Yes, because it is thought provoking and wildly entertaining!
Much more personal.
Lots of laughter, but also very poignant.
First and foremost, Penn is an amazing storyteller. He captures your attention and does not let go until the story is finished. The worst part of this book is when it ends, because I truly felt as if him and I were sitting in my living room just talking. Truly insightful, and brilliantly voiced by Penn himself.
former nuclear scientist
I love Penn and Penn & Teller. I used to live in Vegas, and they sponsored all kinds of civic events. For example, I used to give blood 4-6 times per year, and if I went in December, I got two free P&T tix. I must have seen their show 4+ times and I loved it each time. My husband Tivos Bullsh!t and we often watch it together. I agree with Penn on a lot of things (not the full libertarianism, but a lot of his philosophy), and I think he is a genuinely cool and honest guy.
However, this combination memoir/screed is too much Penn for me all at once. With nothing to leaven his intensity, he curses too much (my husband won't believe that I think someone can curse *too much,* much less that someone curses more than I do, which is how extreme it is). Some of his memories are quite vulgar, especially the scuba diving incident. And he intersperses his ten "atheist suggestions" - his version of the ten commandments - through his reasoning for rational humanism and rambling, loosely interconnected stories that sometimes circle back and sometimes seem to get lost.
Penn is extreme in his views: very often, he loves someone and can compliment that person no matter what (the flaming makeup artist treats P&T like dirt and somehow earns Penn's respect); almost as often, he hates someone to the very core, like the pathetic magician who was so intimidated by Penn he tried to have him removed from the audience. He does outline some disagreements with people he likes, like Seth MacFarlane (my high school classmate!). This gets to be a little difficult after 4-5 hours. I probably should have listened to this in half hour chunks spaced out over many days, because I found myself zoning out sometimes and not rewinding to listen. Part of it may be that I had trouble connecting his vignettes. They weren't chronological, they were often only tangentally or subtly (reveal at the end!) related to the ten suggestions, and sometimes he would interrupt a story with another story that gave background to the first story, so I had to spend a lot of mental energy trying to keep track of what was going on.
As for presentation, it is classic Penn. If you're fan enough to buy this book, you know how he talks: loud and nonstop. He also does what I assume is a carnie trick of drawing breath halfway through a thought or sentence so that the audience stays with him. It's sort of human nature to wait to the end of a thought to turn away, and he doesn't pause at those points, only in the middle, which keeps you hooked. It exhausted me after a bit.
In all, I give it three stars because I did like a lot of the book, but two things dragged it down for me: the vulgarity (speaking as a lady with a fairly high tolerance for vulgar humor), and maybe envy? I feel like he was trying to use his own awesome life to show how wonderful life can be without religion if it is instead filled with love, family, and people. However, despite his frequent self-deprecation and heartfelt praise of those around him, sometimes it really just seemed like he was talking about how awesome his life has been (he's been in the vomit comet! he knows ZZ Top! he is friends with Wayne Newton! he has dated a ton of models/strippers/showgirls/porn stars/dancers/bartenders who could be models!). That was sort of off-putting.
If you are a big Penn fan, this is a big book of Penn. Penn is funny and awesome. If you don't mind vulgarity at all and can listen to hours of such a big personality, you will love this book. If you don't mind vulgarity in general but do have some sort of threshold to what you can tolerate, skip the scuba chapter.
It ranks very highly, I've only listened to a few, and I already enjoy listening to his stories.
Penn himself is a character, but outside of him, just the notion of "Vinny the Snot" is hilarious.
His passion comes across very well.
Oh man, I have no idea...
It's hilarious, it's inspiring and it's human. Penn addressed atheism succinctly in the first 4 sentences and then moves on to reinforce the obvious with so many entertaining and bizarre tales from his life. The book is unbelievably laugh out loud funny while being sincere to the topic. And as an audio performance, it may be my favorite...ever!
The chapter(s) he is asked by a (formerly) Hasidic Jew to experience his first non-kosher meal.
see my Headline
pure honesty and entertainment
This book is in the top two of audio books I have listened to.
I like contemplating god/less, my own personal morality, learning more about other cultures, Penn's life, and family, atheism, magic, I like that its not arrogant, but a personal tale of Penn navigating life and the universe and learning how to best be in the world for him.
It inspired me alot, and probably changed my life.
Arguably Hitchens: as far as why theology is problematic, but you will miss all the underwater sex, celebrity experiences, and magic and so on.
Extreme Elvis in the Swimming pool at Dawn in Vegas.
Penn talking about his mom and dad and sister, made me cry almost everytime.
I love you Penn!
Penn's stories are insightful, funny, and sincere. Well written and great to hear the stories told in Penn's voice.
Make it less about him and how "different" he is and more about his philosophical views, what shaped them and how it affects him today.
No, his voice is not the greatest to listen to.
Yes, there were some parts in which I laughed or nodded my head.
I felt that the title was a misrepresentation of the contents of the book.
I didn't read the print version. However, I don't see how the print edition could be better since Penn is the author and the narrator, he didn't allude to charts or pictures thou I would have liked some I'm sure... especially from his deep-water dives!
His journey into an early 80's San Francisco bath house...lmao
If willing to drink a beer with a guy was the only prerequisite for the presidency he's my candidate, only he doesn't drink so there goes that idea.
I've been a Penn Jillette fan for many years. I watch his Showtime show, read his columns in computer magazines over the years and have owned his movie Penn and Teller Get Killed on VHS. This book however should never have been published. The basic premise of the book is based on broken logic and the other "magical tales" are really stories about how feels bad for making fun of Siegfried and Roy by making fun of them all over again and how he donned a giggly, grab-ass homosexual stereotype to enter a gay club and couldn't figure out why "they" never approached him. To make matters worse, Penn decided to spice up practically every sentence with at least one F word. In all seriousness, if you were to remove every curse word from this audio book it would only be about 20 minutes long.