The book starts off strong.
I loved the beginning with its strong female character and uncertainty about what's going on, but then it lost me with its drawn out non-events and arbitrary support of child abuse.
The book needs a lot of editing. I liked the part about the amazing story that go so much publicity, but then the story is recited, and it's not that amazing or even interesting. All of the interesting parts at the beginning of the book are counteracted by too much information later on. Maybe the point of the book is everything is meaningless.
The book is told from several points of view, and it was annoying when the same event was told from multiple vantages with no new information or insight. A third point of view character is added late in the book that provides no new information at all.
There are much better books to spend 47 listening hours on.
I love a long book, but this one was kind of ridiculously long. It must be like 1200 printed pages. I also like a weird book, but this was weird in a bad way- creepy sexual things going on with underage girls, etc. It never explained a lot of what it rambled on about in the end....like a mystery with out a conclusion. Not sure what the point was of this book or all the hype about it. At least I was entertained enough to finish it. I also enjoyed the narrators, especially the men. Won't listen or read another book by this author, though.
Where do I start??
Stated above.....narration, slightly interesting story.
Say something about yourself! I am a runner and avid listener to books. Audible allow me to do my two favorite things at the same time.
The story brought the reader back and forth between alternate universes. The sense of time shifting kept me engaged and curious about how they tied together. It was like switching from one language to another for a new speaker of a language.
I was intrigued by the Christian themes of rebirth, immaculate conception and naive faith. I remain curious about these aspects of the book and continue to mull them over in my mind well after reading the book. I find it odd for Murakami and I am intrigued by it.
At first the narrators drove me nuts but they became endearing to me as I became pulled further and further into their lives.
I would find it difficult to eat with any of them for fear of being swept away into another reality.
Be patient as it takes a bit to get pulled into this book but once the magnet gets you it is difficult to let go.
The first time through you listen to it in a rush because you want to know where it's going to go next. I'd listen to it for a second time to pick up on the finer interweaving of the story.
I was both surprised (which is good, I don't like predictable) but also I felt like that's where it had to end. I like how the author didn't tie up all the details. He left the reader/listener to think on these and come up with their own ideas.
I've never listened to these narrators but I think they did a wonderful job.
No. It was an easy book to listen too but long.
Disappointment. I was very unhappy with the story.
I only listened to the first couple hours. I was so disappointed with the book that I never finished it. I wish that I had been able to return it.
The style of the book was stiff and the story line was equally so. I only listened to the remainder of the book out of the same curiosity that a bad car accident brings on my ride to work. Save yourself from this car wreck.
The first half of this novel was very engaging and descriptive. I enjoyed every moment listening. The details were vivid and interesting and the ideas were imaginative. The second half unraveled some of the mystery of the first half, but then left me restless to get to the end.
Possibly. I think the novel was too long for the story, so I might consider trying a shorter novel.
This is the first performance I have heard from these narrators. I enjoyed them very much and felt their range of voices was convincing.
I can not imagine this as a movie or series that would not fizzle part way through.
It was a good deal in that it was very long for the 1 book credit. On the other hand, it wasn't all that great. If Murakami wasn't such a famous author I would guess an editor would have cut out half of the book. It was repetitive and the story was pretty silly.
I enjoyed the strong female character but felt the whole story was was pretty ridiculous.
I'm sure it could be made into a movie--it read like it was written to be ready to be a movie.
I'm glad I was listening and not putting in the hours reading the actual book! I would have really felt like I wasted my time if I had.
The first part was good, kept you on the edge of your seat wondering what where and how. However the second part the cohesiveness of the story fails badly! It feels like two different books, and a lot of the characters you grew to know and care about just simply go poof with out any detailed explanation. I kept waiting for the author to bring all the strange events together with some type of glue, but... 47 hours of anticipation and I am left flat. I feel like I got cheated.. seriously that's the only way to describe the feeling your left with...
No but problay this author
Yeah wish I had my 47 hours of listening back so I could apply it to a book better written
this wasn't a good story...maybe it"s a cultural thing, but it lacked imagination, creativity, and mostly continuity! i would not waste a credit or 46 hours of your time on this book!
the story is terrible and down right strange....there's no twist or exciting ending....it's really terrible!
the narrators were fine....it's the story that just simply doesn't make any sense...it just never comes together....i warn you....don't do it!
the narrators were ok and the premise could have developed into something good....it's super repetitive and spends countless hours on pointless boring details...