My review of this book was going to be blah blah blah geeky sci-fi lit comment blah blah blah teenage girl angst. Blah blah blah geeky sci-fi lit comment. Blah blah blah WTF!
There are times when this book feels brilliant. But at about halfway through I started to wonder how in the world this book won both the Hugo and Nebula. I can only imagine how weak the competition must have been for this book you have won.
I'm giving this book 2 out of 5 stars. I feel that is being nice because there are times that this book tries really hard shine and has really cool references. But its lack of plot development kills everything else that it does cool.
Katherine Kellgren has a wondorful range and her reading of this is the best part of the book.
Sure. It's an enjoyable listen and a good story. Kellgren's outstanding performance really set the pace for me. It's the kind of book that gives me a better apprecation for sci fi and the magic of a story itself.
Yes, and again after that... It's haunting, captivating, sweet and painfully real.
When the main character reveals what happened to her sister.
Unfortunately, the narrator was occasionally hard to understand because of her strong accent. Once my ear became 'tuned' this was less of a problem, but it was frustrating at times very early on.
No; I wanted to stretch it out because I enjoyed it so much.
This amazing book can be read on two levels almost all the way through: a completely realist book about a girl's imagination compensating for tragedy and disability; or a fantasy story about ghosts and fairies. Either way, or both, it's beautifully observed, wry, whimsical and wonderful. My only qualm is that the ending felt too sudden and a little contrived, as though the writer simply decided to finish as quickly and efficiently as possible (throwing most of the ambiguity away). Still, even with that caveat, this is one of the best books I've listened to all year.
Illegitimi non carborundum
I almost gave one star only to the story, because there was barely a story. Frankly I found the diary format annoying - it made the minimal storyline seem to drag. But the character development merits an additional star or two. I'm actually a little surprised at the gushing of some reviewers, especially those who read the paper or e-book, but it did win a Hugo, so maybe I'm missing something. I suspect some Audible readers let the lovely accents and voices Katherine Kellgren brought to life sway them in favor of a really very weak and incomplete plotline. The story was intriguing but never very clearly fleshed out - I found myself left with a lot of questions, and I'm not exactly thick-skulled. Ever read a book, not been 100% sold all the way through but thought it might get better because of some good writing? Then you get to the end and you're like, "That's IT?!! I wasted all that time on THAT??" and feel totally let down? Yeah, this is one of THOSE books. I have NO idea why it won a Hugo. It would be worthy of a Young Adult genre award perhaps, for its excellent insight into the mind of a 15 year old female "other". But great sci-fi this is not, with all due respect to Ms. Walton, who I'm certain is more talented than I personally found reflected in this book.
If your sole entertainment is reading books and comparing authors, then you might like this. You might like the main character. You really have to have read a lot of science fiction to even catch some of the references in this diary.
Waiting for something to happen? Keep waiting, because nothing really does. Oh, wait. She reads another "SF" book and compares it previous stories.
While used too frequently, her attitude to have people afraid of her, rather than sorry for her,tells you this is a strong character
Idea that regular use of common items makes the items "comfortable" with you is intriguing
Finished, took effort
I love paranormal books, urban fantasy or paranormal romance, sci fi as well. A good mystery will make me happy as well.
Yes, because there were so many references to sci fi books that I would like to check them out personally.
This is truly a one of a kind type of book.
She brings the story to life with her accent. She makes it seem so real.
Yes and I did it in only a couple of sittings
This is a story of a 15 year old girl Welsh girl who loves sci-fi books and finds solace in them. It takes place in 1979-80 and is written as a diary. It is sort of a sci-fi book, sort of a paranormal book. It is very hard to actually classify this. The story is very engrossing and never boring. The characters are very well fleshed out. The narrator is absolutely perfect for this book. The sci-fi references are fun if you like older sci-fi especially. She is not a childish girl but a young woman made to grow up quickly because of circumstances in her life. I am certainly going to read more of this authors books.
What makes this audio book better than the print version is that the main character, from who's perspective the book is written, is a girl from Wales who moves to England and gets put in a boarding school - and the narrator's accent changes gradually from Welsh to posh English and the story progresses!!
You don't get an effect like that from the print version.
How magic changes not just the future but the past.
I loved how the girl in the story gradually became attached to the father and grandfather she never knew.
I love technology, reading, music, and shoes (not necessarily in that order.)
I recommended this book to my book club based on the reviews, I don’t know if they will ever forgive me. I think I was the only one who finished it. Although I enjoyed the narrator, it took the book forever to get to the point. To me, there wasn’t much substance. I felt like I was listening to a chronicle of all the science fiction books every written and caught myself wonder whether or not I had read each book mentioned. Perhaps that was the point of it all, who knows? It was OK to read on my own, but not a good book club selection. GBC members please forgive me :-)
I read speculative fiction, YA, mysteries, entertaining nonfiction, & occasionally, heavier literature. I want it well written & literate.
Talking about the most memorable moments would risk spoilers
Finding out what Welsh sounds like when I can't travel there was wonderful, and greatly added to the story
A fascinating journey with one of the most memorable of literary young people
Have you read Jo Walton? I just finished "Among Others" and am very excited to find she has written a bunch of other books. "Among Others" is set in South Wales. The main character is fifteen, and a survivor of something horrible in her past, something not explained at the beginning of the book. She also talks to fairies, but the reader is unsure if they are really there or the product of a traumatized mind. Her main character, Mor, is wonderful. She is fifteen, brilliant, troubled, geeky, and obsessed with Science Fiction (Meg from "Wrinkle in Time" combined with Holden Caulfield), and the SF part is wonderful because the story is a frame for lists, discussion, and debate about books that I read during my first love affair with the genre, as the book is set in 1979. I loved this book, but it had something in common with one of my other favorite books, "Swamplandia". I think the author was propelled by her fabulous characters, and fabulous world, and didn't know how to end her story, so the ending was somewhat abrupt, a tad deus ex machina. But I will forgive her that because it was a fabulous journey. I listened to this book, and found the reader, Katherine Kellgren, to be wonderful. I had no idea what a Welsh accent would sound like (my kids were enormously amused by my struggle with the language in "The Dark Is Rising" series) so I was fascinated with the lilt and nuance of the language, but the aural book was also frustrating because I so wanted a written record of all the books mentioned and discussed. I should have used the note taking and bookmarking features, but I was too anxious to find out what happens.