That the main character would be more emotional.
That the references to the books she reads would be more apparent in how she thought and was effected by them before the end.
I would have had a point or more where emotions bubbled up regarding what had happened, where she relives it completely in memory, and have this be a turning point where she begins to melt into herself. I realize that this was there subtly, and it did happen, it was sweet and not as informative as this hungry-for-what-happened-ears would have liked and there was quite a bit of foreshadowing and untold story plot so that it could be unraveled as the main character unraveled. At the end, there is a great scene where she beats her antagonist, and this is the most interactive moment with the plot that the story surrounds itself with, I would have liked more of it, as otherwise, the day in and out of the subtly progressing into womanhood teen was a bit on the not so eventful side. It was a peek into her daily mind.
I also think it is a sweet book, I appreciate what the character had gone through and her perspective of how she saw and her strength at being herself and doing what she needs to do with her life. I think this is great for any young to old woman finding herself. It is a book that shall remain in my memory in the subtlety more than largely eventful. I teared at her receiving the love and acceptance from her new support network who appreciated what she is about. It is what women need (such as me, thus the tears).
It ranks as one of the best books I've listened to all year due to the spectacular narration of Katherine Kellgren. The story is also worthy of all the awards it has won, as it kept me riveted with its fascinating world and characters.
I loved the strong female lead and the world she lives in, with its magic working in the daily life of a teen girl living in 1979.
I felt this was truly a performance. I felt carried away to another world with her Welsh accent and her stunning portrayal of Mori the title character, an avid reader of science fiction..
Sometimes, the story dragged on a bit when Mori spends so much time discussing the books she's reading. I wanted the story to move faster.
I'm64 years old and a retired design engineer. Rreading audio books since 1954...59 years. Strong interests are music and sf/fantasy, all of which I create myself and enjoy from others.
Without question... the audio version should be the only "allowed" publishing... :-)
Not applicable... the whole idea was the book.
I don't want to telegraph anything... but this book builds to its ending the way a great book should.
I am not good at capsulizing an entire book... especailly one specifically *about* words... into a few words... or a "tag line". For anyone to do that with this book, it would be insufficent and take away from its magic.
The reader took my breath away. She not only read the book as if she understood every word almost as if she had written them herself, but as if she understood every one of the many books this story mentions and precis's in its very illuctable way.
I have never heard any other books read by Katherine Keligher. However, I have been listening to talking books since 1954, so I have no idea how she isn't among the few dozen pure favorites I have come to love. If it means anything... which it most certainly actually does... I will be reading every other thing she has ever done. Soon."
There is an almost magical simultaneity here... but then, that is what magic and this book is about. I recently listened to another book just out on Audible... a book by Orson Scott Card (Earth Unaware). At the end he metnions his favorite authors and that he loves reading audible books. His notes sounded as if I had written them myself. I love Sci-Fi and Fantasy, the bigger, the more epoch, the more amazing ... the more I like it. He seemed to echo my very thoughts about this. The precise authors he named are somehow my absolute favorite authors as well. He even put a special and unchanging place of honor for J.R.R. Tolkien and his Lord Of The Rings. It was uncanny to say the least. Of course, I want you to read everything Mr. Card has ever written so you will appreciate that book as much as I did.. and thereby, hopefully, appreciate his short wonderfully "telling" note about his favorite authors. What he wrote could have been a prescient revue of "Among Others".... whether he has read it yet or not... I have no idea.
In any case, if you are in the same realm as he and me in our love of The Lord Of The Rings... and Science Fiction/Fatasy overall... then you will simply love this book. It isn't big, and epoch and it didn't seem like something that would be anything other than a nice read... coming from that full depth of grand fiction and Universes that live in the pages of the best SF and Fantasy. I just didn't think it would blow me away... yet somehow it did. Maybe it did so because it sneakily and smoothly integrated the author's same love of it all into the main thread of the book itself... and it does it magically.
I wasn't quite sure all the way through just how much I really loved it, and wondered a time or two just why it was holding my interest so fast... until the end came. It was nothing short of one of the best passages and conclusions that I have ever read (or heard...) and remember that note about me listening to audio books since I was 5 years old (circa 1954). If you're counting and calculating... and I am now that I'm thinking about it and writing this revue... that is thousands and thousands of audio books. Yes, you can take it to the bank... this is a great piece of science fiction/fantasy and along with the phenomenal reader, this is one credit you will think very well spent. The Lord Of The Rings and all the wonderful books beside it notwithstanding, but included, this little snip of a book fits in and fits in well.
The only thing I could wish for you to make this book the pleasure that it was for me... is that you could somehow *be* me, with my memories of the past 58 years of reading and listening to audio books before you start it. Too bad.... cant make that happen for you... but if your love of The Lord Of The Rings and the genre of SF and Fantasy, and of reading itself... is even one millionth that of mine... this book will bring you great joy.
And if OSC has somehow not yet listened to this marvelous little production... which I highly doubt... he at least won't have to write a review... my bet is he would agree word for word and thought for thought with this one. I saved him some work. -Esak
This book seemed to take a very long time to make it through. I kept checking the timer of the player and thinking “2 hours and 30 minutes? How can that be?” I was thinking this book was about magic in modern societies, but I ended up believing this is a diary of a schizophrenic. The further I got into it, the more she sounded like the Chief from “One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest”. Truly, the 200+ hours of the Games of Thrones series moved more briskly. I will never again complain that Peter F. Hamilton’s Void series was too verbose. This was the longest 10 hours of my life. If you only have 10 hours to live, this is definitely the book. Not only will it make those 10 hours seem much longer, but it will make you want to “cross over” so it will end.
Book on books
Possibly, but the reviews would have to be rave worthy
Picture a book as a balloon. It gets blown up as the story progresses. Some are those long, narrow balloons that take a lot of lung power to get going. Some are normal balloons that fill with air, get tied off and stuck on a poster. Some get filled with helium and float you away. This could have been the later, but instead it was a great big balloon that someone let go of at the last moment and it just blew all over the room making an obnoxious sound.
Characters were personable. Felt like you could have a cup of tea (or water!) with them. Plot seemed to be leading up to something big, and then blah. Can't even say the balloon was popped, because that would at least imply a surprise or shock. This was just a let down. My only hope is that Ms Walton tries again, she'll remember to use helium and let the sucker float us away.
Narration was lovely. Could listen to Katherine Kellgren's voice anytime!
No, the pacing is too slow.
Authentic, tedious, sing-song
I fail to understand the critical acclaim that has been given to this work. While it IS my first listen with this author and narrator, I found the work to be concerned with daily minutiae
that was of little interest to me. A tedious listen.
The superb performance of narrator Katherine Kellgren, and the wonderfully understated humor of the writer couldn't help the lack of a strong plot and a convincing ending.