I haven't finished this one yet and I'm not sure that I will. I don't think I can take listening to Allison Hiroto narrate for another minute. She speaks SO slowly and feels the need to enunciate EVERY SINGLE letter in EVERY word. It's painful. It almost sounds like the automated voice that announces alerts in an airplanes cockpit. I tried to speed it up to 11/2 times but it was a little too fast. It's no wonder this book goes on for so long. Another narrator could knock a few hours off at least.
Editing this massive tome to a short story may have made it tolerable.
No. The two main narrators read without emotion and excessively slowly.
He repeated stories, statements, and thoughts so many times it was excruciating. Nothing was left for the reader/listener to discover. Even sex scenes were painfully mundane and emotionless.
I don't think it could be a 4 or 5 star for me. This was my first listen to this author, and, I think my last...I started skipping toward the last so that it could be over sooner...
I found the narrators tiresome. The monotone voice of the female, was not to my liking.
I believe the problem here was cultural differences. I personally could not make the leap over some of the character quirks. It also seamed unfinished.
Yes from both. I liked the performance and the story. It just went too long and had so much what turned out to be extraneous detail. The exact color of a package of food or the details of a label on a bottle of wine. It seemed like the author was afraid to leave anything to the reader's imagination.
First book that I've read by this author. I did read a short story and I liked that.
Very good. I have no problems with the narration just that the whole thing got tedious after a while.
Considering this story goes on for about 40 hours, very little happens. It meanders on and on. The pacing is poor, the plot is almost non existent, the milieu is so poorly developed it could have been set anywhere with carbon based life forms. The two main characters hardly went through any development.
The deep and sad irony is that this had the subplot of a character rewriting a work to make it more enjoyable. This book needed that treatment.
An excellent story and insight into modern Japan. The narration is first rate and the tale cleverly unfolds holding your interest to the end.
I am married with a teenage son and run my own business. As I am visually impaired, audio books are my life.
I thought it was a great story, very original and enjoyable. The problem was that it went for too long unnecessarily. There seemed to be a lot of duplication and repetitiveness. I would highly recommend this one though as it is very different.
This book is long. Very long. And while that in and of itself is not bad, it was difficult to not notice portions that seemed unnecessary and tedious. It is well written by most standards and an interesting story, but Murakami has set his bar so high with previous works like Kafka On the Shore and The Windup Bird Chronicle, that 1Q84 suffers by comparison. Many questions and plot threads are left completely unanswered or simply swept away in a sentence or two. This is particularly annoying because in a novel that is 46+ hours, it seems more time could have been devoted to wrapping up loose ends and less time toward star- (moon?) crossed lovers narrowly missing each other at various moments.
It's good, but not nearly as compelling as past works that I have enjoyed.
The narration is good, particularly the male readers.
I wasn't prepared for the multiple references to lesbian experiences or the descriptive flashbacks one character keep having. about his mother's affair. With explicit detail the author describes breasts, female parts, etc. This is not what I thought this book would contain. Unless you are into that walk away from it.
Leave the sexual experiences out or prep the reader about it's explicit nature
They both did a great job. Their accents made for good listening.
Curiosity at first. I wanted to know where the story plot was going. Then disappointment. I couldn't see the rest of the story through the sex and descriptions of orgasms.
If books have ratings this is rated R.