Awful narration. HIRE SCOTT BRICK!
Random voices...all bad...all off.
After 200+ hours I,d like to see some dramatic catacysmic climax, but all we get is the sudden deaths of any characters you'd give a damn about.
A total disappointment. Verbose, boring, lacks direction, a poor excuse to take my money. I want a refund. Compared to the other three books this is a disaster of literary proportions.
Roy Dotrice does only three voices in this series.
1) Old Irish Male (All Male voices)
2) Old Irish Female (All Female voices)
3) Leprechaun (Children)
The Narration is extremely frustrating and ruins the experience for me. One character to the next sounds as if they are 100 years old with strep throat. HBO did a fantastic job and this is such a departure. Don't waste your credits and buy the book instead.
all the fluff
to much drama
After audio reading all 5 books went back and reread the first 3 books a 2nd time.
If the first three books were written in the same slogging drawn out style that books 4 and 5 have been written, this series would have flopped hard. I've read dozens of series that started getting poor reviews half way through and I really couldn't understand why. This is the first series (fantasy or otherwise) that I can honestly say has frustrated me to the point of quitting on it.
My opinion is that R.R. was more interested in his story and characters in 1-3. No character was safe from being neutralized or eliminated in this "game of thrones" being played but he did it with care and for the plots best interest. In 4-5 he seemed to go away from good plot and good writing to settle for the shocking, the crude, the gruesome, the sexually explicit, and random violence. Does he think that is why his books sold? How many times must I read the line "beads of water trickled down her breasts" for example? (Boring after the 5th time in a few hours of reading.) Yes all of that was in 1-3 but it was used as spice in a good plot, not the plot itself.
Yes R.R., I'm sure it is a lot of work and toil to create and continue this complex of a story. I'm sure you want to maximize your dollar out of this creation of yours and so have extended it out and watered it down with weak side stories. There has been little to no advance in the plot since the end of book 3. I think it is due to lack of effort, not the lack of places the story can move.
Finally, it is your story to do with what you will, but we the fans have invested time, money, and emotion into this series. It has promised quality in the first 3 books and you have taken advantage of our loyalty and commitment to finish this series by giving us 4-5 (which are clearly 'make-money' books). I'm sure life is real busy with offshoot endeavors that need not be mentioned here, but please return to what made you a loved and successful writer - care for your story as a whole and your readers.
Nothing happens!! Forty some-odd hours of no real story progression. Its clear now that Martin is just dragging the story out to sell more books. I have listened to all of 'the song of ice and fire' series and i keep waiting for the epic war with the Others to happen and i never does. Really any battle or action would be great but this book is just people sitting around agonizing about what they should or shouldn't do. Then he'll just kill off a main character! Why have that story line span five books only to kill that person off in a meaningless manner?? It's official I will never read or listen to another book by Martin. Not that it will matter he wont have a book out for another ten years.
The Narration is horrid. Roy turns every female voice into a raspy old woman. It is borderline unbearable to listen to. Do your self a favor and just read the book if your really wanting to continue with the series. Save your credit for something that doesn't make you want to quit listing to audio books.
I love books!
Don't get me wrong, I'm an avid ASOIF fan and have read/listened to the series several times thus far. But this book 5 A Dance with Dragons was a bit boring, the characters disappointing, and nothing really getting resolved or moving along. If I would guess I would think that George was not quite sure where this series is going. Maybe his a bit preoccupied with graphic novels, short stories, TV show, etc. This book is just OK but when compared to the previous books in the series I was left wanting and empty. It is however a must read if you love the series but I would have felt equally filled with an abridged version of this one.
First I would like to comment on the narrator. I didn't think John Lee was bad in the fourth book, as I have liked his reading from other books very much. That said, I did miss Roy Dotrice's very recognizable characters from the first three books. It is not in error that Roy Dotrice was recognized with a Guiness Record for his work on The Game of Thrones. I was at first very happy that he would be returning for the fifth book. I would like to point out that I started listening to these books just a few months ago and listened to all in quick succession. Therefore I am can very well say that the quality of the last books narration was underpar for Mr.Dotrice. Very familiar character voices were not familiar, male or female. Although Daenarys' voice for example is an oft remarked example of a voice that suffered.
Now for the story itself. I guess it was ok, but not on its own merits. It carries forward mainly because of the weight of all the previous books, especially, the first trilogy of books, so masterfully written. And although Martin's prose is unmatched, it just seemed like he got lost in this book, or maybe there was a lack of editorial control. No one would say Martin is shy to kill off his characters, but maybe he was when it would be time to kill off a few chapters in this book. In summary, the book is ok, but only because we want so badly to see what happens to the characters we connected to in the first books.
I enjoyed the first 2 books. Engaging characters, well written, great reader, fascinating world. But by this book I feel like I am walking the Bataan death march. All the characters I found engaging are dropping like flies. So many new characters and houses I have battle fatigue. On and on it goes and when will it end...and who will be left standing? I think the author is riding a money train to nowhere and I want to get off.
This may actually be a good story, however the whining, mewling voices that the narrator has chosen for almost every character makes it impossible to listen to. I muscled through the first few books, but these voice choices have gotten more and more annoying, and in this book became rapidly intolerable: I could not even finish section one. My 3 year old whines less annoyingly than any of the characters in this narration: extremely painful to try to listen to.