Even after listening, I'm not sure that the second thread-line of story about the tabloids was really that important. In the description, we (or at least I) are lead to believe that this story shaped the tabloids we know today. The connect, while presented to a be a true and valid one, isn't as strong as I had originally thought. The story focused more on the actual murder with the tabloids (it felt) as an aside.In addition, I really thought that the book dragged about 3/4 of the way through, and I was just grinding it out to get the the END! I think the author could've abbreviated some of the details to keep things moving. That being said, it's a very good book and I thoroughly enjoyed listening to it in my car. I would recommend it; just don't expect a fast-paced murder mystery.
Story doesn't seem to be very well written
I'm not sure any cuts would help.
Had a hard time finishing this audio.
This was not a bad book, but not a great book either. It tells the story of a fascinating murder case and of the era of yellow journalism wars. That part of the book was quite interesting although I do feel that there was miscarriage of justice as Augusta Nack should have been executed also.
The most interesting bits of the story are the search for the identify of the victim once various body parts come to the surface and then the trial. The running back and forth and the dirty tricks of the various reporters and the papers were fascinating, but in part went on too long and too much was made of a lot of events.
The incompetence of the prosecutor was astonishing. He went on to prosecute someone where if he had revealed all the evidence he would have lost. Also it shows the sloppy forensic work of the time and how little forensics actually played in the case, although if a full discussion of the wounds on the body had come out in court, Mrs. Nack would have been found guilty. The fact that the prosecutor cut a deal with her so he could get at least one conviction shows the low quality of courts at the time especially in a major case.
The narrator was rather a monotone, although in the part of the trial the narrator was excellent in portraying the defense attorny Howe, who was the leading defense attorney of the time. I found it hard to believe that he lost the case. However, Victorian sensibilities played a role here -- and it is noteworthy that women were excluded from the court after a discussion of how the identification was made, despite the lack of a head.
However, large sections of the books simply go on too long. The whole ending of book was dragged out to the point I stopped listening to it. The writing was on the whole a bit too wordy and an editor should have cut it down in length. There was a lot of unnecessary detail which was dragged out beyond their merit.
Athena Cordelia Smith
This book tells more than just the story of a shocking murder it also tells the beginning of Yellow Journalism which led to the tabloids and paparazzi we have today. All in all a interesting look into history
Different voices and accents were well done. In addition to recounting an infamous murder, included the history of " yellow" journalism and the rivalry between Hearst and Pulitzer
What a story! Learned more New York history and was riveted by the events of the crime. Loved how it was all tied up at the end with what happened to all the persons involved. Highly recommend.
Anyone who is interested in listening to true crime novels will enjoy this story, just an abridged version.
Ill give another one a try, this story was just a tad thin.
I prefer someone who just reads in one voice. Some of his voices just sound dumb.
The crime was macabre.
This story could have been told in half the time. If I hear the name Guldensuppe one more time, Ill snap.
Non Fiction Listener but huge Liar in my regular life
The narration was hard to take seriously and made me doubt the truth of the story or at least the implied importance of it
I would keep an open mind
I am a fan of more of a reading style and not the voice acting used here
The idea sounded good and I previewed but I did tire of the style of narration after an hour our so