Excellent. There were times I was moved to tears with the stark reality and honesty of the story.
Blogger of accidental discoveries through books
The narration of this story was just right and the story itself was intriguing. I enjoyed it.
I found the book dissapointing, having expected more of the Booker Prize selection. It is a failed attempt, uneven in its literary and narrative quality. The plot is very improbable, umrealistic and unbelievable. Compared to the many other Booker Prize winning novel of the past, I found it inferior.
Say something about yourself!
How can a writer and a reader together make an aging man's musings about his failing memory be so compelling? I asked myself, as I continued listening to the very end. There is a mystery to be solved. Why DID his ex-girlfriend's mother bequeath him a small legacy and the diary of an old friend? And what does his ex mean by saying "you just don't get it", and a haunting line from the diary. The book felt really true about what it is like to be aging and find out things are not as you believed. Good one. Satisfying.
I am glad I listened to it on audio, because I'm not sure I could have finished this on the page. The narrator was fabulous, empathetic towards his character, thoughtful in his presentation and enhanced the experience. Having said that, I have had more satisfying audio experiences.
Oh yes, but with caveats. I'd say, 'It's an easy read and a fabulous mediation on adolescence - in fact I related very strongly to the teenagers though the era was far earlier than my own coming of age decade. However [insert things here about anally retentive old men, depiction of female characters etc]
No, but would seek others out.
I found the character of Adrian very resonant, I felt like I had met men like him before. I really found the first half compellingly real.
Sometimes it does a book (if not an author) a disservice to win a major award. I had in my head the whole time,
I wanted so much to like this book, but my plan didn't work. The writing is brilliant, but the female protagonist is ego-driven and self-involved in the extreme, and to what purpose? So there is a big family secret. So what? And why does that have to drive a person's life? The woman's posturing just adds up to a kind of narcissistic masochism, and it's annoying to read about. All she does is plunge the main character even more deeply into the post-adolescent angst from which he's come to be so relieved to finally escape.
Art historian, gardener, feminist. Read for language, characters, history, esp. 18th c. History in US, France, GB, SE Asia, Caribbean.
the fallibility of memory
The author, main character who tries to remember his past, but is is not sure of it. I could empathize with his plight.
I have not listened to Richard Morant before, but I enjoyed his crisp diction and precise reading that seemed to suit the autobiographical narrative.
I listened to this pretty quickly. I usually like to listen to a book two or three times to really get it, especially if it is well written and there is a lot to think about.
"History is that certainty produced at the point where the imperfections of memory meets the inadequacies of documentation" also "History is the bragging of the victor tempered by the delusions of the defeated". This is a wonderfully written and narrated book of Tony Webster's ordinary life recounted when he reaches retirement. It is intruiging and it keeps you guessing right until the last page with an unexpected ending! I will certain seek and read another Julian Barnes novel! Deserving of its Booker prize!
This book deserved the Booker Man Award it received. Very thought provoking with an interesting twist at the end.
Eclectic mixer of books of my youth and ones I always meant to read, but didn't.
These days we are all skeptical. This includes our perception of literary awards. Once upon a time, a prestigious award like the MAN Booker (then the Booker) would have been a strong recommendation to read and own a novel. Now I sometimes regard it as a forewarning! Accordingly, the last two awards of that famous prize have been a pleasant return to the old form.
In this deservedly praised novel Barnes achieves the rare feat of capturing a time and place. Actually, it's not so much A time or A place as capturing the state of mind that, I suspect, 90% of his listeners have visited or inhabited sometime in their lives. That place and time seemed very familiar to me although the plot line and my experience is quite different. I think this is a rare gift of insight.
I won't delve into the plot because its unfolding is a pleasure, a surprise and a joy. It made me wince and smile, in turns. Also, the book is blessedly short. Oh for the return of the short novel. Bravo!
The late Richard Morant's reading was very good, too. It completely suited the text and the principals. It took me a while to stop thinking of Julian Clary (because Morant has, for some reason, a Surrey accent), but that wasn't much of a distraction.