understand everything about a book and have all loose ends tied up in a pretty package, you should probably pass on this book. But if you like to sink your teeth into something big that you will turn over in your mind for days and weeks on end, this is your book. Go for it!
Murakami pays homage to Kafka, Jung, Doystoevsky, Orwell and Tolstoy. Brilliantly even, he weaves them into the story like old friends. I'm not a spoilers person, so let me just say that the way he weaves Jung in is simply brilliant. And to do that in the same scene that he borrows the first line of Anna Karenina from Tolstoy - well, the characters and the scene deserved no less.
Murakami also quietly painted a picture of the 1980's. I was amazed at how Murakami did this with so little reference to popular music. Classical music played a large role in story, as did the noticeable absence of modern conveniences. 1Q84 is a world populated by word processors, floppy disks, pay phones and telephones with cords.
This was my first Murakami book, and now I can't decide between listening to Kafka on the Shore and The Windup Bird Chronicles next. I do plan to start working my way through his works now.
Making the characters more dimensional. They were flat and very much like cookie cutouts. There was too much unnecessary description and not enough necessary description. There were things thrown in that seemed to come out of left field.
An image of what they looked like, above and beyond their descriptions.
None, they all seem to be essential.
This book reads like a first novel with mistakes a first time writer would make. None of the characters seemed to be individuals, with their own individual speech patterns or colloquialisms. Also, none of the characters ever seem to react to situations in a way that would make sense to the average person. Important characters are not given names until near the end of the book, instead being addressed by their title. For example: The dowager. or the much older, married girlfriend. And often descriptions or backgrounds are repeated, ad nauseum. The way the writer has of making one character repeat another character becomes very annoying after a while, as well. Last, but not least, the story line is very confusing. I'm sure it will make sense when I get to the end. If I get to the end.
A plot that went somewhere and a better story line.
Quit repeating everything over and over. It is annoying and offensive. Can the reader remember nothing you've said? The redundancy became insulting.
This is the worst thing I've read in quite a while.
Just some dude.
So far, I can tell that the writer enjoys music and the sounds of his own thoughts and sex.
The story is interesting however not all that original. I enjoy the characters so far more than the story. At first which is this part one of the listen, I can tell you that I absolutely love the readers of this book. A top notch job by the narrators who do a superlative job in reading this book and adding life to the dialogue. The readers have pleasant voices and really care a great deal for the book as well. The story seems a bit contrived. Like a conscience effort to place sex and violence every so often: Roger Corman style.
The writer takes great effort to draw the characters for us to enjoy, however the English translation sometimes might get in the way, especially when eating is concerned. Japanese eating hamburgers and pizza seemed out of place and I dismissed this as a deliberate effort not to alienate American listeners, when in fact I would enjoy the sounds of the authentic dishes such as Meeso soup etc..
I am enjoying this book so far but I have a feeling that I could write the rest of the book myself based on other stories and news articles about a similar vein. I hope I will be delightfully wrong. :)
See my last entry when I get that far.
I'm sure Alison Hiroto is a very nice young woman. But I'm afraid to say that, in my personal opinion, she is not the right choice to give voice to the incomparable prose of Haruki Murakami in 1Q84. She hasn't the chops, training or gravitas, (and again, this is only my own opinion), to handle the job.
I've appealed twice to Brilliance Audio, who published the audio book, to kindly consider re-recording the female part. I don't think they're going to listen to me, but I wish they would. From an R.O.I. perspective, even though they'd have to pay quite a bit to hire and mix a new female reader, they'd more than make that back on the audience that would flock to download the book, once it was re-recorded with another female voice talent.
Perhaps with additional training, coaching and practice, Alison Hiroto could become a great reader. After all, everyone starts somewhere. I sincerely hope she improves over time. But I am truly disappointed in her performance on 1Q84. And it seems from reading other readers' reviews, I am not alone.
So Brilliance Audio, what do you say?
Please work with me to prevail upon Brilliance Audio to re-record the female reader's part.
Yes, the book is enchanting and thought provoking.
I liked the fantasy of the two moons, the little people and I loved the character of the detetective!
My favorite scene was when Anamame went to kill the Leader but the Leader wanted to die. He share with her some thought provoking ideas and they became close friends in the act.
The scene of Adamame teaching classes in self defense at the health club, where she was overly drawn to teaching the students to
The ending of the book was a bit trite and overly sweet. After all the drama of getting Adamame and Tengo together, I cannot imagine another alternative, but it was not believable the two people who had not seen each other since 10 years old would be unquestionable trusting and
After 47 hours of them stuffed in my ears I'm gonna miss those guys, especially Tengo' s part voice, a little bashful at the beginning much more confident in the run, they proved a great strenght at not yawning in repeating so many times same stuff and all the confirmations, the exact identical question after the question, all those considerations using same words as before, reading once again characters' caracteristics i.e. Fuka Eri not using of question marks and, for sure, there is a lot that could have been easily skipped or told us just once or two times, at most.
Same plot's turning points are popular images easy to be liked but leaving a wearisome sense of cheapness for having been chosen, Murakami what happened to you? therefore, easily the same, to be loathed.