I'm a huge WWII buff, and figured I'd give this fictional account a try. I can't say that it was bad, but it really wasn't my type of story. There's a lot of twists and turns, but overall it was simply a dramatic love story set in Europe. The parts that involve a fictional Churchill & FDR were interesting, but I can't say that I was yearning to hear more as the book went on. Drama, love, betrayal, and little bit of suspense, that's what you'll get. Don't expect lots of guns and gory war literature. This book will deliver more of a wartime soap opera than actual WWII suspense. Good but not great, read at your own risk...
Absolutely. It does an excellent job of putting the events of the war into order. So it's a good documentary wrapped up in a great story.
Well, considering how well the events of the war are known I don't think I am spoiling anything if I say Pearl Harbour.
Personally I'm happy if the performer does a good enough job that I don't think about them and can concentrate on the story. This performer is more than passable.
It's far too long for a single sitting, but I couldn't wait to get back to it. I was building a fence at the time, so I was listening all day long, and didn't tire of it.
This book only covers the war until Pearl Harbour. The sequel, War and Rememberance covers the rest. This series is so good that I wish there were more. It easily makes my top five favourites, and I'm an avid reader. I have listened to more than 500 audio books and hundreds more printed and ebooks.
I've never read the print version of this book, nor had I seen the television version of it, so the story was all new to me.
I thought it was an excellent story. To me, the only character that was really developed was Pug Henry. You don't really get to know any of the other characters -- especially the women, who can seem shallow or mere caricatures. Despite this, I enjoyed the book. I found the historical aspects of the book to be very interesting, and I would think that anyone who is not interested in WWII history would not be interested in this book at all.
The performance was excellent and it was easy to listen to.
I listened to The Winds of War, and the sequel, War and Remembrance. I loved both. Such an in-depth portrait of WW II, through the eyes of various characters.
Kevin Pariseau did an AMAZING job of all the characters and accents! He really brought the book to life in a FEAT of narration, acting and even at times - singing! I especially liked his Russian and German accents! Amazing!
This audible book occupied my mind through many hours of home reno! I also feel as though I have gained a substantial amount of historical knowledge about the unfolding of WW II.
Thank you Herman Wouk, Kevin Pariseau, and Audible!!!
Yes. Very compelling story, neatly done.
The whole Von Roon imitation of Manstein's Lost Victories and Halder's and Von Bock's War Diary and even Speer's books, was incrediblbly dead on. Great mechanism for not only explaining events, but also demonstrating the prejudices of the Germans in a very subtle fashion.
Astounding his ability to mimic the different voices. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
I am an amateur historian of WWII, and have over 2,000 books covering various aspects of the war. But when I was 7 or 8, my parents had me watch the Robert Mitchum miniseries(knowing even then my fascination with the period) However, Mitchum and the rest of the cast were so horribly stiff and their stilted performances bored me to tears. And of course Pug appearing in every major scene of WWII was mindboggling. Strangely, listening to this book, I was able to suspend my disbelief on that point and enjoyed the story immensely.
And yes, I went back and tried an episode of the miniseries on NetFlix and still found it incredibly poor, even for the 80's. Shame as Blue and the Gray showed it could be done well.
I don't know how I missed this story years ago and I cannot believe I missed the miniseries. I suppose it's just as well. The story brought such much too life. Well worth reading by anyone who loves historical fiction.
A great book.
Pariseau played all the characters well. All became very real personalities flawed in ordinary ways but quite individual in their courage. You cared about all of them.
Fr. Spannelli of the Vatican
The author took the necessary time, talent, and effort to develop a large cast of characters to their fullness. When you reached the end of the book, you really knew who the characters were. the book is still relevant and the characters are real and fascinating. Every page counted in the telling of the story. Favorite line " We had become a tumbleweed family tossed around the globe by the winds of war." As good today as it was 30 years ago. The great ones always are,
This has been one of my favourite audiobook experiences. I highly recommend this, especially to those who have long commutes and like to really get to know the characters in a book. Kevin Pariseau's voice is gorgeous.
It was most interesting and the story didn't bog down like some
the companion book read this one first
hard to say. The characters are all great and such depth of developement
Such a good listen. Im sad its over.