Tom and Micheal present an accurate portrayal of the US today. Are we as a country in decline, well we certainly embrace mediocrity as a way of life. The pictured portrayed is not pleasant but not unsolvable. We Americans can and will do the right thing but only when the pain becomes to great to not do it. Are we there yet, I suggest you answer that question when you have read That Used to Be Us.
A big picture view of America's current state of affairs with Friedman's traditional "the world is flat" perspective. There are some good insights here and it's worth the read. Overall Friedman does a good job addressing a number of issues that I believe Americans worry about. This includes jobs, immigration, healthcare, social security, our polarized political system, technology, education, taxes, global climate change, etc. I don't always agree with Freidman's conclusions or his proposed solutions but it is intellectually stimulating and a good medium for pointing out the hot spots America needs to address.
One bone of contention is that he is a bit fast and loose with the way he uses statistical data from other countries. Those numbers are typically self reported and almost never accurate. He uses them to make his points but take them with some healthy skepticism.
One piece of data that caught my attention was that: "50% of companies started in Silicon Valley are started by immigrants", which is the case, but not in the rouge solo entrepreneur fashion Friedman is portraying. Over half of silicon valley startups have someone who is an immigrant on their founding team with the caveat that immigrants comprise about 50% of the population in silicon valley. So his claim is accurate but not as strong a data point as he is portraying it to be.
I preferred the audio version of this book.
It is a good recap of history and what we need to do to get back to being a leader in the world!
Excellent! Great view of the world and the USA. Suggestions for change are workable and intelligent. I sent a copy to my Senators, my Representative, my Assemblyman and my son-in-law.
Thomas Friedman (The World is Flat) returns with Michael Mandelbaum to consider how America fell behind the rest of the world and to recommend how she might be able to get back on track. They consider education, the debt, denial of climate change and energy policy, and political failure in Washington. There is little new here for anyone who reads the newspapers and I wish Friedman and Mandelbaum had focused more on remedies and public policy than they did. The reading of Jason Culp is excellent.
This book is not only a civic lesson, interesting told, it is an application of what made us great applied to our future. Every citizen in the US should read it.
This is one of the most important books I have read in many years. The authors really seem to have a grasp on the issues that our society is facing and offer excellent insight into what needs to be done to get us back on track. I highly recommend this book for anyone who cares about where we are as a society, how we got there, and what we need to do.
The authors did not provide a single original thought. Their credentials are insufficient to write a book like this. They simply replicate facts (some hard, some soft) from more prominent, smarter people. While I agree with a lot of what the duo had to say, I have read all the books that are cited and not cited by the two. Skip this book; read Gladwell, Taleb and Carnegie.
I am a Tom Friedman fan. I like his writing style. I like his point of view. The authors are pushing some really important stuff that we need to address now, not eventually. They come down really hard on many of our leaders. They point out over and over and over and over and over again the problems and do come up with some solutions but like most medicine, the solutions don't taste good. They're good writers, so they end the book with nice positive, success stories. Don't be a wimp. Don't just jump to the end to hear the good stuff. Take your medicine like a good kid and you'll feel better at the end.
After reading and enjoying the World is Flat, this one just doesn't quite measure up. Possibly better if you had not read the prior work.